E Cape minister’s quotes ‘taken out of context’

The report that the minister of education in the Eastern Cape, Makupula, told pupils on the weekend that they had no rights, was out of context, the Eastern Cape education department said on Wednesday.

“He said these things in jest, he was only trying to be humorous. He wasn’t suggesting in any way that children don’t have rights,” spokesperson for the department, Loyiso Pulumani, told the Mail & Guardian.

The Eastern Cape’s Dispatch Online reported on Tuesday that Makupula told a debating context on the weekend that no children under the age of 21, who are still dependent on their parents for food and shelter, had any rights.

The report quoted the minister saying: “For you, rights come later in life when you are independent, finished studying and have your own place to stay and your own car. That is when you can start talking about rights."

He was addressing hundreds of pupils at a provincial schools’ debate on Eastern Cape Premier Noxolo Kiviet’s state of the province address.

He allegedly referred to an Eastern Cape boy who took his father to court after he was forced to attend initiation school. This would not have happened in his home, he reportedly said.

“I asked myself what was wrong with that boy. His father did go to the initiation school, but because of the rights now, he did not want to go there himself … I wish he could have been my child, I would have hit him on the head with a knobkerrie and he would have gone to that initiation school crying.”

'African idioms'
But Pulumani said the provincial minister did not say these things “in so many words”.

“There has been a misunderstanding of African idioms here. You need to try to understand the cultural differences here and the nuances in language.”

Makupula spoke in both English and isiXhosa at the “jovial and happy” event, he said.

“Sometimes as a Xhosa man you will talk to another Xhosa man and say ‘I think you have forgotten my knobkerrie’ but it is not supposed to come across as violent,” he said.

Rights groups the Legal Resources Centre (LRC) and the Centre for Child Law reacted with outrage on Tuesday, saying his comments show “an astonishing misunderstanding of the constitutional rights”.

“We have no confidence in a provincial minister for education who would brazenly disregard the rights of children,” they said.

'State of chaos'
Regional director of the LRC, Sarah Sephton, told the M&G that Makupula’s comments are an example of “the state of chaos in the Eastern Cape department of education.

“His comments aren’t so surprising when you have a provincial minister who doesn’t think it’s very serious that there are over 6 000 teacher vacancies in the province and the department has made no indication to schools that it is dealing with the matter urgently,” she said.

Pulumani said it was regrettable that the focus was taken away from the debate and its “high quality”.

“The minister was amazed by the quality of the debate and he was congratulating the pupils on this. It’s regrettable that some of the things he said came across in an unintended way. There was no malicious intent,” he said.

We make it make sense

If this story helped you navigate your world, subscribe to the M&G today for just R30 for the first three months

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.”

Victoria John
Victoria studied journalism, specialising in photojournalism, at Rhodes University from 2004 to 2007. After traveling around the US and a brief stint in the UK she did a year's internship at The Independent on Saturday in Durban. She then worked as a reporter for the South African Press Association for a year before joining the Mail & Guardian as an education reporter in August 2011.

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Test cricket is dead, but not for the eager Proteas

Even before the demise of this format of the game was predicted, the women’s team had little opportunity to experience and enjoy it

Where are the anti-racism accountability bodies?

The field of such NGOs is crowded but who and what are they holding to account and who are they mollycoddling?

South Africa’s factory gate inflation set for another rise

Producer price inflation reached 13.1% in April, marking the highest print since 2012

Electricity for all in Africa in eight years a possibility...

The Africa Energy Outlook 2022 report charts how the continent can get electricity to everyone by 2030.

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…