To enjoy the full Mail & Guardian online experience: please upgrade your browser
Michael Patrick Welch
30 Apr 2015 13:19
Smoke-free: Bourbon Street in the French Quarter of New Orleans is a popular tourist attraction with plenty of restaurants and clubs. (Samantha Kaplan/Bloomberg)
As of last week, you can no longer legally smoke a cigarette inside a bar in the world’s drinking capital, New Orleans, Louisiana.
Perhaps you gasped upon reaching the very end of that
sentence. City after city have dealt Big Tobacco the harsh blow of banning
But other cities don’t lure in tourist dollars by aggressively
advertising a “do watcha wanna”, laissez
les bon temps rouler, attitude.
“You just opened up a can of whupass on lots of neighbours in the city,” says Nick Scramuzza, one of three owners of Lost Love Lounge in
New Orleans’s Marigny neighbourhood. Scramuzza doesn’t look forward to the new
noise complaints he’ll receive when half of his customers end up spending their
time five feet outside his door (the legally mandated distance) enjoying that
holy trinity of smoking, drinking and carrying on.
Nor is he necessarily in favour of the government bossing
everyone around in such a sweeping manner. “But I wake up with a hangover just
from working around the smoke,” Scramuzza shrugs. “So I’m excited about the
As the Wall Street Journal recently reported,
the New Orleans city government has, since Hurricane Katrina, begun trying to
prune some of its cultural shrubbery, turn down the volume a bit. Abetted by
uptight neighbourhood groups, the city has begun policing bars and nightclubs
more strictly, while at the same time fighting a protracted battle to implement
a new “noise ordinance” (read: music ordinance) while also debating an
impending comprehensive zoning ordinance for the entire city that, to some
residents’ dismay, creates more permissive music laws in some instances.
“This is just the wrong time for them to have pursued something like this,” rails William Walker, another of Lost Love Lounge’s
owners who, for reasons of personal choice and personal inconvenience, hates
the anti-smoking law. “Forcing people outside the bar to smoke is going to
exacerbate the tension that’s already there. And when they look to fix that
problem, what they will say is ‘no go-cups’, which the neighbourhood groups are
already working on …”
Lost Love Lounge lives in a relatively quiet residential-seeming
neighbourhood — as do many of New Orleans’s best bars and some of its live
music spots. This neighbourly co-existence is a big part of what makes New Orleans different, and charming like some alcoholic Sesame Street. Recently
though, this unique social contract has become unacceptable for those they call
nimbys (Not in My Backyard), and the fate of New Orleans’s musical personality
feels at stake.
Martha Wood lives beside a loud bar that hosts live music.“The bar was one of the deciding factors in me buying the house, so I won’t
ever complain about the noise,” says Wood, who also manages the St Roch Tavern,
a live music bar which, following a series of noise issues in 2013 — including
complaints about the loud smokers outside — became one of New Orleans’s first
ever watering holes legally disallowed from serving drinks to go.
A grey areaThe city also mandated St Roch a closing time, like a
regular bar in a regular city. “Now any small infraction could get us shut
down,” says Wood. “We recently installed a smoke eater to help with the smoke
because we can’t open the doors at night because of the ‘noise’. There is so much
grey area in this law that they can, and will, use against us.”
The Maple Leaf club where ReBirth Brass Band made its name
playing every Tuesday night, went smoke-free voluntarily in 2014. As did club
d.b.a. on Frenchmen Street, where artists such as singer John Boutte had been
demanding smoke-free nights.
“A lot of the performance venues were already starting to show that consideration to performers, so I wish the city would have just let
that happen instead of forcing the ban into every corner bar that doesn’t host
music,” says Zalia BeVille, a smoker, and manager of live entertainment venue
All Ways Lounge, which went smoke-free two years back because, she says, “the
horn players and the chanteuses, they asked us for it”.
Luckily, All Ways has an outdoor patio, unlike Lost Love
Lounge, whose third owner, Geoff Douville, also a working musician, loves the
ban; he’d previously felt forced to live with smoke to keep his bar financially
viable. “There’s no way I could have banned smoking in my bar without it being
a rule throughout the whole city,” says Douville. “People act like I have that
choice, as a business owner. But if I make that rule, they walk down the block
to a bar with smoking. So I need it to be uniformed across the board for
Unlike most other cities, New Orleans also allows gambling —
not only at our Fair Grounds racetrack and Harrah’s casino (a major job creator
in New Orleans), but also in the many corner bars hosting video poker machines.
Harrah’s sued the city recently for a partial exemption in a class-action suit
along with several dozen French Quarter bars.
A restaurant in the French Quarter of New Orleans (John Moore/Getty Images/AFP)
Harrah’s company claimed to
Nola.com that the smoking ban could cut yearly sales tax collections by
$500 000, and jeopardise the $3.6-million in gambling money the state sends to
the city to cover some safety and sanitation. State law mandates the first
$1.8-million toward cleanup and cops just around the casino, before the next
$60-million goes toward a state education fund. Essentially the smoking ban
could make Louisiana kids dumber, they say.
A great business opportunityMany small business owners also fear smoke-free revenue loss. Smoker Neil Timms owns the Crown and Anchor, an old-school English pub
across the river from the French Quarter in Algiers. Timms met the smoking ban
before, in England. “Back home in Coventry, every pub where I was a regular
closed within a year of the smoking ban,” remembers Timms of the ban, begun in
2007. To avoid the same fate, he’s spending money to build a patio.
Lost Love’s Douville, though, feels the ban to be a great
business opportunity. “The amount of latent people who would enjoy coming out
to our bar, with our food, but would never come because they didn’t want to
smell like smoke for the next seven days — we’re now an option for all those
Councilwoman LaToya Cantrell, who introduced and pushed the
ban, begs to differ: “The responsibility is on the bar owner to keep your
clientele respectful outside your establishment as well,” she states flatly.
“The owners and bartenders need to tell them to go have a smoke but be
respectful to their communities. The idea that we can’t have clean air because
it will cause noise problems is ridiculous. It can be a win-win. I think it’s
about communication, and creating partnerships between the communities and the
Cantrell does acknowledge our city’s uniqueness in terms of
a smoking ban. “How is New Orleans different from the rest of the country?
Well, we’re four times the national average in health disparity, and the
majority of people here are African American. New Orleans is also the only
place known as ‘The City That Care Forgot’,” she says.
“New Orleans needs to finally stand up and say ‘we care about our people in way we haven’t before.’ The most vulnerable people who are
working in [smoky] conditions, these citizens are the backbone of our
hospitality industry, which drives the economy in the state of Louisiana.
“New Orleans is [also] going through billions in
infrastructure improvements in our hospital system,” she adds, a nod to the
city’s post-Katrina economic growth spurt, “so it just seems misleading to talk
about the healthcare industry, and how it’s growing, and the quality of
healthcare improving, when we’re still letting our people work in these
Bring on the banShe puts the argument to rest, adding: “New Orleans is also
unlike other places because you do have the option of taking your drink outside
with you when you go out to smoke your cigarette.”
And what of already vulnerable bars like St Roch Tavern? “If
[those being loud outside] are not the patrons of the bar,” says Cantrell, “the
bar should call the police.”
Many worried that the already strained New Orleans police
department (to put it politely) didn’t need any part in policing smokers. So,
the health department will handle bar warnings and fines. Nola.com reported
that: “The bartender, manager, or owner is required to tell them to stop
[smoking] and, if they refuse, ask them to leave.” Bar customers are encouraged
to: “Come fill out a form or call 311 [and] to include date-and time-stamped
photographs documenting illegal smoking.”
Geoff Douville is not worried and says bring on the ban.
“Watch: the nosy neighbours who complain about the noise now are gonna be the
same ones wanted the smoking ban to begin with.”
In the end, Douville shares councilwoman Cantrell’s win-win
optimism. “Of course they’re gonna complain,” he accepts. “But it doesn’t mean
they’re gonna win.” — © Guardian News & Media, 2015
Create Account | Lost Your Password?