Transformation needs to serve the interests of the majority

The work by the Nelson Mandela Foundation and the production of the position paper has not come at a better time.  

I generally agree with the analysis of the paper, especially regarding what was done to try and make South Africa a more equitable country in all aspects – now we need to focus on what is to be done to transform the country. 

It is difficult to come up with a wholesale solution; it is difficult to try to reconcile while uplifting; to change things for one group of people while keeping them the same for another group of people; keeping whites feeling comfortable, and their lives remaining the same, while transforming to empower the majority that is black.

Sparking dialogue is of course important. A recent example happened at the University of Cape Town where dialogue led to the unanimous agreement that the statue of Cecil John Rhodes must go. As we change South Africa, it is important to let those resisting or those uncomfortable with change know why things are changing.

South Africa needs to transform, not just reconcile. Transformation is profound, fundamental change, altering the very nature of something. Transformational change is both radical and sustainable. Something that is transformed can never go back to exactly what it was before.

The conquest and domination of Africans by Europeans and their descendents was not just physical and economic, it was also mental and spiritual. Therefore, the re-engineering of this country cannot be addressed by transforming the economy alone; it needs to deal with the psyche of not only white people but also and especially the psyche of black people.

But the time for pity parties, blaming and seeking apologies is over. We need action that will transform.

Equality in resources must translate to seeing ourselves and the other as equal human beings regardless of differences in race, culture, gender, religion and so on.

Racism is not just the attitudes and actions of whites towards blacks. It is also the accepting by blacks of the notion that we deserve to be viewed as having lower social value.

A lot of things about South Africa have changed and much more needs to change. I am of the generation that is impatient for change and does not want a single further generation to find things as they are today.

I believe that we need to be critical about our past and passionate about our future.

This does not mean forgetting history – to the contrary, it means knowing and understanding history for what it is and the resulting circumstances we have today. It means not being defined or arrested by history, but instead being passionate and emotional about the possibilities of tomorrow, about the South Africa we want, and being busy getting there.

We need action in many little and big ways, and one of those ways I would like to suggest is for government to make it compulsory that all schools that are “white”, in that the majority of teaching staff is white, be changed.

All of these schools, public and private, should have at least 50% black teachers. And where there is an excess of white teachers they should be employed in black schools. 

Carter G Woodson, in his book The Mis-Education of the Negro, which analyses the education systems in Europe and America and their impact on “the Negro”, says “so-called modern education, with all its defects, however, does others so much more good than it does the Negro, because it has been worked out in conformity to the needs of those who have enslaved and oppressed weaker peoples”.

This is also the case in South Africa.

From a young age white and black children who go to suburban schools mostly encounter white teachers. This defines power relations from a young age, with whites being seen as leaders and generators of ideas and knowledge.

At home, the majority of white children have black maids and garden helpers.  

On television, white and black children are exposed to white definitions of beauty – most shows on the MNet channel are white, as are most popular American series on public channels.

Adverts by big department stores such as Truworths – like the one currently airing – have mostly white models, when the majority of people buying there are black. Examples are countless.

This fosters a generation of white children thinking they are superior and black children who work for recognition by whites. Still in 2015 media, schools and business communicate the idea that blacks are of lower social value.

Dialogues alone won’t change this narrative.

Last year I was in a workshop with management of a major South African bank, which has a wide presence on the continent. When I asked the management why it is so white, and so male for that matter, the response was that they don’t look at race or gender when hiring, they want the best, they are a meritocracy.

The implication is that black people just aren’t smart enough – clear-cut racism.

The same is said when questions about why rugby and cricket are so white are raised.

Racist philosophy has infiltrated so much of our lives that at times people don’t even know they are racist.

The history of human development is defined and littered by conquest, competition and war. Like other members of the animal kingdom, this trait to overcome others is displayed in the sports we play, in the reward systems at schools and in the workplace, right through to the awarding of global prizes such as the Nobel.

As intelligent beings this aspect of nature has assisted us in progressing and developing amazing things such as this laptop I am typing on.

It is the other aspect of competition, our need to be superior to “others” and the need we have for affirmation, that creates schisms that give way to different forms of hatred such as racism.

It is not important to go into depth about the history of racism and how it was developed as an idea, philosophy and science. But as an example, some of the exalted thinkers of Europe’s Enlightenment period contributed to the widespread understanding and belief by Europeans and their descendents that “the civilized nation [Europe] is conscious that the rights of the barbarians [Africans] are unequal to its own”, as written by Hegel in his Philosophy of Right .

The construct of the modern global political economy is based on the philosophies of Hegel, Hume, Kant and Marx that present and justify the colonisation and exploitation of “black savages” and their lands of gold.

It is not in the best interests of South Africa for us to replicate this trajectory. It is important to have dialogues, but because some are comfortable with the status quo – because the major shift and transformation that was expected post-1994 never came – reaching consensus will be difficult.

It is time to serve the interests of the majority.

We need the dialogues to inspire action.

We need civic education reaching every South African so that this work on transforming the country isn’t about what government, business or civil society thinks, but about what we all think.

For this, people need to be educated so that they can exercise their citizenship.

So as we bring down statues and reclaim history, we need to educate, to re-engineer especially the awareness of black South Africans to appreciate that citizenship doesn’t begin and end with voting; so that we bring up a generation of young people who are self-assured and firm about pursuing what is right at all times.

We need to break the social and political culture that existed during our colonisation and domination and that still persists today, and become actors that transform the current economic and social structures and systems.

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Zulu good will DD
Ntombenhle Khathwane
Ntombenhle Khathwane is an entrepreneur and social justice activist.

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Opposition caucuses on panel for Ramaphosa impeachment probe

The parties want to leave the speaker little discretion in composing the panel that will decide whether there is a case for impeaching the president

Amazon may threaten SA retailers

Amazon plans to move into South Africa in 2023 and the world’s biggest online marketplace might give local companies a run for their money

Gallo celebrates 95 years

The history of Africa’s first record label is studded with successes — and controversies

Creecy shoots down Karpowership appeal but extends a lifeline to...

The Karpowership proposal lacked proper environmental assessments, according to the minister, with noise impacts specifically noted

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…