Timol: New case against security cop

The trial of a man involved in the killing of anti-apartheid activist Ahmed Timol has yet to begin but, when it does, the state will rely on circumstantial evidence to argue that former Security Branch clerk João “Jan” Rodrigues was involved in the premeditated murder of Timol, and even his torture.

When Timol’s nephew, Imtiaz Cajee, approached the National Prosecuting Authority in 2004 to investigate the death of his uncle in police custody in 1971, he was told that the NPA had produced “negative results” in finding new evidence and the matter would be dropped.

READ MORE: Timol family hopes for truth from Security Branch policeman

It has been 14 years since Cajee wrote that letter. In that time, the family, working with a team of private investigators and lawyers, found enough evidence to motivate a reopened inquest into Timol’s death. The inquest found last year that the young South African Communist Party activist had been murdered by the security police.

Rodrigues now faces prison time for premeditated murder and defeating the ends of justice. At 79, he is the last surviving policeman from a cohort of security cops who are believed to have tortured Timol and covered up the truth about his killing.

The Hawks’ Captain Frans Ngwako Mathipa has set out the version of events that the state could argue when the trial commences. Mathipa, in an affidavit that was submitted during Rodrigue’s bail application, says evidence from his own investigations show that Rodrigues and two other policemen, Johannes Hendrik Gloy and Johannes Zacharias van Niekerk, were involved in Timol’s torture and death.

“The accused, Gloy and Van Niekerk, tortured and assaulted the deceased. Prior to his death, and whilst in their custody and under their care, the deceased sustained multiple bruises and fractures, including and not limited to inter alia the nasal bone, left orbital
ramus, right inferior orbital ramus fractures of the left and upper jaw, an isolated depressed skull fracture, extensive contusions on the right leg and a dislocated left an[k]le,” Mathipa said in his affidavit.

The injuries were detailed in the testimony of Dr Shakeera Holland, a forensic pathologist, at the reopened inquest into Timol’s death. In her statement, she said Timol sustained these injuries while in police custody.

The medical evidence provided by Holland and the testimonies of other expert witnesses who appeared before the reopened inquest will form some of the circumstantial evidence the state will use to argue that the security police pushed or threw Timol from the 10th floor of John Vorster Square (now known as Johannesburg Central police station) or the roof of the building after they had tortured him for four days.

Mathipa’s affidavit also refers extensively to Dr Salim Essop, who was arrested with Timol. Essop was admitted to hospital after his police interrogators had beaten him into a coma. “During his period of detention from 23 October 1971 until 26 October 1971, Essop was tortured and severely assaulted by members of the Security Branch at John Vorster Square police station.

“On 26 October 1971, Essop was hospitalised in a comatose state, as a result of assault and torture on him by members of the Security Branch,” Mathipa says.

Timol was killed on October 27. Members of Timol family’s legal team have previously argued that, if the police tortured Essop then it would follow that they would have tortured Timol, who was considered by the regime to be a “big fish” in the underground movement.

Ahmed Timol (ahmedtimol.co.za)

Rodrigues, who has confessed to being the last person to see Timol alive, will file an application for a permanent stay of proceedings on Friday. It is set to be heard on Monday. His attorney, Ben Minnaar, has refuted claims that Rodrigues is trying to delay the trial, saying his client is eager to see a resolution to the matter.

“That’s been our stance from the beginning. We want it to be finalised as soon as possible. We have got no instructions to delay the matter,” he said. Sifiso Khumalo, the state prosecutor on the case, accused Rodrigues of drawing out the pre-trial process to avoid trial. “It’s all part of delay tactics,” he said.

If the trial proceeds, the Timol case will set a precedent. The NPA has failed to prosecute cases in which perpetrators of crimes did not receive amnesty from the Truth and Reconciliation (TRC), arguing that there was no new evidence.

An internal NPA memorandum dated November 29 2006 is indicative of this. It was written by the NPA TRC task-team convenor, Silas Ramaite, and informs the national director of public prosecutions Vusi Pikoli that the NPA’s investigation into Black Consciousness Movement leader Steve Biko’s death has been dropped.

Ramaite wrote: “The DPP [director of public prosecutions]: Eastern Cape had recommended that no prosecution be instituted due to a lack of evidence.

READ MORE: Apartheid cop accused of ‘delay tactics’ to avoid murder trial

“It was established that all the doctors who had treated the deceased were dead, except for the chief state pathologist, who, when consulted, conceded that he could not exclude that the injury to the deceased’s head could have been accidentally caused.”

Ramaite is now the acting national director of public prosecutions.

The Timol family has applied pressure on the NPA to pursue the case, but it will be up to the courts to decide whether Rodrigues will be granted a permanent stay of prosecution. The case has now been postponed to October 22.

“Ironically, it was on October 22 1971 that my uncle was actually detained‚” Cajee said. “We are still waiting for court proceedings to commence.”

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Raeesa Pather
Raeesa Pather
Ra’eesa Pather is a Cape Town-based general news and features journalist.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Q&A Sessions: Marcia Mayaba —Driven to open doors for women

Marcia Mayaba has been in the motor industry for 24 years, donning hats that include receptionist, driver, fuel attendant, dealer principal and now chief...

The war on women in video game culture

Women and girls make up almost half of the gaming community but are hardly represented and face abuse in the industry

More top stories

Mysteries behind Battle of Bangui

A new book offers unprecedented insight into South Africa’s strange relationship with the Central African Republic

Gatvol Capetonians, EFF lash out at City of Cape Town...

Public infrastructure was allegedly damaged by the activist group in 2019 and by the Economic Freedom Fighters in 2020

Masuku loses appeal against SIU report on Covid graft

The judge found that when news of improprieties were brought to his attention, Masuku did not take steps to urgently intervene

Leaking De Ruyter’s affidavit countering racism claims was ‘malicious’ and...

Mkhuleko Hlengwa has pointed to people in Eskom or the public enterprises department for making the document public

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…