Media punishment should be ‘proportionate’

Punishment given to newspapers for irresponsible reporting should be “proportionate” to the harm caused, said Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) on Thursday.

“There needs to be better ways to deal with offences of the press,” MMA spokesperson Taryn Hinton said at public hearings conducted by the Press Council at the University of the Witwatersrand.

“The punishment dished out to a newspaper should be equal to the nature of the offence. If a gross violation article was published on a front page the apology should be on the front page as well.”

Hinton also suggested “restorative justice”.

“There should some sort of a fund where if newspapers wrote a story violating a child’s right, the newspaper would pay towards the child’s education.

“If it is a politician, they would then have to run a profile highlighting the good things he/she is involved in.”

The system of punishment used should also be in line with the Constitution.

Hinton did not think the proposed Medial Appeals Tribunal was a solution, because it had the potential of clamping down on media freedom.

More accountability
“The current media self regulatory system needs to be improved; the quality of reporting needs to be improved; and more accountability is needed from the media,” she said.

The MMA also submitted that the section of the Press Code that says no payment should be made for feature articles to persons engaged in crime or other notorious misbehaviour, or their associates, including family, friends neighbours and colleagues, should be amended.

“I find that clause very peculiar because it only prohibits payment of criminals, (or) their neighbours only. We are proposing a ban generally, not just from criminals,” said head of media policy at MMA, Prinola Govender.

She said the Press Council had to ensure that the public was aware of its existence and the Press Code.

The Press Council is holding public hearings with the aim of reviewing its constitution, the Press Code and how it handles complaints. There was a poor turn out of only three ordinary members of the public at the first day of the hearings in Johannesburg.

As from next week, the hearings would be held in Port Elizabeth, Cape Town, Bloemfontein and Durban. — Sapa

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Bomb scare at parliament

The bag suspected of containing a bomb belonged to a parliamentary staff member and was harmless

The slings and arrows of advocate Malesela Teffo’s outrageous fortunes

Now that he has withdrawn from the Senzo Meyiwa murder trial, will the promise of justice for the Meyiwa family be kept?

Digital ‘disruptor’ eats jobs at SA banks amid unemployment crisis

With fewer people visiting branches, opting to seek services online, something has to give

London’s changed – including the climate

The local shops have been replaced by chain stores, the skyline has new features, the digital age stops communication and the green parks are dry and brown

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…