PWC in plagiarism inquiry

One of South Africa’s big four audit firms, PricewaterhouseCoopers (PWC), is at the centre of damning claims of plagiarism levelled against it by a senior Gauteng government official.

Sibusiso Buthelezi, the suspended head of the provincial department of transport, roads and works, accuses PWC of plagiarising a 2007 consultancy report.

Buthelezi further claims PWC had an improper relationship with his former political head, Ignatius Jacobs, and that the firm was paid millions of rands for work that was “grossly unsuccessful”.

Buthelezi was suspended last week by Premier Nomvula Mokonyane after she received a damning report about allegations levelled against him by Jacobs, the former transport, roads and works MEC who now heads Mokonyane’s planning commission.

The report, compiled by attorneys Peter Harris and Michelle Moonsammy of the Resolve Group, recommends disciplinary action against Buthelezi while it clears Jacobs of wrongdoing.


The report, however, left two swords hanging over Jacobs’s head: allegations that he had “pushed PWC down the department’s throat” and claims that he improperly attempted to adjust the composition of a consortium appointed to refurbish the Kempton Park hospital.

In their report Harris and Moonsammy recommend further investigation of these claims after Jacobs failed to respond to the allegations before the first report was finalised. Jacobs’s lawyer, Shaheed Dollie, told the Mail & Guardian this week his client did subsequently respond to the allegations but wished not to disclose his responses at this stage to ensure that the integrity of the investigation is not jeopardised.

Buthelezi’s allegations about Jacobs’s allegedly improper relationship with PWC are three-pronged:

  • The most sensational of his claims is that PWC was involved in a “scandal” for committing plagiarism in 2007 by lifting work done on a new departmental structure by Ukuba Management.

    “Ukuba Management had charged the department about R500 000 and PWC had charged the department about R8-million for the said project,” Buthelezi told the Harris investigation. The department became aware of the “plagiarism” after receiving correspondence from Ukuba’s lawyer, accusing PWC of stealing its work.

    “The department resolved the matter by withholding about R500 000 of fees written by PWC and paying Ukuba Management,” Buthelezi stated. The M&G has seen a letter written by Ukuba’s lawyer, Kate Savage, to the department on December 11 2007. “We are instructed that as a result of the [department’s] decision to contract PWC, a copy of our client’s report on the departmental structure was provided to PWC. PWC subsequently prepared a report for the [department], from which it used almost all of our client’s report [parts of] which were simply cut and pasted, without amendment and for which no credit was given to our client,” Savage wrote.

  • Buthelezi further accuses Jacobs of replacing a “successful” consulting firm, Ebeneza, with PWC in 2006 to design and implement a turnaround strategy for the department.
    Buthelezi opposed the appointment of PWC to take over Ebeneza’s work. This move, he says, was followed by an investigation by PWC into whether Buthelezi could refuse to appoint PWC. “The HOD [Buthelezi] points out that this was absurd as PWC had to investigate whether they had to be appointed or not,” the Harris report reads. “The HOD asserts that this is a conflict of interest and as such PWC should never have agreed to conduct this investigation.”

    Buthelezi requested a full report on PWC’s work by the end of June 2007, which, he says, he did not receive. He subsequently appointed a task team of four (TT4) consultants to do a performance audit of PWC’s work. The Harris report found that this appointment of TT4 was irregular and that Buthelezi should have publicly invited bids for the work.

    According to Buthelezi, TT4 found that PWC’s work on phase one of the turnaround strategy was “grossly unsuccessful and proved to be an expensive mistake by the MEC that merely served to delay resolving issues in the department”.

  • Buthelezi further accuses Jacobs of using John van Rooyen, chair of the departmental acquisitions council (DAC), to “smuggle through” the DAC a contract for two PWC projects disguised as one. “In summary, the DAC was led to believe that it was authorising a R34-million project when in fact it was tricked to authorise a R70-million project,” Buthelezi told the Harris investigation.

    The contract was for the appointment of consultants to design and implement Jacobs’s “dashboard project” — management charters for which PWC subcontracted German consulting firm Dornier.

    PWC’s John White said the firm views its reputation as a “hugely important asset and always strives to operate within a strict code of ethics”. Due to confidentiality agreements, he said PWC could not comment at this stage on untested allegations. “When allegations of this nature are brought to our attention, it is standard procedure for PWC to investigate them internally,” White said. “We will also cooperate fully with any formal statutory investigation into these allegations.”

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories

We need more women in STEM careers

Local solutions are needed to get more women into science, technology, engineering and maths

EU methane emissions policies will affect Africa’s energy transition

African hydrocarbons producers would do well to commit to existing venting and flaring regulations — because methane-specific policies are coming

Long road ahead for tourism-sector recovery

The pandemic has caused 50 000 businesses in the sector to temporarily close, putting 600 000 jobs at risk

New education policy on gender violence released

Universities and other higher education institutions have to develop ways of preventing or dealing with rape and other damaging behaviour

Teachers having sexual relationships with learners is illegal

The Sexual Offences Act criminalises sex with a person under the age of 16 by a person over the age of 18

Herman Mashaba wants you to forget

When considering Herman Mashaba’s new political plans, the South African public must reckon with the former mayor of Johannesburg's actual record
Advertising

New education policy on gender violence released

Universities and other higher education institutions have to develop ways of preventing or dealing with rape and other damaging behaviour

Cambridge Food Jozini: Pandemic or not, the price-gouging continues

The Competition Commission has fined Cambridge Food Jozini for hiking the price of its maize meal during April

Sekhukhune’s five-year battle for water back in court

The residents of five villages are calling for the district municipal manager to be arrested

Vaccine trial results due in December

If successful, it will then have to be manufactured and distributed
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday