No end to bickering over breastfeeding

Everyone, stop what you’re doing and think about babies. Ah, tiny babies drinking milk. Does it fill you with a warm glow, thinking about those small, slow-blinking infants absorbing the nutrition they need from a bottle or breast? Or do you find that the mental image alone drives you to inchoate rage and doubt? What if the babies are drinking the wrong sort of milk? How do we know what’s right anyway? And what if you’re a mom and — horror of horrors — suspected of doing a bad job of keeping your child healthy and well fed?

This isn’t just facetiousness: breast or bottle is one of the most intimate and essential decisions a new parent has to make. That’s probably why the simple advice and support structures aimed at new mothers have an irrepressible tendency to mutate into inflexible dictates, head-shaking horror at other people’s choices and flinty self-criticism.

It also probably explains why a new report in the British Medical Journal (BMJ) on best practice for weaning has become the occasion for another round of this-milk-is-better-than-that-milk bickering. Although the report itself makes the fairly limited claim that exclusively breastfeeding for six months (as recommended by the World Health Organisation) may not be advisable in all circumstances, it has been reported — and responded to — as though it was a full refutation of breast-is-best.

I entered the maternity ward with a very simple feeding plan: “No formula.” Which meant that when an exhausting labour left me and baby too tired to get started properly and a midwife recommended supplementing breastfeeds with bottles, I was devastated. Here I was, a few days into parenthood and I’d already failed my baby. I’d made a hash of giving birth and now couldn’t manage something I’d convinced myself was the most natural thing in the world.

A catchy but inadequate slogan
Though “breast is best” is catchy, like most slogans it does a pretty poor job of conveying all the essential qualifiers. All things being equal, breast milk is the best choice for mother and child. But a few women can’t. Some would like to, but don’t have anyone to teach them how. (Yes, there really is a bit more to it than just socking a nipple in a baby’s mouth and hoping for the best.) Some, from a combination of social pressure and personal qualms, just don’t want to. And some, like me, need a bit of nutritional back-up: Was I still doing what was “best”? Where was my neatly rhyming affirmation?

Absolutist positions are worse than flawed. We’ve come a long way since my aunt was dosed with drying-up pills at her post-labour breakfast, but a zeal for breastfeeding can be harmful too. There’s the bruising of self-esteem that comes when physical or practical realities crush a heartfelt plan.

And the breast versus bottle war instils hostility where there should be none; for a while my nearest mother-and-baby group was a breastfeeding drop-in, which was absolutely lovely until I came to recommend places to a friend with an adopted newborn. Why was this a breastfeeding group and not just a baby group with breastfeeding support from a health visitor?

There’s worse: I knew one mom with a degenerative eye disease who had come off her meds for the pregnancy and was now doggedly refusing to restart them until she’d given her son a full six months of breast milk — blinding herself in pursuit of maternal perfection. It’s a fringe case, but a painful reminder that when one simple message starts to drown out all others, the important thing — the welfare of mother and child — begins to be lost.

I hope every woman gets all the support and help she needs to give her baby the best possible start and usually that means breastfeeding. But turning milk into the frontline of a parenting war is the worst possible outcome. —

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories

The quest for the (vaginal) ring

The HIV prevention tablet is now available in South Africa but popping a pill every day to stay HIV-negative may not be for everyone

A new smoke signal: Is Big Tobacco using influencers to illegally punt new products?

Could companies’ wooing of social media influencers be just a clever ploy to get around the country’s tobacco advertising ban?

How one project is finally helping reduce the risk of suicide among teens

When kids at risk of suicide can talk to trained friends & family, they're seven times less likely to die, says one of the world's largest studies.

Hospitals close in Mpumalanga as doctors and nurses fear for their safety

Health workers in Mpumalanga fear for their lives because of crime and unsafe buildings

What are Echo Trial results does Depo-Provera birth control shot increase risk of HIV

For 25 years, scientists have wondered whether the Depo-Provera could increase people’s risk of contracting HIV. Today, we find out if it does.

After Echo: ‘Why the study results scare me’

We've proven Depo Provera doesn't make it easier to contract HIV. But African women are still left with too few contraceptive choices.

Subscribers only

The shame of 40 000 missing education certificates

Graduates are being left in the lurch by a higher education department that is simply unable to deliver the crucial certificates proving their qualifications - in some cases dating back to 1992

The living nightmare of environmental activists who protest mine expansion

Last week Fikile Ntshangase was gunned down as activists fight mining company Tendele’s expansions. Community members tell the M&G about the ‘kill lists’ and the dread they live with every day

More top stories

The high road is in harm reduction

While the restriction of movement curtailed the health services for people who use drugs in some parts of the world, it propelled other countries into finding innovative ways to continue services, a new report reveals

Khaya Sithole: Tsakani Maluleke’s example – and challenge

Shattering the glass ceiling is not enough, the new auditor general must make ‘live’ audits the norm here in SA

State’s wage freeze sparks apoplexy

Public sector unions have cried foul over the government’s plan to freeze wages for three years and have vowed to fight back.

‘Veteran’s stripes’ vs ‘kind and fair’

This weekend the Democratic Alliance will choose between two starkly different visions for its future

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday