Life and death lottery for ambulance medics

On one side are the badly wounded, desperate to get out to medical attention; on the other are the bodybags of those who failed to make it waiting to be sent back in for burial. The no-man’s land of Rafah’s border crossing, strewn with barbed wire and reverberating with nearby bomb blasts, is a grim patch between the Gazan and Egyptian borders.

But for Dr Nadal bin-Afifi, it was the most reassuring thing he had seen all day. For the second time this week Afifi had made the perilous journey from his home in Gaza City down to the territory’s southern limits to ferry the injured across into Egypt.

“My colleague was killed by an Israeli bomb while making the same trip three days ago,” he said as volunteers rushed to unload his human cargo. “I can’t find the courage to tell my wife I’m doing this.”

Afifi’s ambulance was the ninth to have made it across into Egypt by late afternoon; six more were expected before sundown. At least two doctors and two ambulance drivers have reportedly been killed in the past week.

Once through a heavily defended Egyptian checkpoint, the ambulances pull up under the baking Sinai sun and are immediately engulfed by a swarm of medics, soldiers, NGO workers and journalists.

Patients - mostly children, women and the elderly, according to medics - are whisked through the frontier gates to a hospital in the nearby town of al-Arish, with the most serious cases then flown on to Cairo.

On their way they pass ambulances carrying the bodies of those for whom help came too late, on their way back to be processed for burial in Gaza.

“We are doing the best we can, but really it feels futile,” said one Egyptian paramedic. “There are thousands who need us across the wall. In the past three days I’ve seen 14 make it through.”

Nine days into the Israeli bombardment of Gaza, thousands of Egyptian soldiers are also in Rafah and al-Arish, braced for a possible repeat of last year’s border breach by besieged Palestinians.

“Rafah is a ghost town,” said Nora Younis, an Egyptian journalist and activist who had travelled up from Cairo. “The streets are cold and tense, with barricades and security officers dug in on every corner of every alley.”

For every medical emergency trying to make it out of Gaza, there is a healthy Gazan fighting to return. “In other parts of the world people try and escape wars,” said Khalil Alniss, a Palestinian with UK citizenship who has driven from Scotland to try to deliver supplies into the strip. “But here people say ‘no, I will return to my land and I will die in my land’. Only in Palestine.”

There is anger over the Egyptian government’s perceived unwillingness to open the border, a stance which has provoked mass demonstrations across the Arab world, but those currently in Rafah are divided over who is to blame.

“The people here all have relatives across the wall,” said Rami, a Palestinian staying in al-Arish.
“I’ve seen young children with no legs transiting through this town in the last few days. They could be anyone’s son or brother.”

Deal to admit journos aborted
Plans to allow journalists into Gaza were aborted this week after Israel’s military said it was too dangerous to keep staff at the Erez passenger terminal to allow people to cross into the besieged territory, writes Toni O’Loughlin.

Israel argues that excluding the international media from Gaza is helpful because foreign journalists are unethical and biased in their reporting. Foreign journalists are “unprofessional” and take “questionable reports at face value without checking”, said Danny Seaman, who heads Israel’s government press office, which vets and issues permits to foreign correspondents.

Seaman said it was not Israel’s responsibility to give foreign media access to Gaza. “They should have been there in the first place,” before Israel began restricting access on November 6, said Seaman.

“We are not going to endanger the lives of our people just to let journalists in.”

Israel began restricting media access to Gaza after the six-month ceasefire with Hamas began unravelling on November 4. But a high court challenge by the Foreign Press Association (FPA) resulted in a compromise in which eight members of the media were to be allowed in when the Erez crossing was opened for humanitarian reasons.

The military had told the court that it was too dangerous to allow journalists in.

Under the agreed arrangement, aborted yesterday, the FPA was allowed to select six journalists by lottery and submit the names to Israel for vetting.

Israel selected the other two journalists. In this first pool it chose people from NBC and Fox news, which is pro-Israel.—

Client Media Releases

Changes at MBDA already producing the fruits
University open days: Look beyond banners, balloons to make the best choice
ITWeb, VMware second CISO survey under way
Doctoral study on leveraging the green economy
NWU's LLB degree receives full accreditation