Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Reform school sentence means a spell in jail

Reform school as a sentencing option for juveniles is ”all but a dead letter” in South Africa as there is only one reform school to service eight of the nine provinces, the Grahamstown High Court heard on Monday.

A full bench of the high court was hearing argument on whether it had the power to intervene, by way of appeal or review, in sentences that were appropriate but had been delayed for lengthy periods or which were unlikely to be implemented at all.

The matter came before the full bench after Stepping Stones One Stop Youth Justice Centre Magistrate Cornelius Goosen asked it to review more than 20 cases of children he had himself referred to reform school over the past few years.

He turned to the high court after it was brought to his attention that many of these children were languishing in prison rather than being admitted to reform schools.

By law, children awaiting transfer to a reform school are held in a place of safety. Because of the dire lack of provincial places of safety, most in the Eastern Cape end up waiting in jail.

There they await a transfer to reform school that, more often than not, will never come through. Many of the children involved in the cases Goosen asked the court to review have been sitting in jail for up to four years waiting to serve often shorter periods in non-existent reform schools.

Advocate Mark Euijen, for the Legal Resources Centre in Grahamstown, on Monday argued that the court was obliged to intervene as it involved the State breaching the fundamental rights of those that are ”most vulnerable and least able to protect themselves”.

But Advocate Nico Henning from the office of the Eastern Cape Director of Public Prosecutions submitted that the court did not have the jurisdiction to set aside competent or appropriate sentences.

He said sentences passed might not be enforceable but this was due to a lack of action on the part of the executive rather than to any irregularity in proceedings.

”The problem has to be addressed but this court cannot set aside the sentences in each individual case.”

But Judge Eric Leach questioned whether it was in accordance with justice that a sentence intended by a magistrate could not be implemented.

Judge Clive Plakset said it seemed ”arbitrary, senseless and flew in the face of the rule of law”.

The departments of education and development were last month ordered to produce reports setting out steps they intended taking to address the lack of reform facilities for juvenile offenders in the province.

Advocate Torquil Patterson, who appeared for the two departments indicated yesterday that he did not believe the conduct of the two departments was ”justiciable”.

However, he said they would be open to any ”request” by the court to conduct a proper audit and furnish comprehensive information on the current situation.

The education department has already submitted a report acknowledging the enormity of the problem. However, it indicated a national task team was appointed in May to generate an immediate action plan for the movement of children out of prisons and secure care facilities into reform schools as well as to develop a medium to long-term plan for the implementation of the Child Justice Bill in relation to sentenced learners. – Sapa

Subscribe for R500/year

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and get a 57% discount in your first year.

Related stories


If you’re reading this, you clearly have great taste

If you haven’t already, you can subscribe to the Mail & Guardian for less than the cost of a cup of coffee a week, and get more great reads.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Subscribers only

Zondo commission: 10 unanswered questions

Zuma went to jail rather than testify. Some who did told blatant lies. Who decided Cabinet appointments and how much money was carried out of Saxonwold?

Local elections: Water tops the agenda in Limpopo’s dry villages

People in the Fetakgomo Tubatse local municipality, who have to collect water from Motse River, are backing independent candidates because they’re tired of parties’ election promises

More top stories

Conservation boosts cattle farmers

By adopting sound grazing practices livestock owners get access to markets in a foot-and-mouth disease red zone near the Kruger National Park

COP26 touted to resolve long standing issues on climate debt

Only 16% of losses in South Africa from weather-related disasters in the past four decades were covered by insurers, leaving governments and communities unable to build back

Most climate science is written by white men

In deciding how the world responds to the climate crisis, policymakers rely on research that tends to be written predominantly by men in the Global North

Zondo commission: 10 unanswered questions

Zuma went to jail rather than testify. Some who did told blatant lies. Who decided Cabinet appointments and how much money was carried out of Saxonwold?

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…