Fight to net sea lion’s share of pilchard market heats up

The battle for the local fishing quotas of the lucrative pilchard sector, which forms part of the staple diet of millions of South Africans, has found its way to the Competition Tribunal.

The tribunal is trying to weigh up potential job losses against concerns of a possible monopoly around a primary protein source, in this case by Oceana, which has already paid a R35?million admission of guilt fine for alleged price fixing in the pelagic fish sector, which includes pilchards.

It is alleged to have colluded with other firms about payment for trawlers and crew.

Oceana, which owns pilchard brand Lucky Star and has 73% of the market, has asked the tribunal to overturn a decision by the Competition Commission.

The commission ruling allows the merger with Foodcorp's R445?million fishing business, but stipulates that Foodcorp's pilchard brand Glenryck has to be sold with its fishing rights to retain competition in the sector.

Oceana had planned to sell the brand and keep the fishing quota, which would have given it 80% of the local pilchard market.

Fishing quotas for pilchards decrease
Lucky Star managing director Gavin Rhodes-Harrison said that fishing quotas for pilchards have steadily decreased and admitted that the acquisition of Glenryck's 11% allocation would allow it to reduce its dependence on imports, which are taking their toll in light of the weak rand.

Lucky Star has 15.01% of the fishing allocation and the company imports 60% of its pilchard requirements. It also had a tough year as sales among cash-strapped consumers fell and quotas remained constrained.

Oceana has warned of increased competitors from outside the country, such as Thai Union (one of the largest exporters of fish in the world) and Tropical.

Both have their eye on the South African market, regarded as the "biggest round-can market in the world", and plan to look at ways to enter it "perhaps more aggressively" than they have done in the past.

It's the latest chapter in a conflict-ridden industry, where fights about the allocation of fishing quotas have seen disgruntled fishermen storm the offices of the department of agriculture, forestry and fisheries, most recently accusing deputy director general Desmond Stevens of racism against coloured fishermen who lost their previous quota licences.

Foodcorp testified before the tribunal that it made the decision to sell its fishing business and concentrate on "less risky" sectors after three years of failing to find a black economic empowerment (BEE) partner.

Locked in a legal battle
Foodcorp managing director Josias Andreas van Niekerk said: "What happened in March 2010 [was] our majority black shareholder sold its shares in Foodcorp and that impacted on our BEE shareholding. And since then we [have been] locked in a legal battle with the department of fisheries."

Foodcorp's fishing business consists essentially of harvesting, processing and selling deep-sea trawl hake, South Coast rock lobster and small pelagic fish, such as pilchards and anchovies — the same functions as Oceana.

The Competition Commission said the proposed merger would have the effect of removing Oceana's closest competitor. It stipulated that the Glenryck brand and fishing rights needed to be sold to a strong competitor in the sector, which could provide "real" competition to Oceana.

Ironically, it emerged during the cross-examination of Foodcorp's fishing division managing director that one of the first bidders for BEE partnership was the Umkhonto weSizwe Military Veterans' Association, of which fisheries deputy director general Stevens is treasurer general. The deal fell through.

Other companies that held talks with Foodcorp include Pioneer Fishing, Thebe Investment Corporation, Oceana, Viking Fishing, Balindi Sanqela Consortium and I&J.

In his testimony, Van Niekerk said that Foodcorp's plight had become increasingly desperate after the Thebe offer fell through because of funding problems. He said there was obvious relief after the deal with Oceana received approval from the fisheries department.

"Ambitious plans"
Bidfish Namibia, a subsidiary of the Bidvest Group, has offered to buy the Glenryck brand, saying South Africa's quota allocations would be of no use to it. The tribunal heard that Bidfish has "ambitious plans for the brand" as it is well placed to be a competitor.

Also at stake is Foodcorp's Laaiplek processing factory, where about 1 000 jobs are at stake, which Oceana said it will take over and guarantee.

Greta Engelbrecht, advocate for the Competition Commission, told the tribunal that the fishing quota was essential if Glenryck was to be a real competitor in the sector.

Her concern was that any competitor without local fishing rights would be more dependent on imported fish, which, at present rand rates, would affect its ability to offer affordable canned pilchards.

Lawyers for Oceana insist that there would be sufficient supply from smaller fishing companies in the market to keep Glenryck supplied with stock and two independent canneries to serve the company.

On behalf of Oceana, David Unterhalter said it could not exclude any company from obtaining processing capacity or using existing processing facilities.

Economic data shows that Oceana dominates the South African canned fish market. Five years ago the company was trading at R17 on the JSE and is now close to R83. It has a price-to-earnings ratio of 17.04.

The three-day hearing has been extended to allow for further witnesses, but a date has yet to be set for it to resume.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories

Companies need to plan for the future through skills development

COMMENT: Businesses need to focus on the training the so-called soft skills needed to respond to an ever-changing environment

See people as individual humans, not as a race

We need to ingrain values of equality in education, businesses, society broadly and religious groups to see people

Africa needs businesses that build and strengthen the continent

Africans should know by now that they can’t depend on leaders and should rather learn to do it themselves

Zuma vs Ramaphosa? Neither is the leader South Africans deserve

Neither statesman could command sufficient authority in an ANC that remains mired in corruption and infighting and at the behest of big capital

Sars plan for illicit tobacco still being refined

Meanwhile, billions of illegal cigarettes are flooding the informal markets as lockdown regulations are lifted at last

Women are South Africa’s changemakers and they deserve more

The truth is the economy still largely revolves around men, especially white men like me, writes Alef Meulenberg.

Subscribers only

Q&A Sessions: Frank Chikane on the rainbow where colours never...

Reverend Frank Chikane has just completed six years as the chairperson of the Kagiso Trust. He speaks about corruption, his children’s views and how churches can be mobilised

ANC: ‘We’re operating under conditions of anarchy’

In its latest policy documents, the ANC is self-critical and wants ‘consequence management’, yet it’s letting its members off the hook again

More top stories

War of words at Zondo commission: ‘Grow up Mr Gordhan,...

The cross-examination of the public enterprises minister by Tom Moyane’s lawyers at the state capture inquiry went on well into overtime on Monday evening

‘Where the governments see statistics, I see the faces of...

Yvette Raphael describes herself as a ‘professional protester, sjambok feminist and hater of trash’. Government officials would likely refer to her as ‘a rebel’. She’s fought for equality her entire life, she says. And she’s scared of no one

Covid-19 stems ‘white’ gold rush

The pandemic hit abalone farmers fast and hard. Prices have dropped and backers appear to be losing their appetite for investing in the delicacy

Al-Shabab’s terror in Mozambique

Amid reports of brutal, indiscriminate slaughter, civilians bear the brunt as villages are abandoned and the number of refugees nears half a million

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…