Chinese bubble economy: The bulls versus the bears

Diana Choyleva is the bear in the China shop. The analyst from Lombard Street Research in London believes that last week’s gross domestic product (GDP) figures for China – which revealed growth slowing to a three-year low – are an early warning signal of the hard landing to come.

All that is propping up the economy is gargantuan investment in infrastructure financed by state-directed banks that look more and more like Western banks just before the collapse of 2008. Westerners are so awed by the China dream that they cannot see the coming China-geddon. The excesses that have driven the West into a financial crisis are gripping the Chinese economy, too.

“China’s miracle growth is over,” said Choyleva, adding that if Chinese policy-makers got it right they might, just, see the country’s growth halve to 5% or below. Get it wrong and the consequences could be devastating – not just for China but for the rest of the world too.

Liquidity crisis
“[China] can no longer rely on abroad to buy its excess production. The US will consume less and produce more. The years of current account surpluses are over, rendering the growth model obsolete.”

Meanwhile, the banks that have been the lynchpin of growth are insolvent and their bad loans will eventually lead to a liquidity crisis.

But Choyleva’s is a lone voice. At brokerage CLSA, one of the Asian region’s biggest investment banks, China macrostrategist Andy Rothman said the wall of worry came from a fundamental misunderstanding.
The first myth is that China is an export economy. It is not. Over the past decade, although it enjoyed GDP growth of 10% a year, only 1% of that was from exports.

According to Rothman, it is not an unbalanced export-only economy, instead, it is the world’s best domestic-consumption story. It is being driven by “phenomenal” increases in wages for average workers; incomes are up by 173% over the past 11 years.

That also puts the so-called property bubble into perspective. The price of an apartment in a major Chinese city has leapt by nearly 10% a year for many years. But as incomes are rising even faster – by about 13% a year – it is not the issue it became in the West.

Better still, it is not on the never-never list. Mortgages are still in their infancy in China. One in five first-time buyers purchase with cash. The average down payment is 30% – a long way from the 100% loans that became common in the United States and the United Kingdom. – © Guardian News & Media 2012

Patrick Collinson
Patrick Collinson works from London. Patrick Collinson is editor of Guardian Money and the newspaper's personal finance editor Patrick Collinson has over 11712 followers on Twitter.

ANC and the state step back from taking action against...

Despite alleged abuses of power and people’s trust, the ANC appears to have abandoned plans to reform the controversial Ingonyama Trust Board

Mkhwebane moves to halt ‘grossly unfair’ impeachment process

Mkhwebane moves to halt ‘grossly unfair’ impeachment process

Chaos theory: How Jürgen Klopp has harnessed the unpredictable

The Liverpool manager has his side playing unstoppable football but it’s the attention to detail off the field that has bred the success

Miners speak out against Sibanye

Not a year into buying Lonmin, Sibanye is accused of mistreating the mineworkers who were injured eight years ago during the Marikana massacre. But the platinum giant says it is a miscommunication. Athandiwe Saba and Paul Botes visit Marikana to find out the truth

Press Releases

Wellcome Trust award goes to UKZN mental health champion

Dr Andr? J van Rensburg, a senior researcher in UKZN's Centre for Rural Health, received the Wellcome Trust Discretionary Award.

MTN gears up to deliver improved customer service

On 28 January, the first batch of MTN contract customers will be migrated onto the new customer service platform.

Request for expression of interest on analysis of quality and outcome indicators for regional and district hospitals in Lesotho

Introduction The Ministry of Health of Lesotho with the support of the World Bank funded Nutrition and Health Systems Strengthening...

MiX Telematics enhances in-vehicle video camera solution

The company has launched the gold MiX Vision Bureau Service, which includes driver-coaching tools to ensure risky driver behaviour can be addressed proactively and efficiently.

Boosting safety for cargo and drivers

The use of a telematics system for fleet vehicles has proved to be an important tool in helping to drive down costs and improve efficiency, says MiX Telematics Africa.

Silencing the guns and firearms amnesty

Silencing the guns and firearms amnesty

Gender-based violence is an affront to our humanity

Gender-based violence is an affront to our humanity

UK-Africa investment summit 2020: Think Africa Invest SA

UK-Africa investment summit 2020: Think Africa Invest SA