Mail & Guardian
Mail & Guardian

The Polygamist: Familiar themes, powerful performances

Based on Sue Nyathi's novel, Netflix's ‘The Polygamist’ turns a familiar story of love, betrayal and power into one of the most talked-about South African dramas of the year

Based on Sue Nyathi's novel, Netflix's ‘The Polygamist’ turns a familiar story of love, betrayal and power into one of the most talked-about South African dramas of the year

The weekend belonged to The Polygamist.

The new Netflix series, based on the novel by Sue Nyathi, quickly became the show everyone seemed to be talking about, dissecting and debating. Across social media timelines, WhatsApp groups and office conversations, one name kept coming up: Jonasi Gomora.

The 22-episode drama brings together a strong cast led by Gugu Gumede as Joyce Gomora, Kwanele Mthethwa as Matipa Nkosi, Celeste Ntuli as Essie and Sdumo Mtshali as Jonasi, a construction tycoon whose charm, ambition and recklessness drive much of the story's conflict.

At its heart, The Polygamist is not necessarily telling a new story. In fact, its greatest strength might be how familiar it feels.

Most viewers have encountered a Jonasi before. Some have loved one. Others have survived one. The lucky ones have spent their lives hoping never to cross paths with someone like him.

Jonasi is a man who understands power and is not afraid to use it, even when doing so comes at the expense of the people who love him most. Throughout the series we watch him move through life collecting loyalty, affection and sacrifice from women who help build his world, only for him to repeatedly take that devotion for granted.

What makes the character compelling is not that he is unique but rather that he is painfully recognisable.

Mtshali delivers a performance that refuses to make Jonasi a simple villain. He is selfish, manipulative and often cruel but he is also charismatic enough for viewers to understand why people keep falling into his orbit. The complexity of the character lies in the tension between who he believes himself to be and the damage he leaves.

Opposite him, Gumede provides the emotional anchor of the series.

Joyce is devoted to her family and determined to preserve the image of perfection she has worked so hard to create. Even as her husband's behaviour threatens to pull everything apart, she continues fighting for the life she believes they built together.

Perhaps that is where the show's biggest hook lies.

Joyce represents order, stability and sacrifice, while Jonasi embodies chaos, appetite and entitlement. Watching the two forces collide becomes increasingly difficult to look away from.

The supporting cast also deserves recognition. Ntuli brings warmth and emotional intelligence to Essie, while Mthethwa's Matipa adds another layer to a story overflowing with competing desires, loyalties and betrayals.

Kenneth Nkosi has a much mellow role —  Magesh, the fixer who gets used and abused and never really gets to see and experience his own life. 

The themes explored by The Polygamist are hardly revolutionary. Love, betrayal, power, marriage, loyalty and revenge have long been staples of television drama. Yet the series succeeds because it understands that audiences are not necessarily looking for new problems. They are looking for truthful ones.

The show repeatedly asks uncomfortable questions about the lengths people will go to for love and the amount of pain they are willing to endure in order to hold onto relationships that might be broken.

It also shines a light on conversations that often remain hidden behind closed doors. While the title suggests a story primarily about multiple wives and romantic complications, the series is ultimately more interested in emotional power and the ways people justify behaviour that hurts those closest to them.

Not every storyline lands perfectly and the 22-episode format occasionally stretches moments that might have benefited from tighter pacing. But the shortcomings are outweighed by strong performances and characters that feel lived in rather than manufactured.

By the time the credits roll, The Polygamist leaves viewers with an uncomfortable realisation: the most frightening part of Jonasi Gomora is not how extraordinary he is but how ordinary he feels.

That familiarity is exactly what makes the series so difficult to stop watching.