Netcare coughs up

After seven years of obfuscation and denial, South Africa’s largest private healthcare group, Netcare, finally confessed to its role in a cash-for-kidneys scheme and to benefiting from associated international trafficking of living donors.

Immediately after Netcare admitted to having illegally profited from the scheme, Richard Friedland, Netcare’s chief executive, publicly apportioned blame to St Augustine’s hospital management and transplant coordinators acting in cahoots with surgeons and others — basically every­one involved in the scheme, except Netcare itself.

  • The untold stories
  • Netcare’s conviction in the Durban commercial crimes court is said to be a world first — no other hospital group has been found guilty of supporting an organised trafficking scheme dealing in organs.

    The scheme, dubbed the Israeli Transplant Programme, recruited living kidney “donors”. They were flown to South Africa for harvesting and transplant operations at Netcare’s facilities in Johannesburg, Cape Town and Durban.

    The recipients were Israelis who paid on average $120 000 to an international organ broker, Ilan Perry, and his agents to organise the transplants.

    Ininitally donors were paid up to $20 000 for a kidney, but this dropped when it was discovered that some poor Brazilians and Romanians were willing to accept as little as $5 000 and $6 000.

    “Organ transplant capital of the world”
    At the height of the programme, between 2001 and 2003, Netcare dubbed itself the “organ transplant capital of the world”, performing kidney operations, involving unrelated, living donors, almost weekly.

    While more than 300 such operations took place at Netcare’s transplant clinics in the three cities, the criminal investigations targeted only 109 illegal operations that took place at Durban’s St Augustine’s hospital.

    Friedland previously said that the JSE-listed hospital group never knew that it was party to an illegal scheme, but the group pleaded guilty to receiving money from Perry to arrange illegal kidney harvesting and transplant operations.

    Netcare was fined R4-million for its role in 92 illegal operations at St Augustine’s involving non-related donors and recipients. Five of these operations involved minors, which is also illegal, even with parental consent. Netcare also forfeited R3,8-million to the Assets Forfeiture Unit.

    That, said prosecutor Robin Palmer, was more than the estimated profit that Netcare had made out of the scheme.

    In terms of the plea agreement finalised in court, criminal charges were withdrawn against Friedland as Netcare’s chief executive.

    The charges
    Netcare’s guilty plea has implicated all remaining eight accused — two former transplant coordinators, Lindsay Dixon and Melanie Azor, a Hebrew interpreter, Samuel Ziegler, and five doctors — professor John Robbs and Dr Neil Christopher, who allegedly performed the kidney-harvesting operations, and the transplant specialists, professor Ariff Haffajee, Dr Jeff Kallmeyer and Dr Mahadev Naidoo.

    They face charges of fraud, forgery, uttering, assault and contraventions of the Human Tissues Act, which prohibits kidney transplants involving unrelated, living donors.

    Palmer said two key state witnesses — Netcare’s former national transplant coordinator, Belinda Rossi, and Perry, the international organ broker and syndicate boss — had made statements that firmly implicated Netcare as a group, Friedland as the chief executive, and the other eight accused.

    But whether Rossi, Perry and others will ever testify is now a moot point. The prosecution looks set to engage in further plea discussions before the next court sitting on November 23.

    “We have achieved what we set out to do,” said Palmer, referring to the conviction of Netcare for profiteering through its deals with Perry.

    He hinted that a compromise would now be sought in dealing with the accused doctors, who could be barred from medical practice if they are convicted as charged. “We do not want to denude this province of all its top kidney experts. How will that help anyone?” asked Palmer.

    Programme and negotiations
    From the outset of the case the accused doctors and their lawyers argued that they had nothing to do with setting up the programme or any negotiations with Perry — they had simply been called in to perform harvesting and transplant operations at Netcare’s request.

    Attorney Altus van Rensburg also said that the doctors were shown documentation that the patients were family members. “It was not for them to question or dispute this,” Van Rensburg said.

    The false documentation led to charges of forgery and uttering against Netcare, although these have now been withdrawn as a result of the plea agreement.

    In a statement on the Netcare website states that Friedland has acceded to a request from Netcare’s board of trustees not to seek legal redress against those allegedly responsible for having wrongfully instituted criminal proceedings against him. — Roving Reporters

    Subscribe to the M&G

    These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

    The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

    Related stories

    Q&A Sessions: ‘Nobody will be able to stop us’ — Desmond D’Sa

    Desmond D’Sa, winner of the coveted Goldman Environmental Prize in 2014, tells Paddy Harper how being forcibly removed from his home at the age of 10 taught him to fight for his rights

    Calls to cap Eskom tariff increases

    The national energy regulator has been accused of not following its mandate to protect consumers by allowing above inflation electricity price hikes

    Human contact floats the boats

    Discovering the life-sustaining importance of contact with actual people: colleagues, customers, and deputy presidents

    Durban’s cruisers may just survive the Covid crisis

    Five months of no income means things are touch and go for Durban’s harbour charter industry, but with help they hope to weather the storm

    PPE scandal takes the bread out of SMEs’ mouths

    The Special Investigating Unit is probing contracts worth more than R5-billion, over corruption allegations regarding the procurement of goods and services needed for the government’s Covid-19 response

    Dumpsite fire that smoked out Pietermaritzburg is finally out

    Firefighters have finally extinguished the fire at the New England Road landfill site in Pietermaritzburg, which had engulfed the KwaZulu-Natal capital in thick clouds of toxic smoke since it flared up more than a week ago

    Subscribers only

    Toxic power struggle hits public works

    With infighting and allegations of corruption and poor planning, the department’s top management looks like a scene from ‘Survivor’

    Free State branches gun for Ace

    Parts of the provincial ANC will target their former premier, Magashule, and the Free State PEC in a rolling mass action campaign

    More top stories

    Why anti-corruption campaigns are bad for democracy

    Such campaigns can draw attention to the widespread presence of the very behaviour they are trying to stamp out — and subconsciously encourage people to view it as appropriate

    Tax, wage bill, debt, pandemic: Mboweni’s tightrope budget policy statement

    The finance minister has to close the jaws of the hippo and he’s likely to do this by tightening the country’s belt, again.

    SA justice delays extradition of paedophile to UK

    Efforts to bring Lee Nigel Tucker to justice have spanned 16 years and his alleged victims have waited for 30 years

    Former state security minister Bongo back in court

    Bongo and his co-accused will appear in the Nelspruit magistrate’s court in Mpumalanga over charges of fraud, corruption and theft

    press releases

    Loading latest Press Releases…

    The best local and international journalism

    handpicked and in your inbox every weekday