Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

‘The poor are becoming impatient’

The border between South Africa and Zimbabwe should be ”comprehensively” abolished, Methodist Bishop Paul Verryn told academics at the University of the Witwatersrand on Wednesday.

”In exactly the same way we pulled down the fences in 1994 and found that instead of restricting, it enabled. Instead of closing the economy, it opened up much wider trust in the economy,” Verryn told a colloquium on violence and xenophobia.

He said foundation for what had gone wrong lay in the labelling of vulnerable people as ”illegal aliens” and their criminalisation.

He pointed out that the xenophobic attacks were not on the rich Zimbabweans, but the poor Zimbabweans, ”the ones in the shacks, the ones in the streets …”.

The attacks were a warning to the community about what it did with its resources, said Verryn.

”Resources in this country belong to the entire nation and need to be shared in a way that ensures that every human being knows that they are of value and they have human dignity that cannot be alienated from them.

”And so you have this phenomenon [xenophobia] having wind in our community because the poor are becoming recklessly impatient.”

While the first xenophobic attack he experienced was in Braamfontein three years ago, the government had known of the problem for at least four years.

Each and every South African had to ”scrutinise profoundly” the attitude that ”breeds such vicious violence”, said Verryn.

The system of values at play was inconsistent with the country’s Constitution, many of whose words, he believed, were ”written from personal experience of alienation in your motherland, of humiliation by people over and over again”.

Other academics speaking at the meeting said inequality was at the heart of the xenophobia sweeping the country.

The government claimed to have done more to address poverty since 1994 than any other developing country and indeed had, said economics Professor Stephen Gelb

”Poverty and inequality are not the same thing and cannot be treated by politicians as if they are,” he said.

The problem of poverty was extremely deep and intractable.

”The problem of inequality is equally deep and intractable.”

While it was clear that the government had addressed poverty, it was ”equally clear inequality has not been addressed at all”.

Inequality was ”extreme” and had actually worsened since 1994, Gelb pointed out.

Inequality could only be addressed by the transfer and building of assets such as education, skills, land and houses.

Only asset ownership would persuade people they had prospects and hope for the future.

”The government hasn’t succeeded at all in asset building and transfer.”

On their way home

Kenya is to repatriate 64 people from South Africa following anti-immigrant violence, an official said Wednesday.

”So far 64 Kenyans who have sought assistance are actually on their way back to Kenya as from tomorrow [Thursday],” Assistant Foreign Minister Richard Onyonka told reporters.

He said the government has set aside funds to help all of its nationals in South Africa who might want to return home. As many as 20 000 Kenyans currently live in South Africa.

Tens of thousands of mainly Zimbabwean and Mozambican immigrants have been forced out of their homes since the onset of xenophobic attacks, which have so far left 56 people dead.

Meanwhile, a group of mostly Somalis and Ethiopians clashed with police on Wednesday when they threw stones at a relief workers’ vehicle bringing aid to an emergency relief camp in Akasia, north of Tshwane, South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC) news reported.

Spokesperson Willie Baloyi reportedly said metro police had to use rubber bullets to disperse the angry group. One police officer was injured when his vehicle was stoned.

The group demanded that all relief had to come from United Nations relief organisations and refused aid from the South African government.

They allegedly cut a pipe supplying water to the camp and were stopping fellow immigrants and small babies from drinking water, the SABC reported.

The group were allegedly holding a hunger strike and preventing other foreigners from eating and drinking. — Sapa, AFP

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them.

Carol Hills
Carol Hills works from Boston. Political cartoon & graphic journalism desk @pritheworld. Global images that reflect, make & break the news. Edited by Carol Hills. Carol Hills has over 25992 followers on Twitter.

Related stories

Advertising

Subscribers only

The health minister is on the ropes for dodgy vibes...

Mkhize’s request to take special leave left President Cyril Ramaphosa reeling, party insiders say

Petro states: What happens when 30% of your national budget...

As the demand for oil shrinks and prices collapse, Africa’s petro states — the likes of Angola, Nigeria, Egypt and Equatorial Guinea — will be left with massive holes in their budgets

More top stories

The health minister is on the ropes for dodgy vibes...

Mkhize’s request to take special leave left President Cyril Ramaphosa reeling, party insiders say

State halts its R10bn long-term plan to fully treat acid...

The state is saddled with the burden of treating acid water and polluters are escaping the responsibility

Petro states: What happens when 30% of your national budget...

As the demand for oil shrinks and prices collapse, Africa’s petro states — the likes of Angola, Nigeria, Egypt and Equatorial Guinea — will be left with massive holes in their budgets

Europe, Asia rob West Africa of fish

Greenpeace Africa reports that the fishmeal and fish oil industry is ‘robbing the Gambia, Mauritania and Senegal of livelihoods and food’
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×