Langa: Criticism of judges should be fair, reasonable

Constitutional Court Chief Justice Pius Langa on Monday urged the public to refrain from personal attacks on judges as this practice would weaken democracy.

”I think judges should have a thick skin and, having said that, I’m not encouraging people to call us names,” Langa said at a media briefing in Johannesburg, held at the Constitutional Court.

”We work in public, we give our judgements in public, we give reasons for those judgements. We do expect people to scrutinise those judgements and to make their views known.

”… but what we do insist on is that criticism of judges, judgments, should be fair, and should be reasonable, and should not impune the integrity of judges because in doing so [people] are weakening a pillar of our democracy.”

Langa continued: ”Now what we would not want is criticism that goes to the integrity of a person — a drunk or counter-revolutionary — whatever — those are things we don’t expect to hear from the general public, because it does tell us that they have not read the judgements we have given.”

Langa said he accepted that it was freedom of expression ”but I don’t think people should be insulted”.

Last year the judges came under fire for their judgements by supporters of African National Congress president Jacob Zuma and for the manner in which they handled a complaint to the Judicial Service Commission over an alleged attempt to interfere with the Zuma judgement.

”So how do we feel, we carry on, we just carry on.”

Langa said the court was not just for the powerful and mighty but also for the weak and the poor. Damaging the court’s integrity ”would destroy a bastion of freedom, something that people rely on”.

He said the real test was when the people who called judges names would come back to the court when they had a dispute that they wanted to resolve.

”We are quite comfortable that we think the courts are doing a good job because we think the majority of people believe that.” — Sapa

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Yengeni’s complaint against Zondo is legally uncertain

The chief justice was acting in a non-judicial capacity when chairing the state capture inquiry, so the complaint probably falls outside the law but underscores the risk of naming sitting judges to investigate political scandals

Covid-19 escalates xenophobia in South Africa – Report

Politicians have increasingly come under scrutiny for their alleged inflammatory comments which have been taken as endorsement by anti-foreigner activists

Metaverse: Virtual economy to pump $40bn into African GDP

A study suggests that the virtual world platform could plug more than 40 billion US dollars into the African economy in its first decade.

Bradley Carnell’s shot at US footballing greatness

St Louis City’s head coach has the opportunity to build a legacy from scratch at the midwest club, the latest franchise added to the Major League Soccer.

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…