Phahlane launches another bid to avoid R191m corruption trial

The state’s alleged failure to “properly” disclose millions of pages in evidence related to the R191-million fraud and corruption case against former top cop Khomotso Phahlane forms the basis of his latest attempt to have the matter dismissed. 

On Wednesday, at the Johannesburg specialised commercial crimes court, judgment was reserved on the application by Phahlane and former South African Police Service deputy national commissioner, Bonang Mgwenya, to have the combined 22 fraud and corruption charges against them struck off the court roll – on the grounds that the state failed to properly disclose the case docket to them. 

The charges against them relate to a 2016 contract to fit Gauteng police vehicles with sirens, markings, radios and other equipment, with the state claiming that the tender was fraudulently and corruptly awarded. This includes price inflation that allegedly lost the state more than R191-million. 

There are 11 other accused in the matter, including the company Instrumentation for Traffic Law Enforcement, represented by owner Vimpie Manthata, who allegedly doled out gifts such as a luxury BMW X5 to Mgwenya after his company received the contract. 

On Wednesday, Phlahlane’s legal representative Piet du Plessis argued that the defence had struggled to open certain folders in the voluminous case docket that the state handed over in the form of an external hard drive, and that it took 10 months – from November 2020 when the trial was expected to begin – to get assistance. 

This, Du Plessis contended, prejudiced his client in preparing his defence. Du Plessis argued further that it was unreasonable for the state to expect the defence to study the detailed case docket without specifying which portions of the case file is relevant to the charges against Phahlane. 

“You cannot dump millions of pages on the accused [Phahlane] and expect him to wade through to determine what is relevant. That’s all we’re asking from the state: disclose what is relevant,” he said.

His contentions were rejected by prosecutor advocate Richard Chabalala, who said all the accused were given the case docket, and accused Phahlane of filing unnecessary applications in order to avoid trial. 

“As of today, Accused 7 made not less than five attempts to get the case removed from the court roll. It is hard to not expect him to make another attempt to have the case removed from the court roll if he does not succeed in the instant attempt,” Chabalala said.

He also rejected Mgwenya’s assertions of a lack of proper disclosure as argued by her legal counsel, advocate Kenny Oldwage, who said the technical struggles his client had in accessing certain files were a “deliberate failure by the state to make a proper disclosure” aimed at ambushing her at trial.

Chabalala rebuked Oldwage’s argument, saying Mgwenya’s legal counsel had mentioned in court last April that he would launch an application by 28 May 2021 to strike the case off the roll if it emerged that the state had not made proper disclosures. The transcripts of Oldwage’s submission were submitted in court. Chabalala said Oldwage had failed to file the application on his own set deadline, and was doing so now to waste time. 

“The 28th of May 2021 came and passed but Mr Oldwage did not file a substantive application for the removal of the case from the court roll,” Chabalala said.

“It should also be noted that on the day [30 April 2021] when Mr Oldwage stated that he would file an application for removal of the case from the court roll, he did not tell the court that he had obtained full instructions from Accused 15 [Mgwenya] and/or that they had experienced specific problems with what was disclosed to them by the state.”

Judgement in Phahlane and Mgwenya’s application is expected to be handed down in May. All accused are out on bail.

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Khaya Koko
Khaya Koko is a journalist with a penchant for reading through legal documents braving the ravages of cold court benches to expose the crooked. He writes about social justice and human-interest stories. Most importantly, he is a card-carrying member of the Mighty Orlando Pirates.

Related stories

WELCOME TO YOUR M&G

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

Advertising

Latest stories

Saudi welcomes 1 million for biggest hajj pilgrimage since pandemic

Muslims from around the world have packed the streets of Islam's holiest city ahead of the biggest hajj pilgrimage since the coronavirus pandemic began.

When you kiss nyaope, you marry it

The low-grade form of heroin continues to strip the youth of their future and the young women living in a drug house in Ekurhuleni say the police do not take them seriously

Just transition could secure access to cleaner energy sources in...

A researcher says Africa’s huge renewable energy potential could save lives from air pollution

South African entrepreneur seeks to turn caterpillars into tasty snacks

For many people, particularly from western European backgrounds, the idea of eating insects is still riddled with fear and inhibition
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…
×