Stymied Rights

Late last year, the world’s media rightly beat up on their US colleagues for their shameful coverage of the damage left in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. But let us remember the old saw about living in glass houses. The South African media has had more than its share of Katrinas.

“Natural disasters,” not surprisingly, are perfect candidates for the kind of neglect, complacency, and victim-blaming that characterised the initial coverage of Hurricane Katrina. I offer as an example a study of media coverage of a massive rainstorm that wreaked havoc on the Cape Flats that I conducted with a colleague, Ron Krabill (a media studies professor at the University of Washington and a visiting professor at the University of KwaZulu-Natal).*

The “Manenberg Tornado,” as the series of rainstorms accompanied by fierce winds was dubbed, swept through that township and the neighbouring Guguletu and Tambo Square, destroying homes and leaving thousands homeless on the night of 29 August 1999 (the official count stood at 2,850 families affected by the storm).

We showed how coverage of the event – especially in the case of the popular local dailies, the Cape Times and Argus – and the subsequent rescue operation as well as partial rehabilitation of the affected area, exposed serious flaws in the media there.

For one, the obsession with labeling the windstorm a tornado served the needs of authorities by allowing them to treat the poor as victims and the storm as a natural crisis, rather than as a physical breakdown in the provision of housing.


Heavy storms are not unusual in Cape Town, and every winter leaves hundreds in squatter camps and overcrowded housing projects homeless and exposed to disease. This storm was in fact a perfectly predictable, almost routine occurrence. It could only develop into a disaster, natural or otherwise, as a result of official neglect and unsatisfactory public policy.

But the public authorities were portrayed as the beleaguered saviours of innocent victims, struggling to provide blankets and other “charity”. In one respect, then, politics was absent from the coverage. In another, however, politics intruded in essentially irrelevant ways, particularly an emphasis on the competition between political parties, such as who should claim credit for relief work and who sat where at a press conference. Not included in this debate? The citizens of the affected areas.

When these people were allowed to speak, they not unpredictably expressed anger and frustration with the slow pace of the rebuilding process. In this case, the media consistently portrayed them as “unruly” and “undeserving”.

Furthermore, their actions were associated with “criminal” activity (parallel to the hysterical focus on “looting” in the case of New Orleans). Indeed, “criminality” largely became associated with groups of residents openly clashing with the City Council over the slow pace of relief and reconstruction efforts. Not covered was that later, after the storm was no longer news, it emerged that the vast majority of these crimes were never investigated or substantiated.

What we found could easily be dismissed as an expected outcome: poor people have less access and little say in their own representation within mass media. This is hardly a new or unique conclusion.

But the more significant conclusion of our study was how citizenship claims play out in the media: residents of the townships were allowed to make only limited claims for emergency assistance in the immediate aftermath of the storm. Once they pushed for long-term, structural change in the provision of social services after the immediate crises had passed, their claims to socio-economic rights as citizens were stymied. We don’t have to wait for Katrina to figure that out and find that it happens really close to home.

* See “Mediating Manenberg in the post-Apartheid Public Sphere: Media, Democracy and Citizenship in South Africa,” in Steven L. Robins (ed.), Limits to Liberation after Apartheid (2005, David Philip and Ohio University Press).

Sean Jacobs is The Media’s correspondent in the United States.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Sean Jacobs
Sean Jacobs, founder and editor of Africa is a Country, is on the faculty of The New School and a Shuttleworth Fellow

Related stories

Broadcast takes on social media in the world of politics

Live TV broadcasts of political rallies, funerals and press conferences, may be more decisive than social media in shaping mass debate in South Africa

How do we write about Winnie’s life sympathetically?

Winnie Madikizela-Mandela’s legacy should not be reduced to the uncomplicated heroism that exemplifies today’s personality politics

A Zulu in New York

In 1990, a few months after his release from jail, Nelson Mandela toured the United States and helped cement Americans' popular associations with SA.

Rebel Radio

Experience of low power FM technology in the United States could show the way for greater media diversity in South Africa. Sean Jacobs reports.

Cosmetic Change

Does black-owned media in the US offer better coverage of minority issues than its mainstream counterparts? Sean Jacobs says not, which explains why shaking up the racial make-up of South African journalism is not enough.

A Pawn in Their Game

<i>New York Times</i> reporter Judith Miller abetted the illegal activities of White House officials in a campaign to smear a whistle-blower. Sean Jacobs writes that her jail sentence was more a statement on the sorry state of journalism than a heroic protection of her sources.
Advertising

Subscribers only

SAA bailout raises more questions

As the government continues to grapple with the troubles facing the airline, it would do well to keep on eye on the impending Denel implosion

ANC’s rogue deployees revealed

Despite 6 300 ANC cadres working in government, the party’s integrity committee has done little to deal with its accused members

More top stories

Finance probe into the Ingonyama Trust Board goes ahead

The threat of legal action from ITB chairperson Jerome Ngwenya fails to halt forensic audit ordered by the land reform minister

Ailing Far East Rand hospital purchases ‘vanity’ furniture

Dr Zacharia Mathaba, who purchased the furniture, is a suspected overtime fraudster and was appointed as Gauteng hospital chief executive despite facing serious disciplinary charges

Eusebius McKaiser: Reject the dichotomy of political horrors

Senekal shows us that we must make a stand against the loud voice of the populist EFF and racist rightwingers

Seals abort pups in mass die-off

There are a number of factors — a pollutant, virus or bacteria or malnutrition — may have caused the 12 000 deaths on Namibia’s coast
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday