Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Sassa debacle inquiry: Judge tells Dlamini to stop dodging questions

Social Development Minister Bathabile Dlamini evaded questions during cross-examination on Tuesday.

Dlamini was testifying at an inquiry into her personal role and liability in the 2017 social grants crisis, being held at the Office of the Chief Justice in Midrand.

On several occasions Judge Bernard Ngoepe had to intervene as Black Sash advocate Geoff Budlender attempted to get answers.

In one instance, Ngoepe became visibly upset with Dlamini, telling her to stop dodging simple questions.

“Minister, I’m going to have to note on record that you are not answering the question,” he said.

Budlender had asked Dlamini why she was contradicting herself on record. He said that, in her testimony on Monday, she had said that former Sassa CEO Thokozani Magwaza had never brought it to her attention that there was dissatisfaction at the social security agency over the established workstreams.

“Yesterday you said it was never brought to your attention that there was dissatisfaction … that is not true, because Magwaza brought it to your attention,” Budlender inquired.

Dlamini responded that Magwaza had only informed her later when the workstreams had been established.

‘Minister, please answer’

Dissatisfied with her response, Budlender asked Dlamini again why she had contradicted her own statements.

“For any impasse to be noted happened after Magwaza took office. This surprised me because he had initially agreed.”

Ngoepe then intervened, insisting that Dlamini respond to questions.

“For my own piece of mind, Mr Budlender repeat the question … minister, please answer,” Ngoepe said.

The minister then said she could only answer the question later, “after seeing Magwaza’s submissions”.

Ngoepe, running his hands acrooss his forehead in frustration, then told her: “We cannot keep repeating the same question, so what is the answer minister?”

A defiant Dlamini said: “With all due respect, I would like to see submissions before I would be able to respond.”

The Constitutional Court appointed Ngoepe to head the inquiry into whether Dlamini should be held personally liable for the costs incurred during the South Africa Social Security Agency (Sassa) payment crisis.

The inquiry is investigating whether Dlamini sought the appointment of individuals, to lead the various “workstreams”, who would report directly to her.

Minister reprimanded by translator

The three workstreams – which were “information and business management”, “banking services and project management, legislative and policy requirements management”, and “benefits and local economic development” – appeared to exist in parallel with the function of the department and Sassa.

The leaders of these workstreams acted as advisors to Dlamini, before they were appointed to lead the workstreams, a move that was said to be illegal and irregular.

Further, the Constitutional Court ordered the inquiry to investigate the details of the appointments in terms of when the individuals were appointed, who they reported to, and the details of the dates and contents of the workstream’s report to the minister. Lastly, the inquiry would consider why the minister did not disclose this information to the Constitutional Court, News24 earlier reported.

During the morning session, Dlamini often raised eyebrows by correcting her translator. She had elected to testify in isiZulu.

On several occasions, she would interject while the translator was speaking and make her own submissions in English.

On one such occasion, the translator reprimanded Dlamini, saying that she was not allowing him to do his job. Dlamini immediately apologised.

The hearings are continuing. — News24

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them.

Lizeka Tandwa
Lizeka Tandwa
Lizeka Tandwa is a political journalist with a keen interest in local government.

Related stories


If you’re reading this, you clearly have great taste

If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Subscribers only

SANDF’s ‘dignity’ comes with a R200mn price tag

Find out about the SANDF’s new uniform, which is costing taxpayers close to R200-million, while mission-critical equipment is not maintained

Roshan Morar’s fingers in every pie, including KZN education and...

The controversial auditor’s firm seconded staff to run the education department’s finance offices for more than 15 years. What’s more, former KZN education director general Cassius Lubisi is the audit firm’s new chair

More top stories

Ice skating champion shows off the Cape Flats talent at...

A young ice-skating champion has beaten the odds and brought home a national gold medal

Study finds too much salt can damage immune cell function

The study investigated how sodium intake affects human cells by giving participants 6g of salt in tablet form each day for 14 days, while they continued with their normal diets.

New plan to tackle marine pollution

The environment department’s Source-to-Sea initiative will create 1 600 work opportunities

Gigaba insists he faced sinister threat, slams court ruling on...

The former cabinet minister told the Zondo commission he cannot see how the court concluded there was no evidence of a plot to kill him

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…