Mandela memorial interpreter: SA’s meaningless gestures

The government on Thursday partially apologised to deaf people for the botched sign language at Nelson Mandela's state memorial service on Tuesday, but came to the defence of the interpreter himself and blasted his employers.

It also said that no single government department is responsible for the fiasco and that South Africans have no need to be embarrassed.

"I'm not sure, unless that there is something that I'm missing … I don't think as a country we need to first jump and say that we are embarrassed," said Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu, deputy minister for women, children and people with disabilities, in the first official comment on the incident from the government. "I don't think we should be. Because as a country, a mistake happened while we were trying."

Both the government communications department and the ANC, which were jointly responsible for the event, on Wednesday begged off answering questions about the "creative" interpretation of sign language by Thamsanqa Jantjie while speakers such as President Jacob Zuma and United States President Barack Obama were addressing a crowd of tens of thousands as well as live television audiences numbering in the millions.

The interpretation was so creative that at least three organisations that represent deaf people in South Africa, many experts in local sign language and half a dozen accredited interpreters have said that Jantjie made no sense.

The umbrella group Deaf SA said it has closely analysed his previous work and has no qualms in describing him as a "fake interpreter".

Schizophrenic episode
Bogopane-Zulu's depart­ment was left to answer questions about these claims, many of which she was unable to provide clarity on.

Was Jantjie, who has said he suffered a schizophrenic episode that involved seeing angels during the ceremony, a security risk? That is not known.

Was he security cleared? Probably, but his vetting is still being investigated.

Were proper procurement processes followed, and who was responsible for hiring him? That is not yet known.

But the deputy minister did spring to Jantjie's defence, saying many factors had counted against him, including:

  • The fact that there are were more than 100 dialects of local sign language;
  • As an isiXhosa-speaker, his in-ability to follow English; and
  • The lack of a relief interpreter, leaving him on duty for four hours instead of the maximum recommended 30-minute stint.

Bogopane-Zulu also broadly defended the event organisers and the government. Jantjie, she said, had only been intended as a translator for the audience in the stadium and should not have appeared in television coverage.

Non-existing company
The government had ensured that other sign language interpreters were available for the television broadcast, she said. She added that the attempt to provide a live translation for deaf people is a victory of which Mandela would have been proud.

But there is one party the government is willing to hold responsible: the company Jantjie identified as his employers, SA Interpreters.

The company does not exist, according to registration records, but Bogopane-Zulu said the government "did track down the owners of the company" – initially. "They vanished," she said. "We managed to get hold of them, we spoke to them wanting some answer, and they vanished into clear air.

"Over the years they [Jantjie's employers] have managed to get away with this … offering substandard interpretation services."

It is not clear whether a formal fraud investigation has been initiated. Various government departments and agencies could not be reached, or they said they were too preoccupied with preparations for Mandela's burial in Qunu on Sunday to respond.

Subscribe to the M&G

These are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.

The Mail & Guardian is a proud news publisher with roots stretching back 35 years, and we’ve survived right from day one thanks to the support of readers who value fiercely independent journalism that is beholden to no-one. To help us continue for another 35 future years with the same proud values, please consider taking out a subscription.

Phillip De Wet
Guest Author

Related stories


Subscribers only

‘Captured’ water utility exec holes up

Thami Hlongwa seems to be in hiding after a blacklisted technology company scored millions from Umgeni Water and the owner was murdered

Step-aside guidelines are not about Ace, says Mathews Phosa

The guidelines must be ‘timeless, uniting and not capable of being abused,’ says ANC veteran

More top stories

Pregnant women should be vaccinated, doctors say

New research shows that there has been an increase in maternal deaths during the Covid-19 restriction

Simeone is Atlético’s secret weapon

El Cholo remains true to himself — consistent, totally committed and prepared to graft — and these values are retained by the team

The private-sector players who facilitated public-sector fraud

Let us never forget the private-sector players who facilitated public-sector fraud

Semenya confirms she’s taking testosterone battle to European Court of...

Caster Semenya’s latest legal challenge follows a series of setbacks that seemed to have ended her chances of competing in her preferred events

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…