Home Article Grant: Sadtu must pay for schools’ legal costs

Grant: Sadtu must pay for schools’ legal costs

0
Grant: Sadtu must pay for schools’ legal costs

This emerged in the Western Cape High Court on Tuesday, where the 17 school governing bodies were asking for a review of education provincial minister Donald Grant's move to close the schools.

Eduard Fagan, for Grant and his department, told the court the matter was clearly politically motivated.

He cited the presence of African National Congress Western Cape chairperson Marius Fransman during proceedings on Monday as proof of this.

The ANC-affiliated South African Democratic Teachers' Union (Sadtu) is also an applicant in the matter.

Fagan said the province would not be seeking costs from the school governing bodies, but Sadtu should be made to pay costs because of the political nature of the case.


Legally and procedurally fair
Fagan on Tuesday concluded his arguments in court, insisting the process leading to the decision to close the schools was legally and procedurally fair. He said the Schools Act did not compel his client to consult affected communities.

The provincial department did, however, give school governing bodies an opportunity, during public hearings last year, to make representations to Grant on his intention to close schools.

Fagan argued Grant supplied the schools with sufficient reasons for their closure before they were asked to make representations.

The Western Cape education department is in agreement with a minority judgment by Judge Dennis Davis last year. In the minority judgment, Davis said after "anxious reflection" he would only have made an order in the case of two schools.

He found Grant had complied with the Schools Act in allowing representations, and that there was no legal basis for importing the concept "meaningful engagement" into the wording of that section.

The act ultimately empowered Grant to make the final decision on school closures, he said.

His two colleagues, Siraj Desai and Elizabeth Baartman, did not agree and granted the schools an urgent interdict halting the closures, pending the outcome of a final review process.

The Western Cape High Court has reserved judgment on the matter. – Sapa

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday