State’s forensic experts bid denied in Carl Pistorius case

The Vanderbijlpark Magistrate's Court made this ruling on Wednesday in response to an application by the prosecution.

"It is impossible for the state to foresee every possible defence that the accused may produce," Magistrate Buks du Plessis said.

"At this stage, the court is denying the state's application to amend its further particulars."

Carl Pistorius is facing a culpable homicide charge after an accident in 2008 that led to the death of a 36-year-old woman.

Prosecutor Johan Venter said the state intended calling new witnesses but added he was not sure exactly who.

Kenny Oldwage, for Pistorius, said the state was infringing on his client's rights. The state's approach to wait for Pistorius to testify before revealing which witnesses it would call amounted to a "trial by ambush".

"Carl Pistorius has the right to a fair trial – he must know the state's case. It is an indictment on the criminal justice system … to do this," Oldwage said.

"The state must disclose its case … in the form of evidence … We cannot in these circumstances plead."

Reinstating charges
Prosecutor Johan Venter said he only joined the case on Tuesday and that the state was not sure who the expert witnesses would be. 

Du Plessis said the case was first on the court roll and then struck off the roll, but the director of public prosecutions decided to reinstate the charges in December 2011. He said when the National Prosecuting Authority decided to reinstate charges it needed to have the evidence to prove Carl Pistorius's guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

"The question is not the accused's defence, it is his guilt in terms of what the state can prove," he said.

Oldwage indicated that the defence would call a crime scene reconstruction expert to testify.

Pistorius (28) sat in the dock with his arms folded and occasionally looked down during the proceedings. His family, sitting in the front row of the public gallery, held onto each other.

Earlier in the day, an application by the South African Broadcasting Corporation to broadcast the trial was dismissed. "The court is however open to revisit this ruling in terms of judgment when the time comes," Du Plessis said in handing down the judgment. He also added that the media were allowed to take photographs and moving images when the proceedings were not ongoing.

Joe Nalane, for the SABC, said the trial was in the public interest and that Carl Pistorius was a high profile person when he brought the application.

Venter opposed the application, saying it was not in the public interest and that the matter should be dealt with like any other.

Media interest
Oldwage also opposed the application, saying he had been involved with the case from the onset and was not aware of media interest prior to Olympian Oscar Pistorius's case. 

Broadcasting the case would impose on Carl's right to a fair trial, he said.

"It is common cause that he is here because he is the brother of Oscar."

Oscar Pistorius was charged with the murder of his girlfriend, law graduate and model Reeva Steenkamp.

Oldwage said media interest in Oscar Pistorius's case made it difficult for the legal team to do its work.

Du Plessis said the accident happened on March 8 2008. He said the case was called on September 12 2012, October 23 2012 and on February 21 2013. "I was the presiding officer on February 21 and there was no media present in court," said Du Plessis.

"The only reason the media is interested is because Mr Carl Pistorius is the brother of well-known athlete Oscar Pistorius."

Carl's appearance came a day before Oscar Pistorius is expected to challenge the bail conditions the Pretoria Magistrate's Court imposed on him. – Sapa

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Related stories

Tall inside, but not short of opinions

Navigating the world as a little person is no big deal. But it can be exhausting when other people feel entitled to comment on your height

Expert witness testimony matches Duduzane’s story

An accident reconstruction expert’s testimony confirmed that the former president’s son was well within the speed limit on the night of his crash

Duduzane Zuma culpable homicide case continues

The former president's son will appear in court on Thursday

NPA insider tells NDPP panel Abrahams refused to tackle interference

Advocate Andrea Johnson revealed that former NPA boss Shaun Abrahams ‘chose not to listen’

Duduzani Zuma culpable homicide case postponed

The case relates to a car accident that occurred in February 2014 where one person was killed instantly

Duduzani Zuma culpable homicide case postponed

The charges relate to a car accident in February 2014 where Zuma lost control of his car and rear-ended a taxi

Subscribers only

The shame of 40 000 missing education certificates

Graduates are being left in the lurch by a higher education department that is simply unable to deliver the crucial certificates proving their qualifications - in some cases dating back to 1992

The living nightmare of environmental activists who protest mine expansion

Last week Fikile Ntshangase was gunned down as activists fight mining company Tendele’s expansions. Community members tell the M&G about the ‘kill lists’ and the dread they live with every day

More top stories

Fifteen witnesses for vice-chancellor probe

Sefako Makgatho University vice-chancellor Professor Peter Mbati had interdicted parliament last month from continuing with the inquiry

Constitutional Court ruling on restructuring dispute is good for employers

A judgment from the apex court empowers employers to change their workers’ contracts — without consultation

Audi Q8: Perfectly cool

The Audi Q8 is designed to be the king in the elite SUV class. But is it a victim of its own success?

KZN officials cash in on ‘danger pay for Covid-19’

Leadership failures at Umdoni local municipality in KwaZulu-Natal have caused a ‘very unhappy’ ANC PEC to fire the mayor and chief whip

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday