Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

No racism in Willemse walk-out, says SuperSport

The independent review into the Ashwin Willemse walk-out has found that the conduct of Nick Mallett and Naas Botha “does not manifest naked racism and was not motivated by racist considerations”.

The former Springbok wing walked off of set last month after accusing co-hosts Nick Mallett and Naas Botha of patronising him. The broadcaster announced a few days later that all three would be pulled off the air while an independent mediator looks into the issue.

Advocate Vincent Maleka was elected to chair the review and his findings and recommendations were delivered at the Multichoice offices in Randburg this afternoon.

“That the conduct of Naas and Nick during the off-air conversation with Ashwin and during the live studio broadcast of the post-match commentary of the match “does not manifest naked racism and was not motivated by racist considerations,” the report read.

“Assisted by Prof Habib, Advocate Maleka SC also found that there was also no evidence of Naas or Nick exhibiting either intended or unintended subtle racism.”

Maleka draw on testimony from various sources, including Botha and Mallett. Willemse, however, refused to participate in the review. It’s a decision that indicative of frosty relations between the broadcaster and their analyst, and SuperSport CEO Gideon Khobane was eager to stress that he hopes to begin a process of reconciliation.

“In the spirit of reconciliation, I will make another attempt to reach out to Ashwin for us to find a mutually-acceptable way forward so that he knows that this issue has been fairly investigated,” he said in his statement at the Randburg offices.

Given that Willemse didn’t testify, SuperSport is unable to explain the exact reasoning behind Willemse’s decision to walk off of set.

The report indicates a mix-up over speaking time as one of the possible reasons.

“There are two factors which provide a reasonable explanation for the incident,” it reads. “The first is the (mistaken) technical assumption that there was enough time for all the analyst to express their pre-match analysis or commentary of the Lions/Brumbies rugby match. However, the switch to the live broadcast happened sooner than anticipated. Consequently, there was no time for Ashwin to express his views. The panel then agreed, off-air, that Ashwin would be given the first opportunity to speak after the game.

“The second is that it is reasonable to assume that Ashwin may have regarded the common stance adopted by Nick and Naas as patronising when they insisted that he should thereafter speak first.”

Khobane said SuperSport will be implementing all of the reports recommendations. Namely:

  • A forum will be established for the team of analysts to provide their views on the performance of the analysts (and possible room for improvement) during that specific broadcast, after each studio broadcast.
  • A code of conduct will be formulated for analysts including grievance procedures and credible mechanisms to resolve any grievances they may have.
  • Analysts will be required to operate the touch screen in the studio “across the colour-line”, even though the touch screen is the more complex of the functions on set.
  • Counselling will be offered to Motshidisi, Naas, Nick and Ashwin due to the emotional suffering all have endured from and since the incident.
  • SuperSport will take the additional step to refer the report to the SA Human Rights Commission.

Read the full report of the review commissioned by SuperSport:

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them.

Luke Feltham

Luke Feltham runs the Mail & Guardian's sports desk. He was previously the online day editor.

Related stories

Advertising

Subscribers only

GDP, recession, JSE, rallying rand … these terms mean very...

The economy is not producing work, with many young adults working outside their fields of study or considering leaving the country as a result

More top stories

New membership system encounters problems in ANC branches

The Lower South Coast region has complained of a plot by some branch secretaries to manipulate the system

Police analyst implicated in R600k fraud scheme

But the forensic analyst has also claimed to be a victim of identity fraud

Economy’s signs of life mean little for the poor

GDP growth may be encouraging but it doesn’t mean much for SA’s millions of unemployed

The ANC has moral decay on its plate, and the...

Analysis of news coverage in May shows a governing party that is broke — and bitterly at war with itself
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×