​Bain & Co. ‘used’ for ulterior motives, Nugent commission hears

Bain & Company may have been used for an ulterior motive outside of improving the efficiency of the South African Revenue Service (SARS) when it was brought in to create and implement a new operational model by suspended commissioner Tom Moyane, the Nugent commission heard on Friday.

Vittorio Massone, managing partner at Bain & Co., has distanced the consulting firm from the way the final operating model and changes were implemented at Sars. These have been attributed as the reason for the breakdown in efficiency at the tax agency.

“With the benefit of hindsight think we can understand that there was an intent there. Having read transcripts, you can see how we might have been used,” said Massone.

Sars underwent massive changes in 2015 when Moyane implemented a new operating model, fragmenting some of Sars’ key tax collection and enforcement units, which partly led to a drop in revenue collection.

Massone told the commission the case for change at Sars was to improve the operations there and not to implement “radical change”, as has been heard from current and former officials.

READ MORE: Sars efficiency moved backwards after implementation of Moyane-sanctioned model

He said from reading the testimonies of current and former senior Sars officials who appeared before the commission, he believes the root cause of all the “bad things” that happened at Sars wasn’t because of the organisational structure that they designed.

Massone said there were three underlying factors as to why the structure failed: firstly, the “change in leadership team” where he said too many executives were changed and removed from their position and there was a “juniorisation” of staff. The second reason is the “change of management plan” which he said was not implemented properly with adequate communication and support to employees. Lastly, Massone said other things needed to complement the structure such as processes, communication lines and culture needed to be redesigned. Masonne called these “software” issues.

Masonne added that had these issues been attended to and the leadership not changed, “you would have been talking about a stronger Sars”.

Many senior executives who headed critical units — such as the Large Business Centre which collected a third of Sars’s revenue and the enforcement division dealing with the illicit economy — were sidelined or left Sars after the new operating model was introduced.

When asked if he had raised these issues when he became aware of them, Masonne said he had spoken to Moyane and former chief operating officer Jonas Makwakwa, who did not give him a satisfactory answer beyond: “We are going to work on it”.

The irregularities in the tender process for Bain & Co.’s contract also came under the spotlight at the hearing, with evidence leader Advocate Carol Steinberg questioning how the final invoice was for R164-million.

READ MORE: Increase in union complaints against working conditions at Sars

Steinberg said the company had won the contract to do a diagnostic at Sars at a cost of R2.38-million, which was a 50% discount rate of the consultancy firm’s normal pricing and much cheaper than competing firms.

However, after Bain and Co. completed the diagnostic report on the new operating model they were given a new contract to implement the project for which they charged their regular fees.

Steinberg said going forward there was no competitive tender with the initial price for the work increasing as well.

Massone said it was normal practice in the industry and for Bain & Co. to enter new clients at a reduced rate and it would have been “unsustainable” to continue with the 50% discount but they had given Sars slight discounts of between 12% to 20% in the years 2015 to 2017.

READ MORE: Sars deliberately withheld tax refunds, Nugent commission hears

Tebogo Tshwane
Tebogo Tshwane

Tebogo Tshwane is an Adamela Trust financial journalism trainee at the Mail & Guardian. She was previously a general news intern at Eyewitness News and a current affairs show presenter at the Voice of Wits FM. Tshwane is passionate about socioeconomic issues and understanding how macroeconomic activities affect ordinary people. She holds a journalism honours degree from Wits University. 


Stranded commuters say Ramaphosa’s rail promises ring hollow

Cape Town’s largest passenger rail line has been closed for months, hitting people’s pockets and adding to road traffic congestion

EFF ‘circus’ becomes contagion as MPs heckle Malema

ANC MPs test the EFF’s disruptive tactics on the leader of the Red Berets in Sona reply

Ramaphosa ‘neutral’ in Mkhwebane, Parliament impeachment row

However, the president says even if he has a conflict of interest, another Cabinet member could suspend the public protector

Strike-off case pulls in judge

Judge Mushtak Parker is implicated in an application to strike off his former partners. He is also involved in the fight between the Western Cape high court’s judge president and his deputy

Press Releases

Response to the report of the independent assessors

VUT welcomes the publishing of the report of the independent assessors to investigate concerns of poor governance, leadership, management, corruption and fraud at the university.

NWU student receives international award

Carol-Mari Schulz received the Bachelor of Health Sciences in Occupational Hygiene Top Achiever Award.

Academic programme resumes at all campuses

Lectures, practicals, seminars and tutorials will all resume today as per specific academic timetables.

Strategic social investments are a catalyst for social progress

Barloworld Mbewu enables beneficiaries to move away from dependence on grant funding

We all have a part to play to make South Africa work

Powering societal progress demands partnerships between all stakeholders

So you want to be a social entrepreneur?

Do the research first; it will save money and time later

Social entrepreneurship means business

Enterprises with a cause at their core might be exactly what our economy desperately needs

Looking inwards

Businesses are finding tangible ways to give back – but only because consumers demand it