The writing is on the wall for medical aids

The days of private medical aid schemes may be numbered as the government this week confirmed that it will become the single funder and buyer of medical services under a National Health Insurance (NHI) in the latest white paper approved by the Cabinet.

Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi released the NHI white paper in Pretoria on Thursday. The document sketches out the details of the future NHI Fund through which it will pay for medical services – whether in public or private facilities – for all South Africans.

The fund, which will report to Parliament and be governed by an independent board, will be financed by mandatory contributions.

Whether NHI-specific taxes will be introduced will be decided by the treasury. Yet, Motsoaledi said he was confident that Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba would remain true to former minister Pravin Gordhan’s word when he committed to ending tax credits for private medical aid members and diverting that money to the NHI.

Medical aid members, including state employees, received R20-billion in tax credits in 2015 alone. Motsoaledi argues that high medical aid subsidies for state employees means that about 85% of healthcare costs for a member of the Government Employees Medical Scheme are paid for by the state.

“Part of the source of that NHI Fund has to come from the tax credits, meaning what? You are taking money that is being sent to people who are already rich to help those who are poor, and that is called social solidarity,” maintains Motsoaledi.

The Democratic Alliance has also supported the axing of tax benefits for medical aid members in its NHI alternative, called Our Health Plan.

Motsoaledi adds that the NHI or universal health coverage is the only way to redistribute the country’s heavily skewed resources.

“One private clinic, [Johannesburg’s] Netcare Park Lane Hospital, has 64 gynaecologists – that is more than the total in [government hospitals in] the North West, Limpopo and Mpumalanga added together,” he said.

“About 80% of doctors in this country serve only 16% of the population, [and] the remaining 20% of doctors must serve the rest – how can you expect not to have long queues [in the public sector]? The NHI must make [these doctors] available to the rest of the population and then there will no longer be long queues.”

Under the NHI, the government will be able to buy services from accredited private health facilities for even the poorest South Africans, at set rates. These rates will be determined by the fund in consultation with the health minister.

So even though medical aid schemes are likely to remain until the NHI is more established, their fate appears to be set in stone.

He explains: “Medical aids will have to give way because we want one similar system for everybody. We want one united pool of funds for everybody, and this will also make healthcare very cheap. If you have lots of health schemes all over the place, you are not able to control prices because you can’t use economies of scale.

“In the beginning, we will work with medical aids, but maybe 10 years from now, they will all have to be gone.”

Health department director general Precious Matsoso says she is already working with some medical aids to streamline the products they offer to help them to move members slowly on to one standard package of services that will mirror NHI offerings.

Meanwhile, about 1 000 private health facilities are already working with Matsoso to prepare to begin taking public patients.

But the private health sector isn’t the only one in for a shake-up. The NHI will take some power away from provinces, as 10 Acts will have to amended to make way for the coming healthcare revolution. Legislative changes will, for instance, put control of the country’s large teaching hospitals back in the minister’s hands.

The centralisation of some health functions may also translate into less money for provincial coffers as functions such as drug procurement are taken out of provinces’ hands – a move that some health activists may welcome, after years of protests over weak provincial health management.

Motsoaledi explains: “How many South Africans are happy with their cover and how many are not happy with any cover because they have nothing? People must appreciate that we want to be a nation where equality, social justice and social solidarity are the order of the day.”

No medical aid scheme had issued a statement in response to the new white paper at the time of going to press.


M&G Slow

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Laura López González
Laura López González is a freelance health journalist and editor with more than 15 years of experience covering global health. She is the former deputy editor of South Africa's Bhekisisa Centre for Health Journalism.

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

OPINION| New UK work visa to exclude graduates from Africa

If graduates did not get their qualifications from the list of top 50 universities, 40 of which are in the US, France, China, Hong Kong, Australia, Germany, Canada and Japan, they will be excluded

Hackers infiltrate SA illicit financial flows conference with porn clip

The conference was attended by state agencies, blue- chip global and local non-governmental agencies and public accountability experts

OPINION| South African audiences want more authentic and accurate diversity...

The media has the power to shape perceptions, so television shows and movies can help shape a positive view of people who feel stereotyped

Interdict threat over new Tendele coal mine in KwaZulu-Natal

Tendele Coal plans to open a new mine despite a court ruling that the licence was unlawfully granted

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…