Squabble over emissions targets at Bali meeting

Developing countries led by China squabbled with the West over mandatory emission cuts at the Bali climate-change conference, as activists accused Canada on Saturday of undermining the negotiations by insisting on targets for poor nations.

China, which some believe has surpassed the United States as the world’s top emitter of carbon dioxide and other heat-trapping gases, questioned the fairness of binding cuts when its per capita emissions are about one-sixth of the US’s. It said, too, that it has only been pumping pollutants into the atmosphere for a few decades, whereas the West has done so for hundreds of years.

”China is in the process of industrialisation and there is a need for economic growth to meet the basic needs of the people and fight against poverty,” said Su Wei, a top climate expert for the government and member of its delegation at the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Bali.

”I just wonder whether it’s fair to ask developing countries like China to take on binding targets,” Su said on Friday. ”I think there is much room for the United States to think whether it’s possible to change [its] lifestyle and consumption patterns in order to contribute to the protection of the global climate.”

Delegates from nearly 190 nations are attending the December 3 to 14 meeting in Bali and are likely to agree to launch negotiations that will lead to an international accord to succeed the 1997 Kyoto Protocol on global warming. They also are expected to set a deadline for completing negotiations and agree on some of the issues to be discussed.

The protocol, which was rejected by the US, commits three dozen industrialised countries to cut their greenhouse gases an average of 5% below 1990 levels between next year and 2012, when it expires.

Indonesian Environment Minister Rachmat Witoelar, who is president of the conference, said discussions on starting post-Kyoto negotiations were on track and that ”God willing” an agreement would be reached by next weekend.

”There is no deadlock,” he said. ”I would think about 85% of those in the room have the same direction.”

Binding targets

However, Climate Action Network Canada, a coalition of Canadian environmental groups, said Canadian negotiators in Bali have been told to ”demand that poorer nations accept the same binding absolute emission reduction targets as developed nations”.

”The Kyoto Protocol is built on the recognition that industrialised countries are largely responsible for the problem of climate change, and must take the lead in tackling it,” said Steven Guilbeault, of the environmental group Equiterre. ”Canada is trying to rewrite history by putting the burden of emissions reductions on poorer countries.”

Climate Action Network Canada gave reporters a one-page document that it described as a leaked copy of Canada’s negotiating stance. It was impossible to verify the authenticity of the document, and a spokesperson for the Canadian delegation did not respond to a request for comment.

The chief UN climate scientist, Rajendra Pachauri, said it is next to impossible to expect the developing world to agree to cuts when its per capita emissions are so much less than the West.

”What is absolutely essential is to see that the developed countries establish a record of action and commitment, which I think will induce and provide a moral basis for developing countries to assume the burden,” Pachauri said. ”In the absence of that, I don’t think anything is going to happen. With per capita levels being so different, it’s not likely that anybody in the developing world would accept commitments.”

Angus Friday, chairperson of the Alliance of Small Island States, many of which are threatened by sea-level rises, said developed countries have a ”moral responsibility” to show leadership on the issue and act first to tackle global warming since they have contributed far more to the problem than poor countries.

”The danger in the developed world is that the culture of entitlement is not being matched by the culture of responsibility,” he said. — Sapa-AP

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Gauteng ANC conference likely to produce mixed bag of leaders

No slate is expected to emerge victorious as poorly coordinated conference finally gets under way

Africa’s Covid neglect poses global danger

Low vaccination levels and high number of health-compromised populations make the continent a ‘breeding ground for variants’ that pose a global risk

Kenya opposition leader selects woman as running mate

For the first time a woman is running on a major presidential ticket – a big marker in Kenya’s history. But for marginalised voters, the politics of representation comes with many contradictions

Art imitates life at the National Arts Festival

This year’s National Arts Festival in Makhanda - the first live one since the pandemic - tackles unemployment, the Marikana Massacre and the manner in which black women in society are written about

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…