Minister dodges apology to blue-light victim again

Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa has launched a last-ditch attempt to avoid having to apologise to Chumani Maxwele, the Cape Town student who was arrested and abused by police after being accused of showing his middle finger to President Jacob Zuma’s motorcade.

Mthethwa has now applied for a review of an appeal finding by the South African Human Rights Commission, which upheld its earlier ruling that he should apologise to Maxwele. A disappointed Maxwele is frustrated by the minister’s stance. He said that by continuing to fight the issue, Mthethwa was sending out a message that he was protecting the officers who had infringed his human rights.

“An apology means a lot because it exonerates me,” said Maxwele. “This is a straightforward case, but by dragging out this matter the minister appears [to be] protective of those police officers who have done wrong.”

After his arrest while jogging on the M3 highway towards the University of Cape Town in February 2010, Maxwele was bundled into a police VIP protection vehicle, hooded and had his hands tied behind his back. The 25-year-old ­jogger was held in police custody for 24 hours and interrogated by intelligence agents about his ANC affiliations. He was forced under duress to write a letter of apology to Zuma.

Maxwele believes an apology from Mthethwa will instil public confidence in the police and encourage others to come forward with complaints. Nichola de Havilland, the director of the FW De Klerk Foundation’s centre for constitutional rights, which lodged a complaint on Maxwele’s behalf, said a rapid finalisation of the case was imperative.

She said the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act stipulated that judicial review proceedings had to be instituted without delay and she would call for an early review to avoid the matter dragging on for years. “There is absolutely no legal justification for the review and clearly the minister is simply buying time. Until there is finalisation, the VIP unit will continue to act as a law unto themselves.”

Zweli Mnisi, spokesperson for Mthethwa, said the minister was following legitimate legal processes that any South African was entitled to access. Mnisi dismissed De Havilland’s claims that the VIP unit would continue to act unlawfully until the minister apologised to Maxwele and said her comments about the blue-light brigade were “a sweeping generalisation”.

Numerous complaints
Democratic Alliance leader Helen Zille has gone further in her condemnation of the behaviour of the VIP protection unit, describing its members as “presidential blue-light bullies” after a string of serious incidents highlighted their actions. The conduct of members of the blue-light brigade has led to numerous complaints against the VIP unit.

There has been a public outcry over incidents such as the assault in 2009 of a motorist who got “too close” to a vehicle in Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe’s motorcade on the N12 highway near Johannesburg. When a pedestrian was killed by a VIP protection unit vehicle in Zuma’s convoy in Ulundi that same year, the regional head of the unit, Commander Mzondeki Tshabalala, was quoted by News24 as saying that the public did not respect the unit’s vehicles, or those of the police, and simply refused to “move out of the way”.

De Havilland believes the recent calls for the banning of the blue-light brigade would be unnecessary if the minister apologised. In its findings the commission told Mthethwa to apologise to Maxwele after it found that the unit had violated Maxwele’s constitutional rights to human dignity, freedom and security, privacy, freedom of expression, peaceful and unarmed demonstration and political choice. The police had also infringed his rights as a detained person, the commission found.

It criticised the police’s initial failure to respond “timeously and substantively” to its correspondence about the case. Based on Maxwele’s undisputed complaint and the investigation conducted by the commission, it called on Mthethwa to apologise within 30 days.

As well as an apology, the commission ruled that the South African Police Service should compile a programme, including plans and time frames, for the education of its ­members – specifically the members of the VIP unit — regarding their duty to act in accordance with the Constitution and the law.

“The minister of police, on behalf of all the members or employees who were involved in the incident, must make a full written apology to Maxwele for their unlawful and unconstitutional behaviour,” the commission stated. The minister appealed against the finding on the basis that Maxwele had lodged a civil claim for damages and his involvement in the commission’s investigation could prejudice court proceedings.

In its findings on appeal the commission stated that although there was no direct evidence that the minister had purposefully intended to undermine and disregard the commission, his conduct during its investigation had led them to believe he was doing that.

“These unnecessary delays compromise the commission in fulfilling its mandate to the Constitution, which specifically protects the fundamental rights of all citizens, the complainant in particular,” it said.

The commission found that the matter involved a dispute over human rights and that it fell within its scope and mandate. The fact that the case would come before a court of law did not preclude the commission from proceeding with its own investigation, it found. Maxwele is claiming R1.45-million from the police for his ordeal.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories

Cradock Four back to haunt De Klerk

Pressure is mounting on the NPA to charge the former president and others involved in political killings during apartheid

De Klerk now admits apartheid was a crime against humanity

Apartheid’s last president walks back comments that definition was a Soviet plot

Slice of Life: The harsh light shines on purpose

The #RhodesMustFall movement may have began because of a statue but it did so much more

FW de Klerk Foundation responds to the M&G’s apology

The FW de Klerk Foundation responds to the Mail & Guardian's apology over a story published in the paper, regarding FW de Klerk.

The DA responds to the M&G’s apology

The Democratic Alliance responds to the Mail & Guardian's apology over a story published in the paper, regarding its leader, Mmusi Maimane.

Day of reckoning for SABC’s Motsoeneng

But there's no sign yet that Communications Minister Faith Muthambi will be asked to explain her role in Hlaudi Motsoeneng's rise to the top.

Subscribers only

Toxic power struggle hits public works

With infighting and allegations of corruption and poor planning, the department’s top management looks like a scene from ‘Survivor’

Free State branches gun for Ace

Parts of the provincial ANC will target their former premier, Magashule, and the Free State PEC in a rolling mass action campaign

More top stories

WSU suspends classes and exams to avoid the spread of...

The university says it has to take the precautionary measures because 26 students have tested positive on its East London campus

Entrepreneurs strike Covid gold

Some enterprising people found ways for their ventures to survive the strictest lockdown levels

Ithala backs its embattled chairperson

Roshan Morar is being investigated in connection with KwaZulu-Natal education department backpack sanitiser tender worth R4-million and a batch of face masks that vanished

Emery Mwazulu Diyabanza: Liberating Africa from land of liberté

The cultural and political activist is on a quest to bring looted treasures back home

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday