Gordhan: Mkhwebane’s report ‘politically motivated and riddled with errors’

Pravin Gordhan has gone to court to set aside the Public Protector’s recent report which found he had acted improperly, saying it was politically motivated and “riddled with reviewable errors”.

The report, released by advocate Busisiwe Mkhwebane on Friday, related to the approval by Gordhan — who was finance minister at the time — of an early retirement for former South African Revenue Service (Sars) deputy commissioner Ivan Pillay and for Sars to cover the cost of the resulting actuarial shortfall. Gordhan further approved a request to then keep Pillay on at Sars on a fixed-term contract.

READ MORE: Public Protector’s report ‘wrong’ in fact and in law — Gordhan lawyer

Mkhwebane directed President Cyril Ramaphosa to take disciplinary action against Gordhan and for Sars to recover money that was paid as an actuarial shortfall on Pillay’s behalf.

In papers filed on Tuesday, Gordhan has asked the high court in Pretoria to set aside and declare the report “unconstitutional, unlawful, irrational and invalid”. He has also asked the court to order that Mkhwebane personally pay the costs “on a punitive scale”.

Gordhan said that, despite making submissions to Mkhwebane, the final report “reveals no sign of any meaningful consideration of or reflection on the contents of [his] submissions”.

“It was as if they were ‘going through the motions’ and intended to find against me … from the outset,” said Gordhan.

The evidence showed that when he approved the retirement, he acted “with extraordinary care”, after “seeking extensive advice from at least six people with expertise and knowledge of the applicable legal and regulatory provisions,” Gordhan said.

He suggested that the timing of the release of the report was politically motivated. “I say this because there was no reason for the unseemly haste with which the Report was issued on Friday, 24 May 2019, a mere 48 hours following the delivery of my submissions,” he said.

Gordhan said he could “only conclude” that the rush was informed by “improper and irrelevant considerations, or an ulterior purpose or motive”.

His political opponents had sought to use the complaint, and now her report, to attack his integrity. This was the only plausible explanation for why Mkhwebane would “effectively ignore” his submissions, he said.

“I believe the report was issued when it was issued, with the findings and remedial action it contained, so as to enable a renewal of the ongoing political campaign against me by proponents of ‘state capture’ and defenders of corruption”.

Gordhan said he placed his trust in the courts to determine that he did not contravene the law.

“Unlike other individuals who threaten legal action when they are accused of wrongdoing or even criminal conduct, yet do nothing to institute litigation, I have nothing to hide.”

READ MORE: EFF stands by Public Protector after earlier misgivings

He also said that, because the facts that gave rise to the complaint happened years ago, the way Mkhwebane decided to entertain the complaint was irrational and unlawful. “Section 6(9) provides that the Public Protector may not entertain a complaint more than two years after the event at issue, except where, in special circumstances, the Public Protector exercises her discretion to do so.”

There were no special circumstances in this complaint, he said.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Franny Rabkin
Franny Rabkin
Franny is the legal reporter at the Mail & Guardian

Related stories


Subscribers only

Wits in a climate hot spot

The university says it provides a platform for multiple voices to be heard on any issue, including that of a climate denialist

Mantashe is pumping gas

The minister believes liquified petroleum gas is needed in the energy mix, but some experts are not convinced of its merits

More top stories

‘I’m no climate-change denier’

The presentation by Lars Schernikau, who works in the commodity and coal business, has provoked an outcry

Mlambo invites commentary on claims of judicial capture, again

A candidate for the Northern Cape bench lucidly explained in reply to the Gauteng Judge President that bribing a judge is a lottery you are bound to lose

Funding bombshell leaves law students in limbo

Wits sent students notices stating that they were liable for tuition, allowance and accommodation costs for 2020. The bombshell was dropped on the students in the last week of March.

Alcohol lobby’s data is wobbly

A recent report by the alcohol industry contradicting established research and should be thoroughly questioned

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…