Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Auditor General finds that Sars overstated compliance figures

The Auditor General (AG) found that the South African Revenue Service (Sars) in 2017 flouted the Income Tax Act by overstating its compliance figures in public documents.

The findings, in an AG report dated March 2017, came to light on Tuesday during public hearings in Pretoria for the Nugent inquiry.

Tax compliance refers to making payments to the revenue service in full and on time in line with relevant legislation.

The commission of inquiry, appointed by President Cyril Ramaphosa, is probing the state of corporate governance, revenue shortfalls and allegations of misconduct at Sars.

Evidence leader Advocate Carol Steinberg highlighted the findings while leading testimony by Dr Thabelo Malovhele, who until 2015 was the agency’s executive for tax, customs, risk and compliance analysis.

He was later asked to sign a contract that identifies him as a ‘Domain Specialist’ but says he still has no proper job function.

She referenced a confidential affidavit that pointed to who at Sars was responsible for the overstating of the compliance figures. While the correct figure is unknown, Sars apparently stated that its compliance level was at 91.14%, which according to the AG is not true.

The findings relate to corporate income tax (CIT) and personal income tax (PIT).

“The indicators are that Sars overstated compliance in its public documents. There are legislative requirements on how to measure compliance, and they were breached,” Steinberg said.

Warnings

Malovhele told the commission he had repeatedly warned his superiors of the risk but was seemingly ignored.

He was formerly the head of Sars’s compliance and strategy research unit, which was responsible for measuring the revenue service’s compliance figures according to the Income Tax Act.

This unit was disbanded under a new operating model instituted by now suspended SARS Commissioner Tom Moyane. The subsequent decline in compliance was directly correlated with a decline in revenue collection, Malovhele told the commission.

READ MORE: Sars efficiency moved backwards after implementation of Moyane-sanctioned model

Compliance figures are key to determining which areas of the economy are least tax compliant, which in turn enables Sars’s enforcement divisions to focus on these areas to boost compliance and up revenue collection Malovhele explained in his testimony.

Updated definitions

The definitions for tax types and entities were published in the Government Gazette he said, and those were strictly adhered to before 2015 in determining compliance figures.

But these definitions were updated under the new Sars administration.

“What happened was we were taken away from even setting compliance targets – other people took over that responsibility. The challenge was when definitions were changed to make compliance in PIT and CIT look better. One definition we fought but didn’t succeed was “economic active entities”,” he said.

“The definition pushed compliance in CIT, which was very bad, from 12% to 40%,” Malovhele said by way of an example.

“We knew that this definition was misrepresenting the true state of compliance,” he added.

Steinberg, reading from the AG report stated:

“What the AG finds is; As part of our completeness testing, we noted that the following tax payers were excluded from returns required the denominator, taking into account the economically active definition. However, the tax payers were claiming VAT payments and refunds of that same year.”

“Based on the legal requirements, these companies are legally required to submit corporate income tax returns and therefore should form part of percentage required to file CIT tax returns, as reported in annual reports, but were not,” the report continued.

“There is a very similar story in PIT where SARS has indicated that 91.14% did file their returns but the Auditor General finds that the indicators were wrong, and thus the figure is overstated.”

Professor Michael Katz, a member of the commission, was incredulous that such a key factor of tax collection had been seemingly abandoned by Sars under the new operating model and questioned Malovhele on why this was done, and for whose benefit.

“I don’t know,” Malovhele conceded. — Fin24

Subscribe for R500/year

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and get a 57% discount in your first year.

Kyle Cowan
Kyle Cowan

Kyle Cowan is an investigative journalist at News 24.

Related stories

WELCOME TO YOUR M&G

If you’re reading this, you clearly have great taste

If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

Advertising

Subscribers only

Hawkish Reserve Bank sees South Africa edge towards a rates...

Analysts say the Reserve Bank could start tightening monetary policy as early as next month

Coko vs S ruling: The case against a subjective test...

Acting judge Tembeka Ngcukaitobi’s acquittal of a rape suspect has raised controversy, but legal experts say the fault lay with legislators and not the court

More top stories

Zuma tries to turn his courtroom attack on Downer into...

Jacob Zuma has laid charges claiming that Billy Downer, and the NPA, have irredeemably tainted the arms deal corruption charges that have haunted him since 2005

Top greenhouse gas emitter South Africa earns kudos for new...

The Healthy NDCs Scorecard has recognised South Africa’s efforts in revising its nationally determined contributions to mitigate climate change

Almost 7 000 children receive Pfizer shot on first day...

More than 39 000 young people had registered on the government’s database by 4pm on Wednesday

Police murder trial: 189 metal pellets killed Nathaniel ‘Lokkies’ Julies

At least 65% of the pellets in the cartridge hit the 16-year-old when he was gunned down in Eldorado Park, Johannesburg, allegedly by in-training constable, Caylene Whiteboy
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×