Zille rejects equity quotas as ‘Verwoerdian measures’

Coercive equity quotas are a Verwoerdian wrong the Democratic Alliance (DA) should not and will not support, party leader Helen Zille said on Thursday.

Zille told the Cape Town Press Club this was why the DA needed to reject the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Bill and the Employment Equity Amendment Bill.

Ultimately, the revised legislative regime would impose "rigid racial-based quotas", she said.

"There was absolutely no excuse for the DA supporting Verwoerdian measures like that."

Zille was trying to clear up the DA's public policy spat on economic equality legislation, which she has termed a "plane crash" and which has pitted her against the party's parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko and caucus.

She steered the DA into a legislative U-turn after it voted in favour of the Bills in the National Assembly and told the South African Press Association of Mazibuko's support for the measures: "She got it completely wrong."

Position on affirmative action
On Thursday, Zille set out a highly nuanced position on affirmative action, saying the party, in the words of one of its billboard slogans, "supports BEE that creates jobs, not billionaires".

Zille said this was why the party initially voted in favour of the Broad-based Black Economic Empowerment Bill – it created incentives for employing previously disadvantaged individuals but did not resort to coercive measures that would scare off investors.

It changed its stance and took a stand against it in the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) because, she said, Trade and Industry Minister Rob Davies reneged on assurances on the code of good practice attached to the Bill.

One of the most objectionable provisions in the code in her opinion was the threshold for determining the extent to which a beneficiary could profit from share transfers.

Instead of dropping this to R10-million, as Davies had promised DA MPs, it was raised to R50-million, making it a recipe for entrenching "race-based crony enrichment".

When the Bill came back to the National Assembly this week because the NCOP had made changes, the DA voted against it.

Shift from liberal individualism
On the Equity Bill, Zille said, the DA's true position was always abundantly clear, despite how MPs voted.

It would not support any law that sought to impose race quotas through "draconian penalties" imposed by unelected officials.

The DA this week tried unsuccessfully to effect amendments to the Employment Equity Bill in a NCOP committee and save face after it voted for it in the National Assembly only to see MPs rebuked by Zille.

Asked whether the internal fallout had made her rethink vague plans to step down as party leader in 2015 and possibly hand the reins to Mazibuko, she answered: "As soon as somebody else can do this job better than me, I will leave and I will do something else for the cause."

The press club gathering took place at the elite Kelvin Grove Club in the DA heartland and Zille took care to explain the party's shift from liberal individualism to a more "substantive" approach that allowed for affirmative action.

"We believe it is also part of the state's role to provide a ladder and for some people the rungs of that ladder have to be closer because they don't start at the same place … we are trying to reconcile that with our other fundamental beliefs." – Sapa

Keep the powerful accountable

Subscribe for R30/mth for the first three months. Cancel anytime.

Subscribers get access to all our best journalism, subscriber-only newsletters, events and a weekly cryptic crossword.

Related stories


Already a subscriber? Sign in here


Latest stories

Kenya’s top court reviews disputed bid to change constitution

The Supreme Court ruling on the proposed constitutional changes, expected after three days of hearings this week, may have major consequences for the August 9 presidential and parliamentary polls.

Democracy delayed in Mali spurs sanctions from neighbours

Mali’s junta now finds itself ostracised by its regional peers – and at the centre of a dangerous new geopolitical game.

‘Armed bandit’ or ‘bandit terrorist’? In Nigeria, the game of...

Over the past two months a controversy has developed over the government’s desire to relabel armed outlaws as ‘bandit terrorists’.

Bring Patrice Lumumba home

The return of Patrice Lumumba’s remains must not be an occasion for Belgium to congratulate itself, but for a full accounting of the colonial violence that led to the assassination and coverup

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…