Israel challenged by Iran charm offensive

As Iran's new president reaches out to the West with a message of moderation, Israel's hawkish approach on Tehran's nuclear programme looks likely to come under pressure, experts say.

President Hassan Rowhani on Tuesday emphasised the peaceful nature of the Islamic republic's atomic programme, telling the UN General Assembly that "nuclear weapons… have no place in Iran's security and defence doctrine."

Israel scrambled to denounce the speech, with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu calling it "cynical" and "full of hypocrisy".

"This is exactly Iran's strategy – to talk and play for time in order to advance its ability to achieve nuclear weapons. Rowhani knows this well," charged Netanyahu.

But Rowhani's diplomatic overtures, which stand in stark contrast to the belligerent statements so commonly heard from his predecessor Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, are proving to be quite a challenge to the Israeli premier.

"For the past eight years, Israel's efforts to convince the world … to tackle Iran's nuclear designs head on relied on… adamant, Holocaust-denying Ahmadinejad," commentator Chemi Shalevan wrote in Haaretz newspaper.

"Ahmadinejad… served as Israel's number one talking point, its strategic propaganda asset, a poster boy who self-explained Tehran's sinister designs."

Diplomatic challenge
Rowhani's message is a "real diplomatic challenge for Israel," Professor Uzi Rabi, an Iran specialist at Tel Aviv University, told Agence France-Presse.

"The last time Netanyahu was at the United Nations, it was much easier for Israel to argue on Iran. I'm not sure shouting… is the best Israel can come up with [this time]," he said.

Last year, Netanyahu stood before the UN General Assembly and drew a red line on a cartoonish depiction of a bomb, saying the international community must act to prevent Iran from using its nuclear programme to build a weapon, a charge accepted by the West but denied by Tehran.

This year, when he addresses the UN General Assembly on October 1, the Israeli leader will seek to play down the differences between Rowhani and his predecessor, the top-selling Yediot Aharonot daily said.

"Netanyahu will say that, like Ahmadinejad, Rowhani also adheres to the goal of destroying the State of Israel and attacking the entire Western world."

Rabi agreed: "Israel is trying to make sure everyone is keenly aware that the Iranian charm offensive is just tactics – it doesn't mean there's real change."

Nuclear talks
Israel's concerns over a thaw were further stoked on Monday when officials said US Secretary of State John Kerry would hold his first nuclear talks with Iran's Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif at a landmark meeting at the UN headquarters on September 26.

"Netanyahu… is not going to be in the negotiations room so he's trying to remind the US of the reality that there's not been evidence of change," Dr Emily Landau of Tel Aviv University's Institute for National Security Studies said.

Israel fears the meeting could undermine its efforts to put further pressure on Iran, according to Dr Raz Zimmt, a research fellow at Tel Aviv University's Iranian studies centre.

"Israel's government and prime minister are facing difficulties convincing the international community to treat Iran the same way it has treated it before," Zimmt said.

"In the West, they see Rowhani as totally different from Ahmadinejad. They're right, but… Rowhani hasn't come up with a concrete proposal on how to resolve the nuclear issue.

"Any pact between Iran and the West… might isolate Israel," Zimmt said.

Washington has been "working behind the scenes to allay Israeli concerns and has said that the Iranian president will be judged by his actions," Israel's Maariv newspaper said on Sunday.

But Rowhani's "charm offensive", together with developments in the wider Middle East region, may trump Israel's protestations, analysts warned.

"Both the US and Iranian administrations have decided there's a window of opportunity to talk," Zimmt said.

As part of efforts to burnish the Islamic republic's image, Rowhani's delegation to the UN includes a Jewish MP, Iranian media reported.

Holocaust is 'reprehensible'
And in a radical about-turn from his Holocaust-denying predecessor's rhetoric, Rowhani, in an interview with CNN, condemned the Nazi genocide as a "reprehensible" crime.

"I'm not sure the US can help it. Rowhani is the star of the UN," Rabi said.

"The Iranians could come up with an interim suspension of uranium enrichment, but in the long term Iran is going to prevail when it comes to its nuclear plan," Rabi predicted.

And with much of the Middle East in crisis, Iran knows Washington may need its help in other areas, such as Syria.

"This is why they're coming up with a new initiative" to talk with the West, Rabi said, saying Iran was "capitalising on the Syria saga".

But Landau disagreed, saying the real reason for Iran's reaching out was the pressure of Western sanctions.

"What we're not seeing is any indication that Iran is willing to change course as far as the nuclear issue is concerned," she said.

"The US wants to see real concrete steps from Iran." – AFP

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever. But it comes at a cost. Advertisers are cancelling campaigns, and our live events have come to an abrupt halt. Our income has been slashed.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years. We’ve survived thanks to the support of our readers, we will need you to help us get through this.

To help us ensure another 35 future years of fiercely independent journalism, please subscribe.


Sadtu calls for the closure of schools

Citing cases such as a school to which only four learners returned, to be met by 20 teachers, the union said Covid-19 is wreaking havoc on learning

SAA creditors give go-ahead on rescue plan

Unions and staff representatives have agreed to severance packages for about 2 700 employees who will lose their jobs.

Basic income grant on the cards as Covid-19 threat intensifies

The pandemic has triggered a global economic crisis that will leave many South Africans without income security

Reinstated Ingonyama Trust managers hit with retrenchment notices

The effect of Covid-19 and the land reform department’s freeze of R23-million because the ITB didn’t comply with budget submissions are cited as some of the reasons for the staff cuts

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…

The best local and international journalism

handpicked and in your inbox every weekday