Malema not in the political wilderness just yet

Julius Malema may be facing a massive battle to save his political career after his expulsion from the ANC but he is not in the political wilderness just yet.

The ruling party’s national disciplinary committee (NDC) formally expelled Malema on Wednesday after deliberating over arguments offered in mitigation of sentence.

The expulsion is the latest stage in the disciplinary process which began in August last year.

Although the ruling could be construed as the end of Malema’s attempts to remain in the ruling party, the controversial youth leader is left with a number of options to save his skin.

Appeal some more
After initially being suspended from the ANC for five years in November, Malema challenged the NDC’s ruling on the grounds the charges against him were politically motivated.

The national disciplinary committee of appeals (NDCA) overruled his argument, but allowed him the opportunity to argue in mitigation of his sentence — as they did the ANC.

As the NDC returned with a fresh sentence of expulsion, Malema is once again afforded the opportunity of appealing the sentence.

He must file his appeal within 14 days of the sanction being handed down.

Ebrahim Fakir, political analyst at the Electoral Institute for the Sustainability of Democracy in Africa (EISA), said even appealing the latest judgment would not be in Malema’s best interests.

“The NDCA showed in the first appeal hearing that their tolerance and appetite for his behaviour is already marginal. It would be foolhardy for Malema to think he’s going to get a different result,” Fakir told the Mail & Guardian.

Malema remains youth league president as well a full member of the ANC until the secondary appeals process is finalised.

Next stop: NEC
If Malema’s appeal fails again, his next port of call would be the ANC’s national executive committee (NEC).

However, this would be a tall order as he would first have to convince the NEC his case is worthy enough to be heard by them.

He would then have to garner the support of over half of the ruling party’s main decision body in accordance with section 12 of the ANC constitution.

While support is evident for Malema among some of the ANC’s top brass, initial indications show he would struggle to put together sufficient numbers to have the decision returned to the NDC.

Nonetheless, there has been a precedent of sorts set in this regard.

In 2006, former ANC chief whip Mbulelo Goniwe was found guilty by the ANC’s NDC on a charge of bringing the party into disrepute after attempting to use his political office to obtain sexual favours.

Goniwe successfully brought the matter before the NEC, who then overturned the ruling issued by then NDC chair Kader Asmal.

But it didn’t all go Goniwe’s way, as the NEC ruled the process had to start afresh and he was found guilty again and sentenced to a three-year suspended suspension.

Additionally, getting the matter on the NEC meeting’s agenda will be a challenge.

It involves applying to ANC secretary general Gwede Mantashe, who determines the programme.

This does not bode well for Malema as he has often called for Mantashe to be replaced at the next ANC elective conference by former league president Fikile Mbalula.

“There is no guarantee the NEC would be sympathetic to him. If they even decide to hear him, the best they can do is return it to the NDC and Malema should realise by now the NDC won’t rule in his favour,” said Eusebius McKaiser, political and social analyst at the Wits Centre for Ethics.

Delay until Mangaug
Alternatively, Malema could attempt to have his sentence quashed at the ANC’s next elective conference in Mangaung in December.

This would involve tabling a motion to nullify all disciplinary charges against him to voting delegates at the conference.

As per section 11.3 of the ruling party’s constitution, the conference is granted the power to “review, ratify, alter or rescind” any decision taken by the ANC or its constituent bodies.

But Malema must first assure he attends Mangaung by delaying the process surrounding the appeal of his expulsion. Should that process already be concluded, it would be up to other ANC members to take up the cause.

His former comrades would also be hesitant to throw their hat in with a persona non grata.

“He would need sympathy from a very influential person on the ANC NEC to pull this one off. That person would have to take up his cause and based on the current mood within the party, I don’t see anyone being foolish enough to do so. By supporting Malema they are putting their political careers in danger,” Fakir said.

Should these recognised avenues to challenge the expulsion fail, Malema could count on the youth league sticking with their decision to disregard the NDC’s ruling completely.

On several occasions, the league has said it would defy any sanction handed down to Malema as the ANC must “inform and convince” league members of the decision to institute disciplinary action.

It would be dangerous territory for the youth league as the ANC’s “top six” leaders — including President Jacob Zuma and Mantashe — have the power to dissolve the youth body, and call a fresh elective conference.

Moreover, Fakir said the ANC would not accept the youth league defying an NDC order.

“The league would be shooting themselves in the foot if they went this route. The ANC would look bad both nationally and internationally and would thus send a message that such a move is unacceptable,” Fakir said.

This was echoed by McKaiser who said the youth league would embarrass themselves by defying any NDC ruling.

“Malema would have no right whatsoever to be an active ANC member, talk on party platforms or even come near Luthuli House. The ANC would then be forced to use security or a court interdict to remove him from the premises if he showed up after his expulsion is finalised,” McKaiser said.

In desperation, Malema could elect to take the matter to court as an absolute last resort.

Although he has previously said this will never happen, Malema could use alleged violations of the process in which his expulsion order was handed down.

Before the NDC announced their final decision, Malema’s legal representative Dali Mpofu confirmed to the M&G that a formal complaint based on lack of notice was issued to the ANC.

But it could be an extremely risky strategy as anyone who has taken the ANC to court has never survived politically.

“At the best it would be a Pyrrhic victory as the ANC have a history of alienating those who drag political matters into the legal domain. Aside from that, the NDC was so thorough, Malema would struggle to find a legal basis to challenge the findings,” McKaiser said.

For more news and multimedia on ANC Youth League president Julius Malema click here.

In a previous version of the story, we said Eusebius McKaiser is a political analyst at the Centre for the Study of Democracy. He is, in fact, a political analyst at the Wits Centre for Ethics.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Nickolaus Bauer
Nickolaus Bauer is the Mail & Guardian's jack of all trades news reporter that chases down stories ranging from politics and sports to big business and social justice. Armed with an iPad, SLR camera, camcorder and dictaphone, he aims to fight ignorance and pessimism through written words, photographs and videos. He believes South Africa could be the greatest country in the world if only her citizens would give her a chance to flourish instead of dwell on the negativity. When he's not begging his sub-editors for an extra twenty minutes after deadline, he's also known to dabble in the occasional poignant column that will leave you mulling around in the depths of your psyche. The quintessential workaholic, you can also catch him doing sports on the weekday breakfast show on SAfm and presenting the SAfm Sports Special over the weekend.

Related stories


Subscribers only

Q&A Sessions: Marcia Mayaba —Driven to open doors for women

Marcia Mayaba has been in the motor industry for 24 years, donning hats that include receptionist, driver, fuel attendant, dealer principal and now chief...

The war on women in video game culture

Women and girls make up almost half of the gaming community but are hardly represented and face abuse in the industry

More top stories

Gatvol Capetonians, EFF lash out at City of Cape Town...

Public infrastructure was allegedly damaged by the activist group in 2019 and by the Economic Freedom Fighters in 2020

Masuku loses appeal against SIU report on Covid graft

The judge found that when news of improprieties were brought to his attention, Masuku did not take steps to urgently intervene

Leaking De Ruyter’s affidavit countering racism claims was ‘malicious’ and...

Mkhuleko Hlengwa has pointed to people in Eskom or the public enterprises department for making the document public

SABS ‘contemplates’ 170 retrenchments to save R150m

Salaries account for 65% of the South African Bureau of Standards’ total operating‌ costs

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…