To enjoy the full Mail & Guardian online experience: please upgrade your browser
05 Dec 2011 09:50
Argentina’s ties with Iran have been virtually frozen since Argentine authorities secured Interpol arrest warrants for five Iranians and a Lebanese in 2007 in connection with a 1994 attack on a Buenos Aires Jewish centre that killed 85 people.
Tehran denied links to the bombing but in July offered talks with Argentina to start “shedding light” on the case.
The 1994 attack came two years after a group called the Islamic Jihad Organisation, which was believed to be linked to Iran and the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah, claimed responsibility for bombing the Israeli embassy in Buenos Aires, killing 29.
For more than a decade Argentina appeared to do little to investigate the attacks. But when Nestor Kirchner became president in 2003 he vowed to reopen the cases, calling the neglect “a national disgrace”.
Several years later former Iranian president Ali Rafsanjani was among those indicted by Argentine prosecutors and sought by Interpol.
But there have been signs of a thaw in the two nations’ frosty ties.
Argentine exports to Iran, which dropped to a few tens of millions of dollars annually amid sour relations, have grown in recent years, soaring more than 70% last year to $1.5-billion.
“As the rest of us work to pressure Iran to end its nuclear weapons program and stop supporting terrorism, Argentina’s government has been considering moving in the opposite direction,” a European envoy said on condition of anonymity.
On the surface, Argentina’s positions on Iran appear little changed. In May, Argentine prosecutor Alberto Nisman, who heads a special unit dedicated exclusively to investigating the 1994 bombing, had the Interpol arrest warrants renewed.
Last month, Argentina joined a majority of United Nations member states in the General Assembly’s human rights committee to vote for a resolution condemning Iran for its human rights record.
Things are changing
But there are signs that things are changing. In September, Argentine President Cristina Fernandez told the United Nations General Assembly that Buenos Aires was ready to engage in dialogue with Iran, though she also urged Tehran to make good on its offer to help investigate the bombing.
“This is an offer to dialogue that Argentina cannot and should not turn down,” Fernandez said in her speech.
Western United Nations envoys said eyebrows were raised in the General Assembly when Argentina’s United Nations ambassador Jorge Arguello broke with tradition and remained seated as Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad blasted Israel, Europe and the United States in his speech to United Nations member states.
In previous years, the Argentine seat was left empty when the Iranian president addressed the 193-nation assembly. As United States and European officials exited the hall to protest Ahmadinejad’s typically fiery speech, Arguello stayed put.
“Iran and Argentina have recently been taking a number of overt steps - in some cases in response to pressure brought to bear by Iran - to open a clean slate in the countries’ political relations,” a Western diplomat said.
Iran has every reason to want to mend relations with Argentina. Under sanctions and increasingly isolated due to its nuclear program, Tehran has few allies and needs friends. Argentina is also on the 35-nation board of the United Nations nuclear watchdog, where Iran’s nuclear program is a key issue.
Diplomats said Argentina’s motives for warming up to Iran were unclear. In addition to boosting trade with Iran, some envoys said Argentina was pursuing a Brazilian-style foreign policy emphasising ties with non-aligned developing nations.
“In general, we see a ‘Third Worldism’ in Argentina’s foreign policy—asserting independence from the big powers, seeking out new relations with countries like Iran,” an Israeli official in Jerusalem said.
Several European diplomats noted that Fernandez is a close ally of regional leftists like Venezuela’s Hugo Chavez and Bolivia’s Evo Morales, who have warm ties with Iran.
Argentine foreign ministry officials did not respond to requests from Reuters for comment.
Iran’s nuclear program was one of the topics United States President Barack Obama brought up during his meeting with Fernandez last month on the sidelines of a Group of 20 meeting in France.
“The president also underscored the importance of continued United States-Argentine cooperation related to Iran,” a senior Obama administration official said.
The United States has had its own difficulties with Fernandez’s government. There are concerns about unresolved payments to United States firms and bondholders. In February, Argentine officials seized guns, ammunition and communications equipment from a United States Air Force plane that had landed in Argentina. The items were later returned but the incident annoyed Washington.
Foreign Minister Hector Timerman has also criticised United States policies in Latin America.
The Jewish community in Argentina, the largest in Latin America, has also grown increasingly worried since the Argentine newspaper Perfil reported in March that Timerman was holding secret negotiations with Iranian officials and had offered to drop the investigation into the 1994 attack.
“We’ve expressed our unease about attitudes toward Iran,” Aldo Donzis, president of Argentina’s DAIA Jewish community group, said about the apparent warming of relations.
That unease is shared by Israel. The Israeli official said Argentina was unlikely to push hard on the arrest warrants for the 1994 attack: “The sense here is that they’re unlikely to pull out the stops in order to see the warrants enforced.”
Suspicions about Iranian intentions in Argentina continue to this day. Earlier this year, Saudi Arabia warned Argentina of a possible Iran-backed plan to attack Saudi and Israeli embassies in Buenos Aires that ran parallel to a a plan to kill the Saudi United States envoy, an Argentine diplomatic source said.
Tehran denied allegations that it planned such attacks.
In a recent interview with Reuters, Mohammad Javad Larijani, a senior Iranian official and adviser to the country’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, said Iran would like repair ties with Buenos Aires that were damaged by Israel.
“Relations between Iran and Argentina have been the subject of Israeli sabotage,” he said. “I don’t think there is any basic difficulty in redeveloping our relations.”
He also dismissed the idea that the arrest warrants would lead to any action by Iran or Argentina, describing them as “obsolete”. Larijani added that Iran was working to expand its presence in, and trade with, South America.
European diplomats, however, said that there were limits on how close Argentina can get to Iran.
Not only would the government want to avoid unduly angering Washington, dropping the investigation of the 1994 attack altogether, as Iran would like, would be very difficult.
“Argentina has always taken a strong public line on Iran,” an envoy said. “Another line would be political suicide.”—Reuters
Create Account | Lost Your Password?