Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Oilgate decision ‘a victory for M&G and Public Protector’

The decision by Thuli Madonsela not to contest an appeal court judgment ordering the Public Protector to set aside a 2005 report into the Oilgate scandal not only upholds the integrity of the Mail & Guardian‘s investigations into the matter, but also strengthens the office of the protector, said M&G editor in chief Nic Dawes on Wednesday.

Madonsela announced earlier on Wednesday that she would not be challenging the judgment, which sets aside the 2005 report into the Oilgate scandal by her predecessor Lawrence Mushwana.

The M&G revealed in May 2005 how R11-million in taxpayers’ money had flowed from PetroSA, the state oil company, to the ANC’s 2004 election campaign, through empowerment oil trader Imvume Management.

Mushwana purported to investigate the matter, but made no attempt to consult the M&G during his investigation. He held in his report: “Much of what has been published by the M&G was factually incorrect, based on incomplete information and documentation and comprised unsubstantiated suggestions and unjustified speculation.”

The M&G took Mushwana’s report, widely held to have been a “whitewash”, on review under the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act, following its release in July 2005. Judge Ntsikelelo Poswa heard the matter in November 2007 and in July 2009 found in the M&G‘s favour, setting the report aside.

On June 1, the Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by the Public Protector against the high court order, upholding Poswa’s ruling that the report be set aside.

On Wednesday, Madonsela said her office accepted the ruling.

Victory for the Public Protector
“While technically this is a victory for the M&G it also a victory for the Public Protector as it makes it very clear she has a constitutional duty to use her wide-ranging powers to conduct robust investigations,” Dawes said.

In the ruling, the SCA did not order Madonsela to re-investigate the matter, but rather to look into what was needed to fulfill her duties in her role as the new Public Protector.

Madonsela told reporters in Pretoria she would scrutinise the report “to establish what needs to be done to conclude this matter”.

Madonsela’s announcement comes as her office embarks on a series of investigations into improper leasing of state buildings involving several high ranking figures, including police commissioner General Bheki Cele and businessman Roux Shabangu.

In the course of her investigations, Madonsela has in turn been accused of corruption and fraud during her time as a commissioner at the South African Law Reform Commission (SALRC).

On Wednesday, Madonsela rubbished the fraud and corruption allegations, vowing not to be sidetracked from fulfilling her office’s constitutional mandate.

Integrity upheld
“In essence this is a great outcome, both for us and the office of the protector. The final judgment set the record straight on Mushwana’s report, which impugned upon our journalistic integrity. Furthermore, it provides support for what Madonsela is trying to do in her position
— exactly what he predecessor could not,” Dawes said.

Madonsela would not say whether she would be reopening the investigation into the Oilgate scandal, but did commit the office of the protector to engaging the M&G on the matter.

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them and receive a 40% discount on our annual rate..

Nickolaus Bauer
Nickolaus Bauer is the Mail & Guardian's jack of all trades news reporter that chases down stories ranging from politics and sports to big business and social justice. Armed with an iPad, SLR camera, camcorder and dictaphone, he aims to fight ignorance and pessimism through written words, photographs and videos. He believes South Africa could be the greatest country in the world if only her citizens would give her a chance to flourish instead of dwell on the negativity. When he's not begging his sub-editors for an extra twenty minutes after deadline, he's also known to dabble in the occasional poignant column that will leave you mulling around in the depths of your psyche. The quintessential workaholic, you can also catch him doing sports on the weekday breakfast show on SAfm and presenting the SAfm Sports Special over the weekend.

Related stories


Subscribers only

NW Premier Mokgoro ‘meddles’ in contentious R1.5m HOD appointment

Provincial HOD hired despite implication in ‘jobs-for-pals’ probe involving former minister Faith Muthambi

Wild garlic harvesters back in court

Healers say the plant is part of their heritage, but officials counter that it is a protected species

More top stories

Public works tables ‘solutions’ to botched Beitbridge border fence tender

Scopa ‘disappointed’ by slow pace and lack of consequences on Beitbridge irregularities.

ANC resolute over its step-aside decision: Duarte

The governing party has identified 40 members charged with serious crimes who will have to step aside

New Covid-19 variant in South Africa ‘of concern at a...

The Covid-19 B.1.617 variant, first detected in India, is now listed as one of concern, but the World Health Organisation says it does not doubt the efficacy of global vaccines

Your guide to side effects: What you can expect after...

Soon, South Africa will start with its mass vaccine roll-out. We take a look at what to expect when you get vaccinated.

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…