Motshekga: ‘We can’t be perfect’

Failing to provide all textbooks to every single pupil is not a violation of their rights, Basic Education Minister Angie Motshekga says in papers filed at the Constitutional Court. Doing so would amount to a level of “perfection” that Motshekga says she does not need to achieve.

She and her department are asking the court to dismiss the ruling that Judge Neil Tuchten handed down on May 5 in the latest Limpopo textbook case.

In her application, Motshekga disagrees with Tuchten’s judgment that, if the government fails to deliver one textbook to one pupil, this constitutes a failure to realise the right to basic education for that pupil.

But “in respect of the provision of socioeconomic rights – basic education being one of such rights – perfection is not the standard required from the applicants”, the appeal argues.

At the end of April, nongovernmental organisation Basic Education for All (Befa) and 18 schools, represented by Section27, launched legal action against the department.

Budgetary constraints
The parties argued before Tuchten that budgetary constraints and the failure of school principals to report shortages had caused the delay in deliveries.

Tuchten ruled that this delay was a violation of the affected pupils’ rights. “If there is one learner who is not timeously provided with her textbooks, her right has been infringed,” he said. He also ordered the department to report to the applicants on the submissions it will make to the fiscal authorities for the funds it will need for next year’s textbooks.

But the minister and her department now argue that the Constitutional Court has already “rejected … the notion that social and economic rights contain a minimum core that the state is obliged to furnish”.

Their appeal here cites a prior judgment involving the City of Johannesburg’s provision of water to residents.

School hours
And anyway, the department says in its papers, government policy “does not stipulate that each and every textbook has to be delivered to each and every learner, but only provides for access to … textbooks during and after school hours”.


Tuchten’s contrary ruling on this point referred to Judge Jody Kollapen’s finding in the original court action, which Section27 launched in 2012 during the Limpopo textbooks crisis.

In that case, Tuchten said, Kollapen “found that the provision of textbooks was indeed a component of basic education”.

“The dictum of Kollapen … is binding on me unless I find it is clearly wrong … I think, with respect, that the learned judge was right.”

Motshekga’s appeal does not actually mention Kollapen’s prior judgment, but argues that the true test of whether the government had provided basic education to pupils was whether it had taken reasonable measures to realise this right. The department’s actions to remedy shortages this year amounted to “much more than reasonable measures”, it submits.

Balanced out
By the time the department was taken to court this year, only about 2% of textbooks still had to be delivered, the appeal says. Any adverse effects the shortage had on pupils would be balanced out by “tuition given by teachers”, photocopies “of the relevant portions from the textbooks”, notes written on the blackboard, workbooks and pupils sharing textbooks.

Tuchten’s judgment said such measures are inadequate: “An inattentive pupil may miss entirely what the teacher is saying, with no way of retrieving the information being imparted. Notes prepared by teachers will vary in quality from one individual to another.

“The absence of textbooks places an additional workload on the teacher. And there is evidence before me that in some schools in Limpopo there are no copying facilities.”

Regarding Tuchten’s ruling that the department must report back on its funding plan for 2015’s textbooks, the appeal says “this has to be dealt with in terms of the relevant provisions of the Promotion of Access to Information Act”. It also argues that Basic Education for All can only resort to this Act after having exhausted an “internal appeal procedure”.

Departmental spokesperson Elijah Mhlanga told the Mail & Guardian that it had “no further comment” on the matter.

Nikki Stein, an attorney at Section27, and Befa declined to comment.

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever. But it comes at a cost. Advertisers are cancelling campaigns, and our live events have come to an abrupt halt. Our income has been slashed.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years. We’ve survived thanks to the support of our readers, we will need you to help us get through this.

To help us ensure another 35 future years of fiercely independent journalism, please subscribe.

Advertising

Coalition politics and law: The fight over Tshwane

With coalition politics on the rise, particularly in local government, this kind of court case is likely to become more common

High court declares Dudu Myeni delinquent

Disgraced former SAA chairperson Dudu Myeni has been declared a delinquent director by the...

SANDF inquiry clears soldiers of the death of Collins Khosa

The board of inquiry also found that it was Khosa and his brother-in-law Thabiso Muvhango who caused the altercation with the defence force members

No back to school for teachers just yet

Last week the basic education minister was adamant that teachers will return to school on May 25, but some provinces say not all Covid-19 measures are in place to prevent its spread
Advertising

Press Releases

Road to recovery for the tourism sector: The South African perspective

The best-case scenario is that South Africa's tourism sector’s recovery will only begin in earnest towards the end of this year

What Africa can learn from Cuba in combating the Covid-19 pandemic

Africa should abandon the neoliberal path to be able to deal with Covid-19 and other health system challenges likely to emerge in future

Coexisting with Covid-19: Saving lives and the economy in India

A staggered exit from the lockdown accompanied by stepped-up testing to cover every district is necessary for India right now

Covid-19: Eased lockdown and rule of law Webinar

If you are arrested and fined in lockdown, you do get a criminal record if you pay the admission of guilt fine

Covid-19 and Frontline Workers

Who is caring for the healthcare workers? 'Working together is how we are going to get through this. It’s not just a marathon, it’s a relay'.

PPS webinar Part 2: Small business, big risk

The risks that businesses face and how they can be dealt with are something all business owners should be well acquainted with

Call for applications for the position of GCRO executive director

The Gauteng City-Region Observatory is seeking to appoint a high-calibre researcher and manager to be the executive director and to lead it

DriveRisk stays safe with high-tech thermal camera solution

Itec Evolve installed the screening device within a few days to help the driver behaviour company become compliant with health and safety regulations

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday