/ 6 September 2005

More killer Katrinas?

Tropical storms have doubled in destructive potential in the past 30 years because ocean surfaces have become warmer, according to a leading climate researcher.

This is the first time that an increase in the size, duration and power of tropical storms has been linked to global warming. And the result could have a significant effect on British weather, and have potentially disastrous consequences for the Caribbean, the West Coast of the United States and Pacific countries such as Japan.

Professor Kerry Emanuel, of the atmospheric, oceans and climate research department at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, has studied data from all the severe storms — or tropical cyclones — over the past 30 years.

He says they have been more intense, longer in duration and have generated far more power than computer models had predicted. Emanuel, an acknowledged world expert on the thermodynamics of tropical cyclone research, believes the power of the storms to create huge waves and mix the surface water of the oceans could also affect ocean currents, particularly the Gulf Stream, which sends warm water northwards and keeps Britain’s climate milder than it otherwise would be.

Many scientists have predicted that the Gulf Stream could slow or be ”turned off” by the effect of increased fresh water entering the Arctic from melting ice. But Emanuel believes that the greater mixing of warm water in the tropics could have the opposite effect, speeding up the currents and driving more warm water north.

Although there is no connection between his research and recent observations in Iceland, temperatures in the North Atlantic have risen notably as a direct result of a strong current flow pushing farther north.

Emanuel’s findings follow an inconclusive scientific debate about whether the frequency of storms is a natural phenomenon or a result of man-made climate change.

Climate models run through computers indicate that storms are likely to become more severe, but this is the first evidence that this is already happening. What is surprising is that the severity is far more pronounced than the computer models predicted. These models estimated that wind speeds would increase by 2% to 3% as a result of an already observed rise in the ocean temperature of 0,5°C. Because of the longer duration of storms, this would increase the total force exerted by the average hurricane by 8% to 12%.

However, Emanuel’s measurements of real winds show that storms can pick up much greater intensity as the ocean waters mix.

During a storm, the winds cause the warm surface water to mix with the cooler ocean below. Normally, this mixing would put a brake on the power of the storm because of the overall reduction in sea temperature it causes. But measurements show that it is not just the surface of the sea that has warmed in recent decades — the layer underneath is also at a higher temperature.

This means the wave action that mixes the layers does not have such a pronounced cooling effect as before and, as a result, the intensity of the storm remains significantly higher.

Emanuel’s view is that at least part of this increase in ocean temperature is caused by man-made climate change. ”Whatever the cause, the near doubling of power dissipation over the period on record should be a matter of some concern, as it is a measure of the destructive potential of tropical cyclones.”

Julian Heming, a tropical prediction scientist with the Met Office in Exeter, said he did not question Emanuel’s measurements, but pointed out that there was disagreement among scientists about whether the observed trend was man-made or part of a natural cycle. — Â