Philippines: Confusion over Haiyan death toll

The government is at odds with the world body over fatality figures from one of the world's worst storms on record, which struck the central Philippines province of Leyte on November 8.

Reynaldo Balido, spokesperson for the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council, said on Friday the number of confirmed dead had risen significantly from the previous count of 2 360, adding that 1 140 were reported missing.

"It is the result of reporting by the LGUs [local government units]," he said.

"The LGUs did not report immediately because they have to be careful in their reporting. They have to validate everything," he added.

"The clearing operations of roads and communities are ongoing and we will see if there are more dead bodies [underneath the debris]."

Earlier on Friday, confusion deepened when the Philippines agency disputed UN death toll figures, and officials said a police general who claimed 10 000 people might have been died was removed from his position.

Citing regional authorities, the UN said on Friday the latest figure for the number of dead in last week's storm was at least 4 460.

The national disaster council maintained a much lower figure of 2 360, with Balido saying "not true" when asked about the UN's toll, before raising it later.

Different figures
The differing counts came as officials said regional police chief Elmer Soria had been removed from his post, adding another twist to a tale, which has seen President Benigno Aquino accused of downplaying the scale of the disaster.

"Superintendent Soria and many of our police officers from Region 8 have been through a lot over the past days and they may be experiencing what you might call 'acute stress reaction'," national police spokesperson Reuben Sindac said.

"As such, it was deemed by higher headquarters that he might need to go through some 'stress debriefing', hence, his recall.

"A new regional director [not affected by the recent events] has been appointed as his replacement," he added.

The death toll from Super Typhoon Haiyan has been a source of contention and confusion between the UN and the Philippine government for much of the past week.

After Soria made his claim, John Ging, operations director for the UN's Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) on Monday said it was estimated that over 10 000 people had died.

The next day Aquino told CNN that number was "too much", estimating that the final toll would be around 2 500.

The OCHA said their number was obtained from the regional taskforce of the Philippine National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC) on Wednesday.

"As of 13 November, the government reported that 4 460 people have died," OCHA said.

Asked for the source of the figures, Manila-based OCHA spokesperson Orla Fagan said: "We are getting it from the operations centre of the regional taskforce set up by the NDRRMC."

On Thursday, UN humanitarian chief Valerie Amos said: "The figure of 10 000 is not a UN figure," adding that it was put together by local officials.

"We have no way of verifying. I think it will take a long time before we have an accurate assessment of the number of people who have died." – AFP

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Bradley Carnell’s shot at US footballing greatness

St Louis City’s head coach has the opportunity to build a legacy from scratch at the midwest club, the latest franchise added to the Major League Soccer.

How to safeguard your digital footprint in cyberspace

Apply physical security measures in cyberspace; if you won’t open your door to a stranger, why accept offers and requests from strangers online?

Strike looms at Sars over 0% wage increase

The revenue collector says it is unable to offer its 12 479 staff any salary increase, leading Nehawu and others to announce strike action

Why opposition party solidarity matters in the SADC

There is a need for opposition parties to hold governing parties to account, thus strengthening democracy

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…