ConCourt passes the buck on Zimbabwe report

The Constitutional Court has sent the M&G‘s application to have a controversial report on the 2002 Zimbabwe elections all the way back to the high court.

The Constitutional Court on Tuesday directed a Mail & Guardian application to have a South African government report on the 2002 Zimbabwe general elections made public, back to the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria for further consideration.

The judgment relates back to an M&G challenge in 2007 of the government’s decision to keep secret a report on the constitutional and legal conditions surrounding Zimbabwe’s controversial 2002 elections under the basis of the Protection of Access to Information Act of 2002 (Paia).

The report, which was commissioned by then-president Thabo Mbeki from judges Sisi Khampepe and Dikgang Moseneke, was to be used by the president for policy formulation. Khampepe is a judge in the Constitutional Court and Moseneke is deputy chief justice. Both recused themselves when the court heard the matter in May.

The matter was brought to the Constitutional Court by the presidency, who had previously been ordered first by the high court, and then the Supreme Court of Appeal, to release the report to the M&G. The government had argued that the report was a record of Cabinet, which is excluded from Paia’s ambit in terms of Section 12(a) of the Act.

It also claimed the report’s release would expose confidential exchanges between the countries’ governments — a further limitation found in Section 41 of PAIA.

In a majority decision written by former chief justice Sandile Ngcobo, the court ruled that the high court, where the matter originated, should invoke its power to study the report’s contents.

“The majority concluded that the high court should have invoked its power to examine the report to decide on the state’s claims that it was exempt from disclosure,” the judgment read.

This means the case will now return to the same court in which it was ruled thatthe report should be released.

Although a majority judgment, the bench was split on the matter, with Judge Edwin Cameron leading a dissenting judgment stating that the presidency had failed to justify its refusal to release the report, further arguing for its immediate release.

M&G editor-in-chief Nic Dawes said the ruling was very disappointing.

“It has been over three years since we applied for this report to be released,” said Dawes. “They have decided to send this back to the high court — meaning a further delay in an already very long and drawn out process.”

“It’s also disappointing in that it was a very narrowly split decision with four judges deciding we should have the report and five judges deciding otherwise,” Dawes added.

The M&G has vowed to continue the fight to have the report released.

“This is far from being an outright defeat,” Dawes said. “I haven’t had an in-depth look at the judgment, but it looks as though it makes some strong comments about the responsibility of the state to make information available as part of Paia. We still have the opportunity in the high court to win access to the document that we believe South Africans have a right to know about.”

For more on the M&G‘s bid to force the president to release the 2002 Zimbabwe election report view our special report

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Nickolaus Bauer
Nickolaus Bauer is the Mail & Guardian's jack of all trades news reporter that chases down stories ranging from politics and sports to big business and social justice. Armed with an iPad, SLR camera, camcorder and dictaphone, he aims to fight ignorance and pessimism through written words, photographs and videos. He believes South Africa could be the greatest country in the world if only her citizens would give her a chance to flourish instead of dwell on the negativity. When he's not begging his sub-editors for an extra twenty minutes after deadline, he's also known to dabble in the occasional poignant column that will leave you mulling around in the depths of your psyche. The quintessential workaholic, you can also catch him doing sports on the weekday breakfast show on SAfm and presenting the SAfm Sports Special over the weekend.

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Yengeni’s complaint against Zondo is legally uncertain

The chief justice was acting in a non-judicial capacity when chairing the state capture inquiry, so the complaint probably falls outside the law but underscores the risk of naming sitting judges to investigate political scandals

Covid-19 escalates xenophobia in South Africa – Report

Politicians have increasingly come under scrutiny for their alleged inflammatory comments which have been taken as endorsement by anti-foreigner activists

Metaverse: Virtual economy to pump $40bn into African GDP

A study suggests that the virtual world platform could plug more than 40 billion US dollars into the African economy in its first decade.

Bradley Carnell’s shot at US footballing greatness

St Louis City’s head coach has the opportunity to build a legacy from scratch at the midwest club, the latest franchise added to the Major League Soccer.

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…