UCT pops up on global varsity list

After global university rankings last week put only one South African university in its top 200 — the University of Cape Town (UCT) — a second set of rankings this week also singled out only one local university. And it is again UCT.

But a falling-out last year between the two organisations that used to produce a joint set of annual rankings and now compete against each other has raised questions about criteria used to compare any universities. In South Africa such questions boiled over in a spat this week between the Democratic Alliance and Higher Education Minister Blade Nzimande over what the rankings say about the quality of local universities.

Last week’s rankings were produced by QS, a multinational organisation based in London that describes itself as “the world’s leading network for top careers and education, linking graduate, MBA and executive communities”.

QS’s most visible contribution to South African education is made once a year when it holds a fair in Johannesburg at a five-star hotel to attract applicants for the top-dollar MBA degree.

Its top 200, released last week, put UCT at 161. Taking pole position was Britain’s Cambridge University; United States Ivy Leaguers Harvard and Yale followed and University College London was fourth.


Oxford — often paired with Cambridge as Britain’s other medieval university and as its rival in their annual boat race — was sixth.

Reporting the QS results, the Guardian noted that Times Higher Education (THE) — a publication of the British Times — was “concerned” that QS’s rankings “rely too heavily on subjective surveys of scholars and employers and not enough on hard indicators of excellence”.

THEs expression of anxiety on this score was well timed to bring some academics and all university brand managers worldwide to the brink of nervous collapse in the run-up to the release of its top 200 this week.

In the THE survey UCT rose to 107. The world’s current superpower invaded the top five positions and former imperialists Oxford and Cambridge were tied in sixth place.

In South Africa the global competition seeped into local politics when the DA tabled a question in Parliament, asking whether Nzimande had any plans to get any of our universities into the top 100. The official opposition tarnished their own scholarly credentials a tad by referring to the first set of rankings as THE‘s.

Undaunted by the opposition’s academic obtuseness, Dr Nzimande (PhD, Natal) replied at length. And the DA duly attacked his reply in a statement it released with unconcealed glee. Lost in the political dust-up was whether rankings of whatever stripe serve any useful academic purpose.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

David Macfarlane
Guest Author

Related stories

Walter Sisulu University is playing catch-up with online learning

Some affluent institutions have already finished the first semester online, but historically disadvantaged universities like Walter Sisulu University are having to start from scratch

A small number of students can return to university, but some choose not to

They stayed away because they feared getting Covid-19, had comorbidities, were in quarantine, had become infected and the safety measures such as curfews were too limiting

Students ‘dreams are crumbling’

Those at historically disadvantaged universities feel abandoned while their peers at richer institutions continue with their studies

The student funding scheme changes lives – it’s too important to fail

We need a NSFAS that is run effectively and efficiently to serve poor and working class young people who want to change their lives through education.

Student drops out as tech access issues hinder his learning

In April, UniZulu announced that it had negotiated zero-rated data with MTN, Telkom and Cell C in so its students could access teaching and learning on its online platform without incurring data costs

Universities can decide which students return to campus, even if they are not in their final year

Higher education minister expands the allowance for who can be on campus, but numbers cannot be more than a third of the student population
Advertising

Western Cape warned not to be complacent about flat-lining Covid-19...

The Western Cape, which once had the highest number of Covid-19 cases in South Africa, is seeing a steady decline in active cases

Sisulu axes another water board

Umgeni Water’s board in KwaZulu-Natal was appointed irregularly by her predecessor, the water and sanitation minister claims
Advertising

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday