Appeal tribunal shreds classification of 'The Spear'

The Film and Publications Board cannot ban online images, an appeal tribunal told it this week. (M&G)

The Film and Publications Board cannot ban online images, an appeal tribunal told it this week. (M&G)

It cannot impose age restrictions on publications and websites not involved in its classification process. It cannot use the protection of children as a reason  when it wants to protect the dignity of a specific segment of society and may not assume that any nudity in art is automatically harmful to children.

The board erred in a number of respects when it classified the painting, "The Spear", depicting president Jacob Zuma with his genitals exposed, as restricted for children under 16, tribunal chairperson  Karthy Govender wrote in a decision that struck down all classifications on Brett Murray's painting.

"It is apparent from the reasoning of the classification committee that it was heavily influenced by the need to affirm the dignity of African males and protect sensitive persons and children." But even though that could perhaps be excused, "given the intensity of the furore", it went beyond the law, the tribunal said.

It also rejected the board's attempts to justify the classification after the fact on the basis that it could harm "children raised with cultural norms and values that find the public display of an African elder's genitals deeply offensive".

Especially with art, the tribunal found, plain nudity is not enough and harm to children has to be more than likely, not just a possibility.

The ruling on "The Spear" comes less than two weeks after the Constitutional Court found unconstitutional a provision that would have required magazines with any sexual content to submit to pre-publication classification.

Phillip de Wet

Phillip de Wet

Phillip de Wet writes about politics, society, economics, and the areas where these collide. He has never been anything other than a journalist, though he has been involved in starting new newspapers, magazines and websites, a suspiciously large percentage of which are no longer in business. PGP fingerprint: CF74 7B0F F037 ACB9 779C 902B 793C 8781 4548 D165 Read more from Phillip de Wet

Client Media Releases

Utility outages: looking at the big picture
UKZN scientists get L'Or'eal-UNESCO Women in Science grants
Springbok-mania hits MTN head office
Optimise your SMS campaigns this Black Friday