If it were a Hollywood movie, it would be a remake of Alien vs Predator. On one side is the giant Sony corporation, which is backing the Blu-ray high-definition DVD format by building it into its PlayStation 3 (PS3) games consoles. Facing it across the global battlefield is Toshiba, backed by Microsoft and Intel, promoting the rival (and incompatible) HD DVD format.
The stakes are very high indeed for companies on both sides. Yet Sony, the pre-fight favourite — with the bestselling games-console franchise in the world and the backing of seven Hollywood studios (basically all of the big ones except Universal Pictures) making their movies available on Blu-ray — is nowhere near delivering the early knockout blow it wanted.
Instead, early defections from the Blu-ray-only camp and lagging sales of PS3 consoles have blurred the picture of which format will win. Samsung broke ranks with Blu-ray last month by announcing it will make players that play both HD formats, following a similar move by LG.
In addition, most analysts acknowledge that the PC manufacturers will play a key role in the format war — and having Microsoft and Intel behind HD DVD is significant. Neither of these two Toshiba allies has shown signs of switching camps so far.
Gamble on a bundle
Meanwhile, PS3 sales in the United Kingdom, the European market where PS3 has had its most successful launch, were 165 000 in week one but fell to 28 000 in the second week, a trend that has been echoed in other markets as well.
Sony took a big gamble bundling the Blu-ray player with the PS3, a move that contributed both to delays in its release and higher prices for the consoles. Last week, Ken Kutaragi, the “father of the PlayStation”, paid the price and resigned as chairperson and chief executive of the Sony Computer Entertainment unit.
With the sales of PS3 lagging, the new machines may not be the cornerstone of a recovery at Sony, with video-game-related losses for Sony’s year ending in March expected to amount to $2-billion — double original expectations.
Sony has a lot riding on the success of the PS3, especially after it was wrong-footed in the music player market by Apple’s iPod. It certainly doesn’t want to have another Betamax or MiniDisc story, either. For Sony, the PS3 and Blu-ray are part of an important corporate move to regain its pre-eminence in the consumer electronics business.
The picture is less clear for Toshiba, but certainly the company is keen to secure its share of the nascent market for high-definition players, and that means not wanting terms to be dictated by Sony. Toshiba also has an important backer on its side in Microsoft’s Xbox.
The decision not to build the HD DVD player into the Xbox console means it does not work as a Trojan horse as the PS3 does for Blu-ray. But those who choose to buy an HD DVD attachment for the Xbox are definitely motivated by a desire to buy and play discs in the new HD format.
On the retail side, the battle is also taking some interesting twists. In a recent blog on Digital Trends, Rob Enderle said that United States retail giant Wal-Mart plans to bring in “a massive number of low cost (possibly sub-$200) HD DVD players for Christmas”. Although unconfirmed by Wal-Mart, such a move could be decisive. Wal-Mart uses DVD sales as a loss-leader to attract shoppers and accounts for between 40% and 45% of all US DVD sales.
In Europe, the HD DVD Promotion Group has also been busy signing up smaller European studios to the Toshiba format, hoping to “build a local ecosystem” for HD DVD software. The group is able to leverage the fact that the cost of replicating HD DVD discs is cheaper — the equipment is an upgrade from DVD replicators and there are no regional code controls.
Appetite for local-language movies is also quite high in several European countries, a fact that the HD DVD camp hopes to exploit by having more of these titles available on their format sooner. In France, for example, 40% of the DVD market is for titles from independent studios, according to Screen Digest.
“We expect to have 200 unique titles available by year’s end in Europe and a third of them will be local,” says Xavier Bringue, HD DVD European group manager.
Crumbling support
At the moment there are 180 Blu-ray titles available in Europe, coming almost exclusively from big Hollywood studios. But despite the weight of titles, the number of HD DVD discs that are bought against the number of players sold is much higher than for Blu-ray discs. In the UK, this so-called “attach rate” for HD DVD discs is 28 per year on average, while for Blu-ray it’s five, says the HD DVD Promotion Group.
While sales of Blu-ray hardware in the US (including PS3s and standalone players) is five-to-one against HD DVD hardware sales, Blu-ray’s software sales figures are also a lot less impressive, at 2,3 discs per player, according to a recent report.
“If PS3 people all started buying HD discs, then by sheer weight Blu-ray would walk this battle,” says Helen Davis Jayalath, senior video analyst at Screen Digest. “But that’s not likely, because they are gamers.” And, she adds, the Wal-Mart story “was an overoptimistic leak on the part of one of a number of Chinese companies that Wal-Mart is talking to. [Enderle] seems to believe that if a Wal-Mart cheap player deal goes ahead, HD DVD will ‘win’. I’m not sure Sony will give up that easily.”
But the Blu-ray hard line has begun to crumble among Hollywood studios, where Warner and Paramount are hedging their bets by making discs in both formats. And it may be significant that Warner will offer its much-anticipated The Complete Matrix Trilogy only on HD DVD later this month. Given the importance of the first Matrix movie to the adoption of DVD players, this may be significant for HD DVD.
Much of the format battle revolves around which blockbuster movies are released on which formats and when. But an even bigger question is the pricing of players. At the moment, Blu-ray players are more expensive — and not just the PS3 consoles. Standalone Blu-ray players are as much as $300 more expensive in the US than HD DVD players; similar pricing gaps exist in other markets.
But perhaps the biggest problem is that even the cheapest standalone players cost more than $300 each, too high to spur mass consumer adoption. Given the high stakes for both hardware makers and content companies, neither side is likely to stand down easily. In fact, this format war might not have a clear winner and loser. Despite the video industry’s painful memories of Betamax vs VHS, multiple formats do co-exist in the games industry.
“The most likely scenario is that neither lose, but instead both formats survive,” says Davis Jayalath, of Screen Digest. “That doesn’t mean it will be a 50-50 split. It just means that even though it is more than likely that Blu-ray will be the stronger format, HD DVD is still strong enough to be a viable business.” — Guardian Unlimited Â