Secrecy Bill: Actually, minister, you got it wrong

Legal experts have challenged the ANC’s claim that international precedent does not show a need for a public interest clause in legislation concerning the protection of state information.

Civil organisations and the media took to the streets to decry the Protection of Information Bill, which the National Assembly voted in with 229 votes. The M&G takes a look at the protests across the country.

A public interest clause would protect individuals who disclose classified information on the basis that the public’s right to know outweighs any potential harm that would come from revealing the information. Civil groups lobbied to have such a clause included in the Protection of State Information Bill but it was not included.

As the Bill stands, anyone who receives leaked documents would be compelled to hand them to the police or face prosecution. If they felt the information was in the public interest they would then have to request that the minister of state security declassify the documents. Those who contravened the law would be subject to a fine or imprisonment of up to 25 years.

During a National Assembly debate on the Bill earlier this month, State Security Minister Siyabonga Cwele said: “We have looked at international best practices and there is no country which practises such reckless practice.” He said that even Britain’s Official Secrets Act did not include a public interest defence.

But Prisca Orsonneau, a lawyer at the Paris Bar and coordinator of the legal committee of media-freedom organisation Reporters Without Borders, said that Cwele’s statement was caricatured Western countries’ laws and showed that the ANC lacked sound legal advice in drafting the Bill.

“The reality is more complex than that,” she said. “It is not because Western countries are not always in accordance with the best practices that South Africa should not respect international standards.”

‘Harms test’
According to Orsonneau, some countries, including the United Kingdom, had specific laws to protect whistleblowers, while others had access to information laws that took into account the public interest. There were exceptions for extremely sensitive material but these had to pass a “harms test”, in which a judge weighed the legitimacy of the state’s reasons for keeping the information secret and the risk that releasing the documents posed to national security against the right to freedom of expression.

Jonathan Klaaren, dean of the Wits University law school, said that both the government and those opposing the Bill should recognise that a public interest defence was not necessarily as simple as inserting a clause into the legislation.

“Even where there is no explicit public interest defence there can be an implicit public interest defence,” he said. In such cases courts would be called on to interpret the law and could find a way to allow disclosure because of public interest.

In the United States, for example, there was no single law concerning disclosure of classified information. Rather, there was what the Harvard Law Review referred to as “a patchwork of laws and provisions serving that function, each applying in different circumstances”.

An executive order on classified national security information issued by US President Barack Obama last year stated that information could be classified only if its unauthorised disclosure “could reasonably be expected to cause identifiable or describable damage to the national security”, and also that “if there is any doubt about the need to classify information it shall not be classified”. It also specified that nothing in the order would limit the protection afforded by other legislation, including the American Constitution and three related Acts.

This contrasts sharply with South Africa’s secrecy Bill, which, if it is promulgated, would take precedence over other Acts, including the Promotion of Access to Information Act.

Constitutional law expert Pierre de Vos said there was a precedent for a public interest defence. He pointed to the Council of Europe Convention on Access to Official Documents, the international standards set out by the non-governmental organisation Article 19 and to Canada’s Security of Information Act.

The European convention states that access to information contained in an official document may be refused if its disclosure could harm specific security interests, unless there is an overriding public interest in disclosure.

Canada’s laws concerning state secrets include a public interest defence which explicitly states that individuals who disclose classified information will not be found guilty of an offence if they have acted in the public interest.

The passing of the Protection of State Information Bill came as no surprise, raising the threat to media freedom. View our special report.


Hlophe complaint is an eerie echo

But the new complaint against the Western Cape judge president is also unprecedented

Mabuza contract grows by R10m

Eskom’s negotiators in a R100-million maintenance contract came back with a proposal to push up the costs

‘There were no marks on his neck’, Neil Aggett inquest...

The trade unionist’s partner at the time he was detained at John Vorster Square says she now believes his death was not a suicide

Study unpacks the ‘hidden racism’ at Stellenbosch

Students say they feel unseen and unheard at the university because of their skin colour

Press Releases

Silencing the guns and firearms amnesty

Silencing the guns and firearms amnesty

Gender-based violence is an affront to our humanity

Gender-based violence is an affront to our humanity

UK-Africa investment summit 2020: Think Africa Invest SA

UK-Africa investment summit 2020: Think Africa Invest SA

MTN unveils TikTok bundles

Customised MTN TikTok data bundles are available to all prepaid customers on *136*2#.

Marketers need to reinvent themselves

Marketing is an exciting discipline, offering the perfect fit for individuals who are equally interested in business, human dynamics and strategic thinking. But the...

Upskill yourself to land your dream job in 2020

If you received admission to an IIE Higher Certificate qualification, once you have graduated, you can articulate to an IIE Diploma and then IIE Bachelor's degree at IIE Rosebank College.

South Africans unsure of what to expect in 2020

Almost half (49%) of South Africans, 15 years and older, agree or strongly agree that they view 2020 with optimism.

KZN teacher educators jet off to Columbia University

A group of academics were selected as participants of the programme focused on PhD completion, mobility, supervision capacity development and the generation of high-impact research.