Union, regulator disappointed at Fidentia boss sentence

"The FSB believes that the fine of R150 000 or 36 months in prison does not acknowledge the extent of the damage caused by Mr [J Arthur] Brown's actions," spokesperson Tembisa Marele said.

The National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) and Cosatu echoed these sentiments.

"The union is highly disappointed at the light sentence and the discrepancies in judgments passed by our justice system," said the NUM spokesperson Lesiba Seshoka.

"Cosatu thinks the sentence is entirely inappropriate and just reinforces the view that if you have money you will not be held to account," spokesperson Patrick Craven said.

Brown was recently convicted after admitting to misrepresentations he made regarding investments entrusted to him.

Western Cape High Court judge Anton Veldhuizen handed down Brown's sentence on Wednesday.

Veldhuizen said a R75 000 fine, or 18 months imprisonment, was being applied for each of two fraud counts.

Brown was also given an 18-month jail sentence on each count, but these were suspended for four years on condition he not be convicted of fraud again.

No deterrent
Marele said the two counts on which Brown was convicted involved funds intended for the beneficiaries of Mantadia [Matco], subsequently renamed the Living Hands Umbrella Trust.

"It is the FSB's view that today's sentence neither acts as a deterrent, nor does it send the right message to other white collar criminals," she said.

The sentence also did "very little" to inspire confidence in South Africa's judiciary.

The FSB nonetheless respected the court's decision, but hoped the state would appeal for a harsher sentence.

Seshoka said the Mantadia asset trust company was responsible for paying money from the mineworkers' provident fund to the widows and orphans of workers killed in mine accidents.

He said the union was, therefore, angered at the light sentence Brown received.

"Not so long ago, someone who stole R100 was sentenced to 10 years," he said.

Craven said Cosatu was "outraged" that Brown's sentence was not heavier and called on government to review the court's dismissal of other charges against Brown.

The state originally laid 192 charges against Brown.

Protest action
"We call on government to announce on its intention to appeal by [Monday], failing which we will embark on protest actions at the Western Cape High Court until clear commitments are given for some prosecutorial actions," Craven said.

Sentencing Brown, Veldhuizen said he had not been convicted of stealing millions from pensioners and Fidentia, or of defrauding either party.

Rather, the fraud of which Brown was convicted of was "an extremely diluted version of fraud, which the indictment alleges".

He criticised the state's handling of the case, and asked why the FSB's chief financial officer Dawood Seedat was called to testify only after Brown was convicted.

Seedat testified in aggravation of Brown's sentence. – Sapa

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Guest Author

Related stories


Subscribers only

Come what may, the UIF will pay

The fund – the main safety net for unemployed workers – will run at an almost R20-billion deficit

‘Terrorised’ family shines a light on traditional leadership for vulnerable...

The ambiguity between traditional and constitutional leadership has been exposed by the violent banishment of an Eastern Cape family

More top stories

High court grants Dlamini-Zuma leave to appeal adverse ruling on...

The court held that the ongoing state of disaster meant there was public interest in the legal test applied to measures taken to contain the pandemic

Concourt to hear Zondo commission’s application for contempt order against...

The former president has one week to file answering papers in the application that also seeks a prison sentence imposed on him

Koko maintains he had no idea he was exchanging emails...

On his fourth appearance before the commission, the former Eskom CEO maintains he was tricked into sharing company information with a third party

Zuma foundation claims ex-president was prepared to testify, but Zondo...

Zuma’s namesake organisation twists facts and the law – he told Zondo he would answer questions but only in private to the deputy chief justice

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…