Police minister’s Nkandla report misses the key point

The conflicting official reports on the R246-million security upgrade at President Jacob Zuma’s private home in Nkandla, in all their disorienting secrecy and semantic manoeuvring, have left South Africans more confused and frustrated than ever. The political debate now revolves around one obvious question: was any of this money spent on nonsecurity comforts?

Yes, said public protector Thuli Madonsela in her report last year, and the president must therefore pay back a “reasonable percentage” of the amount spent on his new visitors’ centre, amphitheatre, cattle kraal, chicken run and swimming pool.

No, said Police Minister Nathi Nhleko in his report last month: these were all vital “security features”, for which the president “is therefore not liable to pay”.

Both are wrong.

The applicable law clearly states that even essential security measures must be paid for by the owner of the property being upgraded, even if he has not asked for or agreed to the upgrade. This draconian version of the “user pays” principle is found in the National Key Points Act, passed by apartheid securocrats in 1980 but still in force and still implemented by the current security cluster.

Sidestepping this, Nhleko’s report finds that “cost determination could not have been informed by the National Key Points Act, as it is not applicable in this particular instance”. He offers no official reasons for this conclusion, but the real reason is clear. What’s more, Nhleko is contradicted by the evidence obtained by amaBhungane in its lengthy legal fight for the Nkandla files under the Promotion of Access to Information Act.

Foremost is the 2010 certificate declaring Zuma’s Nkandla home a national key point, signed by Nhleko’s predecessor, Nathi Mthethwa, and explicitly acknowledged by the presidency.

In it, Zuma’s “attention is drawn specifically” to the section of the Act that makes him liable to pay for all security upgrades. It also tells him unambiguously that, as the owner, he is obliged to implement them “at own cost”. It even advises him that he “can submit a claim for tax deduction in respect of expenditure incurred on security measures”.

In 2013, the interministerial task team, in which Nhleko’s department played a key part, confirmed that the National Key Points Act applied, and even exploited that fact to classify their report “top secret”.

But they omitted the part about payment, only lamenting that “a Special Account was not established”, which could be used under the Act to provide “financial assistance, including loans” to owners implementing security upgrades.

Finally, Zuma himself, in his report to Parliament last year, acknowledged he had been advised that Nkandla was declared a national key point, and for that reason he instructed Nhleko, “as the designated minister under the National Key Points Act, to report to Cabinet on a determination as to whether the president is liable for any contribution in respect of the security upgrades”.

Nhleko did not do this. Instead, he sought to supplant the Act with a 2003 Cabinet memorandum that imposes no costs on the owner and no cap on costs to the state. But no Cabinet policy can trump an Act of Parliament. Nor can any number of video demonstrations.

No report can rewrite the facts and the law governing the Nkandla upgrade, hence the inescapable conclusion: Zuma must pay back the money.

Ben Winks is part of the Webber Wentzel legal team acting for amaBhungane in its case for access to the Nkandla files


Study unpacks the ‘hidden racism’ at Stellenbosch

Students say they feel unseen and unheard at the university because of their skin colour

Workers’ R60m ‘lost’ in banks scam

An asset manager, VBS Mutual Bank and a Namibian bank have put the retirement funds of 26 000 municipal workers in South Africa at risk

‘Judge President Hlophe tried to influence allocation of judges to...

Deputy Judge President Patricia Goliath accuses Hlophe of attempting to influence her to allocate the case to judges he perceived as ‘favourably disposed’ to former president Jacob Zuma

SAA grounds flights due to low demand

SAA is working to accommodate customers on its sister airlines after it cancelled flights due to low demand

Press Releases

MTN unveils TikTok bundles

Customised MTN TikTok data bundles are available to all prepaid customers on *136*2#.

Marketers need to reinvent themselves

Marketing is an exciting discipline, offering the perfect fit for individuals who are equally interested in business, human dynamics and strategic thinking. But the...

Upskill yourself to land your dream job in 2020

If you received admission to an IIE Higher Certificate qualification, once you have graduated, you can articulate to an IIE Diploma and then IIE Bachelor's degree at IIE Rosebank College.

South Africans unsure of what to expect in 2020

Almost half (49%) of South Africans, 15 years and older, agree or strongly agree that they view 2020 with optimism.

KZN teacher educators jet off to Columbia University

A group of academics were selected as participants of the programme focused on PhD completion, mobility, supervision capacity development and the generation of high-impact research.

New-style star accretion bursts dazzle astronomers

Associate Professor James O Chibueze and Dr SP van den Heever are part of an international team of astronomers studying the G358-MM1 high-mass protostar.

2020 risk outlook: Use GRC to build resilience

GRC activities can be used profitably to develop an integrated risk picture and response, says ContinuitySA.

MTN voted best mobile network

An independent report found MTN to be the best mobile network in SA in the fourth quarter of 2019.