Reserve Bank: Auditors were part of the VBS Mutual Bank conspiracy

The audited financial statements of VBS Mutual Bank which were submitted to the Reserve Bank were not reliable, Parliament heard.

The standing committee on finance on Wednesday heard from the Reserve Bank governor Lesetja Kganyago, deputy governor Kuben Naidoo and others about the processes followed in handling VBS Mutual Bank’s curatorship. The Reserve Bank placed VBS under curatorship earlier this year as it was facing a liquidity crisis.

Naidoo shared what he believed was the “most salient” lesson learnt from the VBS matter.

“We overly relied on the audited financial statements [of VBS],” Naidoo said.

He explained that banks are expected to submit returns to the Reserve Bank, sometimes on a monthly or a quarterly basis. These returns must be signed off by the bank’s senior management, the CEO and auditors.

“It is quite obvious in hindsight that the data that was submitted on a monthly basis or a quarterly basis by VBS was not accurate, even though the auditors approved it,” he said. 

“That is why we were not able to pierce that veil because auditors were part of that conspiracy.”

Naidoo said this shows that other ways to verify financial statements must be explored, not only for small institutions but all banks.

It is a serious offence for banks to submit false data to the Reserve Bank. Banks could lose their licence or be imposed a significant fine. 

“If any bank giving us data on a monthly basis or quarterly basis – whether those are audited or not – if those are not accurate it is an incredibly serious violation,” Naidoo said.

He also explained why Nedbank was chosen to facilitate repayments to VBS deposit holders, as EFF MP Floyd Shivambu wanted to know if a proper bidding process had been followed.

Naidoo said that no competitive bidding process was followed, there were two criteria which had to be met, these are related to costs and geography. Based on the recommendation by the curator, Nedbank was chosen.

“The welfare of the depositors and the speed of execution was important,” Naidoo explained. We looked at banks offering similar products and their cost structure. We chose the bank with those products at the lowest fees. 

Kganyago suggested that the curator’s report be made available to the committee, to satisfy MPs of their choice.

Deputy governor Francois Groepe expressed disappointment that MPs were suggesting impropriety by the leadership of the bank. He said that the Reserve Bank had asked probing questions and debated before the final decision was taken.

“There is no hesitation of the leadership of the bank to avail the report outlining the process,” said Groepe. “It is a pity that aspersions are cast on leadership of the bank as to how the decision was made.” — Fin 24

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Lameez Omarjee
Lameez Omarjee
Parliamentary reporter at Fin24.com

Related stories

WELCOME TO YOUR M&G

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

Advertising

Latest stories

Iran ‘categorically’ denies link with Rushdie’s attacker

Rushdie, 75, was left on a ventilator with multiple stab wounds after he was attacked at a literary event Friday in western New York state

Defence minister Thandi Modise in Moscow for security conference

Discussions about Russia’s invasion of Ukraine are absent from the official programme

Ugandan student develops mosquito repellant from sour milk

The death of Jovia Kisaakye’s brother from malaria and the family’s struggle to sell fresh milk led to the new product

How the digital age has changed the existence of big...

The evolution of technology has changed how music is produced, removing the need to have a contract with a record label to do it. With more musicians choosing to be independent, are big recording companies becoming obsolete?
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×