Columnists

Opinion: Oscar Pistorius - what's race got to do with it?

Khaya Dlanga

The case against Oscar Pistorius was bound to take a racial turn. And Henke Pistorius's comments are just the beginning, writes Khaya Dlanga.

The Oscar Pistorius case was featured on may front pages of both local and international papers. (Felix Karlsson, M&G)

Oscar Pistorius's father made some incendiary comments when he said that the ANC-led government does not protect white people, which is why they have to arm themselves.

The complexities of race in South Africa have been exposed once again. Who is the greater victim of crime? Pistorius's father suggested – without any facts to back his comments – that white people were greater victims. He was only supported by emotion. He reminded me of a parent who blames the school after their son is expelled for being a bully.

One of the debates the Pistorius case brought about was violence against women, which is where the Minister of Women, Children and People with Disabilities, Lulu Xingwana, entered the fray. She told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation: "Young Afrikaner men are brought up in the Calvinist religion believing that they own a woman, they own a child, they own everything and therefore they can take that life because they own it." She later apologised for these comments. This shows South Africa is a truly racialised nation and it will take us some time to get over it. Pistorius's case is going to open one debate after another about how we see ourselves as citizens of this country.

When Hilton Botha, the investigating officer in the case, was called to the stand during the bail hearing of Pistorius, we came to realise that he made one blunder after another. His appearance before the court turned out to be a massive embarrassment for the country after the world's media reported every word he said. The defence stopped short of calling him incompetent, as did magistrate Desmond Nair. The world did not care that Hilton Botha was a white man. It just saw an incompetent police force in South Africa.

What does his race have to do with anything, some will ask? If Botha were a black man, I have no doubt we would have heard murmurs that he was advanced in his career because of black economic empowerment. We would have heard about how the government keeps pushing people to positions even though they are not qualified to do the job, simply because they are "the right colour". The suggestion that black people get jobs even when they cannot do the jobs would have lived on for a long time. And some might have been thrilled that the international media was there to see it. We would have heard words like, "cadre deployment" and "employment equity" – all not so subtle hints suggesting that unqualified black people are employed in jobs they cannot handle.

Botha is an Afrikaans-speaking white man. He has the good fortune of being presumed competent because he happens to be a white man. Black people in senior positions are generally presumed incompetent until proper evidence has been demonstrated. Do not think that they are presumed incompetent by just white people; black people make the same assumptions too. I have even heard of cases where black people would rather go to a white doctor than a black one because they assume the white person knows more. It happens.

But it should not happen. 

To paraphrase Martin Luther King Jr: I have a dream that man's competence shall not be judged by the colour of his skin but by his ability to do the work. The skin of a person does not define his competence or lack thereof. 

This is the reason many black people, who are good at their jobs, feel that they need to work twice as hard as a white person just to prove that they are as good as a white person. This is not very different from what women face; according to a McKinsey study men are promoted based on potential, while women are promoted on accomplishments. It's probably the case with black people too.

We come from a society that is used to having black people as housekeepers, gardeners and tea ladies. It is no wonder then that it is taking us so long to adjust to the fact that all South Africans can be capable and competent, no matter what colour. Some day the scars from our past, which cause some to doubt the capabilities of another simply because of their race, will be healed. But until then, we must continue with legislation which enforces companies to promote diversity so that people can see competence is not a colour, nor is it owned by a single race and lacking in others. 

When the world looks at South Africa, it does not look at colour, it looks at us as one country. We should remember that too. South Africans forget that we are one people who like to look at each other as "those people".


Topics In This Section

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus