Fracking story contains ‘wild’ untruths

Sarah Wild's article ("New US study inflames SA's fracking feud", June 28) contains untrue comments.

The figure of 390-trillion cubic feet of gas is mere speculation. At this stage it is not known how much or how little gas is available, and it should be reported as such. Further, the figures of potential gas volumes as published by the US Geological Survey have been shown to be substantially overinflated and many of the US gas plays contain less than 10% of the original estimates. It is irresponsible journalism to publish numbers that have not been proven.

South Africa does not need the gas. The new power stations now under construction are coal-fired and will remain so. No amount of shale gas will change that. Similarly, the South African coal-mining industry is not going to go away once gas is used domestically. The coal will simply be exported and burned elsewhere and there will be no net improvement in global greenhouse gas emissions.

There are vast quantities of conventional gas available from our neighbouring states of Namibia, Angola and Mozambique. The concept of energy independence (from fossil fuels) is an American one to avoid dealing with troublesome Venezuelans, Iranians and other unreliable suppliers of oil. South Africa will only be self-sufficient when we begin to put more effort into exploiting renewables, of which we potentially have vast quantities.

The mind-set of "business as usual" when exploiting hydrocarbons cannot be  perpetuated. The vast financial resources used to explore for Karoo shale could be better spent elsewhere.

As for the 2000 barrels of water quoted by the "Shell experts", since when are volumes of water measured in barrels? Litres, kilolitres, cubic metres and gallons are commonly used. Assuming that a barrel means a volume of 220 litres, it would imply that the "Shell experts" mean that 440 000 litres of water is used. Yet a Shell borehole drilled recently in Pennsylvania used more than 12million litres.

In South Africa the boreholes will be deeper and geologically more complex and therefore will use more water than in the US. Shell's draft environmental management plan of March 2011 says that "the volume of water required to perform that operation could be up to six million litres"  – a far cry from 2000 barrels!

I would suggest that if Wild insists on writing scientific articles, she adopt a modicum of scientific standards in her reporting. – Jan Arkert, PrSciNat

 Sarah Wild replies: The "390trillion cubic feet" is from the US Energy Information Agency and is taken as the definitive estimate of shale gas resources. It was updated earlier this year because the previous estimates were considered too low. I quoted barrels because that is what the American expert used when I was in Wyoming, speaking to a project manager on one of Shell's Pinedale Anticline sites. He was using an American metric, which I retained. That number is per fracking phase, and there can be multiple phases. The rest is arguable personal ideology. I will continue to "insist" on writing scientific articles.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories

Gwede keeps options open despite anti-fracking ruling

The minister of mineral resources and energy, Gwede Mantashe, has announced that his department will not be extracting gas by way of fracking

Groundwater maps could help South Africa prepare for safer fracking

A vulnerability map could help assess the risks associated with fracking and groundwater which around 300 towns depend on in South Africa's Karoo

​Court throws out fracking application for KZN

A procedural failure on the part of government has meant a further delay for attempts to get gas out from under 15 000 farms in KwaZulu-Natal.

‘Give SA its own fracking agency’

South Africa has adopted a softly-softly approach to shale gas exploration.

BHP write-down reveals fragile state of shale

The size of BHP Billiton's $2.8bn write-down for its US shale assets took some banks by surprise - at least two thought it was too small.

Let’s debate facts – not feelings

To debate on the basis of science-based evidence before making decisions is something we should aspire to in every field where it is possible.

New education policy on gender violence released

Universities and other higher education institutions have to develop ways of preventing or dealing with rape and other damaging behaviour

Cambridge Food Jozini: Pandemic or not, the price-gouging continues

The Competition Commission has fined Cambridge Food Jozini for hiking the price of its maize meal during April

Sekhukhune’s five-year battle for water back in court

The residents of five villages are calling for the district municipal manager to be arrested

Vaccine trial results due in December

If successful, it will then have to be manufactured and distributed

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday