Court sets aside R1-trillion nuclear deals SA with Russia, US and South Korea

The Western Cape High Court has set aside nuclear agreements signed by government with vendor countries, declaring them unlawful and unconstitutional. These deals were with Russia, the United States and South Korea.

The judgment comes after Earthlife Africa and the South African Faith Communities’ Environment Institute approached the court in October 2015, challenging government’s decision to buy up to 9 600MW of nuclear energy.

They argued that the minister of energy, then Tina Joemat-Pettersson, had signed the agreements without a debate in Parliament. This was based on her department’s interpretation of Section 231 of the Constitution, which outlines two procedures by which South Africa becomes bound to an international agreement.

The first is more onerous, and requires that Parliament must approve any agreement. The second, used for “technical, administrative or executive” agreements, just asks that agreements be tabled before Parliament “within a reasonable time”. In practice, and according to the Office of the Chief State Law Adviser, that time is one year.

The South Korean agreement was signed in 2010, and the US one in 2009. But both were tabled only in June 2015.

For the Russian agreement – the Strategic Partnership on Nuclear Power and Industry – the state argued that it did not need to be debated in Parliament because it had the legal standing of an international agreement. But in their court papers, Earthlife and the faith institute included a memo from the state law adviser, which said the agreement needed approval by a resolution of Parliament. The memo was presented in Parliament when the agreement was tabled.

In its ruling, the high court sided with the applicants and set aside all three agreements.

Follow the Mail & Guardian for more updates on this developing story.

Keep the powerful accountable

Subscribe for R30/mth for the first three months. Cancel anytime.

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.

Sipho Kings
Sipho Kings is the acting editor-in-chief of the Mail & Guardian

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Zondo dismisses Fraser’s application to cross-examine witnesses

The former head of the State Security Agency and Zuma ally did not come close to complying with the state capture inquiry’s rules for cross-examination, Zondo said

Hawks head testifies before SAHRC: Intelligence would have been ‘ideal’

No members of the police, defence force or state security have been implicated ‘at this stage’ in ongoing investigations into the July unrest in KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng

A to Z guide on HIV: The top 10 things...

The HIV pandemic isn’t going anywhere until a cure is found. In the meantime, HIV clinicians say South Africa should protect its victories

PODCAST: How South Africa fits into the global economy, pt...

Michael Power chats to the M&G editor-in-chief and business journalists about South Africa and its place in the global economy

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…