Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Shareholders lose out as Moyo vs Old Mutal drags on



There’s a clear loser in the no-holds-barred war between the Old Mutual board and its twice-fired chief executive, Peter Moyo: the shareholders who have watched the share price fall by 17% — erasing more than R16-billion from its market capitalisation — as the gloves have come off.

Independent analyst Theo Botha says that neither Moyo or Old Mutual has come out as the clear winner so far and that shareholders have borne the brunt of the dispute.

“Normally if there is a dispute in a company like this then the CEO [chief executive] will leave. This case has caught the shareholders off guard,” he says.

A corporate governance expert and lecturer at the Gordon Institute of Business Science, Morris Mthombeni, says that it is still possible that the dispute can be resolved but neither side has indicated any likelihood of this.

“The way each side is playing this out suggests that it’s near impossible for them to actually repair their relationship. What is clear is that both sides should have worked a lot harder to arrive at a situation to avoid finding themselves in a litigation,” he says.

The dispute between Moyo and the Old Mutual board began shortly after Moyo was suspended in May and dismissed in June, due to a “conflict of interest” and a “material breakdown in trust and confidence”.

Moyo went to court to fight his dismissal, which he said occurred without disciplinary proceedings.

Part B of his application wants the board declared delinquent.

Moyo came out victorious on July 30 when Judge Brian Mashile in the Johannesburg high court ordered that he be temporarily reinstated pending his other application.

The company nevertheless barred him from returning to work and launched an appeal to the ruling, which was heard by the same judge earlier this month. The judgment was expected to be handed down at the end of August but Moyo has now requested that the court hold back until the outcome of his application is heard in September.

In the latest affidavit, filed on Monday, Moyo wants the courts to find that the Trevor Manuel-led board of directors have deliberately interfered with the functioning of the courts because his contract was terminated by the company for a second time last week.

Moyo has also lambasted Old Mutual for rejecting the settlement proposal he sent to the company on August 5. In the correspondence sent to Old Mutual, seen by the Mail & Guardian, Moyo says that the proposal to bring forward his application to have the company’s directors declared delinquent while he is placed on voluntary special leave, with full benefits, is a bid to “break the current impasse and to avoid unnecessary prolonged litigation and in the interest of all stakeholders.

“During that period, the parties would apply their best endeavours to reach a settlement in respect of all outstanding issues between them,” the proposal reads.

To counter the proposal, Old Mutual placed two options on the table: firstly for both parties to agree to suspend the court ruling which ordered Moyo’s temporary reinstatement; and secondly that the company withdraw its appeal to the initial court ruling.

Commentator and chartered accountant, Khaya Sithole says that both parties should have considered the long-term consequences of airing their “laundry” in the public domain.

“What makes this unique is that both parties are of the view that they have a reasonable chance of succeeding in a litigation process, therefore they are persisting with it.”

If they really applied their minds, he says, they might consider that the consequences of losing are just too great.

Thando Maeko is and Adamela Trust business reporter at the Mail & Guardian

Subscribe for R500/year

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and get a 57% discount in your first year.

Thando Maeko
Thando Maeko is an Adamela Trust business reporter at the Mail & Guardian

Related stories


If you’re reading this, you clearly have great taste

If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Subscribers only

Fears of violence persist a year after the murder of...

The court battle to stop coal mining in rural KwaZulu-Natal has heightened the sense of danger among environmental activists

Data shows EFF has lower negative sentiment online among voters...

The EFF has a stronger online presence than the ANC and Democratic Alliance

More top stories

Libyan town clings to memory of Gaddafi, 10 years on

Rebels killed Muammar Gaddafi in his hometown of Sirte on 20 October 2011, months into the Nato-backed rebellion that ended his four-decade rule

Fishing subsidies in the W. Cape: ‘Illegal fishing is our...

Fishers claim they are forced into illegal trawling because subsidies only benefit big vessels

Kenya’s beach boys fall into sex tourism, trafficking

In the face of their families’ poverty, young men, persuaded by the prospect of wealth or education, travel to Europe with their older female sponsors only to be trafficked for sex

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…