A month ago, Catarina Manungo (47) was the owner of a two-bedroom house in Boksburg, where she lived with her four children and a granddaughter. A few short weeks later Manungo and her two youngest children find themselves living in a tent in the Maputo neighbourhood of Matola Garre.
Manungo and her children are some of the 37 000 Mozambicans who have fled xenophobic violence in South Africa in the past month. Tens of thousands of other migrants from all over Africa are crowded in shelters inside South Africa. Officials in Maputo put the number of Mozambicans killed at 23. A total of 50 people died in the violence.
Manungo joined her husband — a miner — in South Africa in 1982. They saved enough from his earnings to buy a house before he died in 2003. Like most Mozambicans in South Africa, Manungo worked in the informal sector, eking out a living selling vegetables. She stayed on in South Africa rather than return to Mozambique when the Mozambican civil war ended in 1992 because she felt living conditions were better in South Africa and had no family to return to.
She says she lived in relative peace with her South African neighbours until a marauding mob ransacked her home and burnt much of her property on May 21. She managed to gather her children and flee. Her voice choked with emotion, she told a meeting convened in Maputo this week to discuss the regional effects of the crisis that she never imagined something like this could happen.
The gathering of 174 representatives of civil society organisations from Mozambique, South Africa, Botswana, Zambia and Zimbabwe was organised by the Southern Africa Trust and Mozambique’s Community Development Foundation (FDC) on June 10 to assess the situation of people displaced by the attacks and examine the root causes of the violence.
The chairperson of the FDC, Graça Machel, told the meeting she had heard gruelling first-hand accounts of the violence when she visited centres in South Africa that government and civil society organisations had set up for fleeing migrants. Machel said most of the displaced people expressed anger at South Africans; the challenge, she said, was to channel this anger and despair into a force that ”will enable us to say ‘never again’. We must find ways to build strong bridges that will take us where we were before.”
Machel said that one of the root causes of the violence was the influx of foreigners into South African cities coupled with the migration of South Africans from the countryside to cities. Add the recent increases in food prices to this enormous pressure on urban infrastructure and you get an explosive mixture: ”The poorest South African suburbs no longer have the capacity to absorb more people. It’s no longer possible to live there,” she said.
Machel blamed the situation on the development models that governments have adopted. If in the past Southern Africa was divided by colonialism and apartheid, she said, today it is divided by poverty. ”Extreme poverty dehumanises people and leads them to madness. The hatred and intolerance displayed were aimed against the conditions they are living in. People were opposing the subhuman conditions in which they live.”
Jody Kollapen, head of the South African Human Rights Commission, said it was essential to bring the perpetrators of the heinous crimes seen over the past few weeks to justice. He also said that a candid debate on reparations is needed.
For reparations to be successful, Kollapen said they will need to include a plan for reintegration supported by financial help to enable the victims of xenophobia to start afresh. Such a plan must also take poor South Africans into account, he said, so as not to foster resentment among people in almost equally desperate need of assistance.
Mozambican President Armando Guebuza has called on his fellow citizens to show tolerance and refrain from retaliating against South Africans. Speaking to the returnees at a transit centre Guebuza described the xenophobic attacks in South Africa as the work of people opposed to regional integration, which should lead to complete freedom of movement of people and goods throughout the Southern African Development Community region.
”We shall continue on the path of solidarity and unity,” he said, ”but we must never opt for violence, since we know very well what the price of violence is.”
Some of the returnees told Guebuza they wanted to return to South Africa as soon as conditions allowed. But others have been so badly shaken they have decided to stay in Mozambique permanently. Although uneasy calm prevails in South Africa at the moment, Catarina Manungo would rather brave the cold and harsh winter buffeting her exposed tent than risk a return to her home in Boksburg. ”It’s better to sleep in a tent under a tree than to return for God knows what.” — IPS