Get more Mail & Guardian
Subscribe or Login

Ex-girlfriend tells court Oscar attached to his gun

An ex-girlfriend of Oscar Pistorius on Friday portrayed him in court as a man obsessed with firearms who often woke her up at night because he feared somebody was breaking into his house.

Samantha Taylor, testifying on day five of Pistorius's murder trial, stressed that during their relationship Pistorius always alerted her when he suspected there was an intruder.

Prosecutor Gerrie Nel begged Judge Thokozile Masipa's indulgence to introduce fresh evidence before asking Taylor to describe these incidents, taking the disabled Olympic athlete's defence lawyer by surprise.

The former girlfriend recalled one night when Pistorius heard something hit against the bathroom window. "He woke me up and asked if I had heard it. I told him it was probably the storm," said Taylor.

Pistorius on Monday pleaded not guilty to the premeditated murder of Reeva Steenkamp, a blonde model for whom he left the teenaged Taylor. He claims he believed he was targeting an intruder when he fired four shots into a locked bathroom, fatally injuring Steenkamp.

Taylor's testimony on Friday, cast Pistorius as a paranoid and aggressive man who frequently argued with her, and was extremely attached to his cellphones and his handgun. On one occasion he fired a 9mm pistol through the sunroof of a car while driving with her and a friend, she said.

'He cheated on me'
"There was a lot of commotion in our relationship," she said, adding that it ended for good when he attended an award ceremony with Steenkamp. "He cheated on me with Reeva Steenkamp." 

In cross-examination, Pistorius's lawyer Barry Roux immediately reduced Taylor to tears. He said the young woman, who was 17 when she started dating Pistorius, was lying about when their relationship ended and that he would provide copies of their emails to prove this.

Judge Masipa briefly adjourned the court, before Roux resumed questioning and set out to show Taylor's recollection of events during her relationship with Pistorius was unreliable. This included her account of the night he drew his gun at a car he believed had followed them to his home.

Taylor said it was not true, as Pistorius claimed, that he had merely moved to her side to protect her.

The next witness was the chief security guard at the Silver Woods estate where Pistorius shot Steenkamp in the early hours of February 14 last year.

Pieter Baba too became emotional on the stand after describing the events of that night and recalling his shock when he saw Pistorius carry a fatally wounded Steenkamp down the stairs of his house.

Baba said following reports of gunshots at the athlete's home, he had called Pistorius, who told him everything was fine. "Mr Pistorius said to me, 'security, everything is fine'," Baba said.

"I heard that he was crying," he added.

But he told his colleague Jacob who was with him that he was sure that something was wrong. Pistorius then phoned him back, perhaps by accident, and simply sobbed before the line went dead. "I immediately told Jacob everything is not right."

'Everything is fine'
Roux tested his recollection too, asking whether Pistorius said "he is okay" or "everything is okay", and whether he said "okay" or "fine". An exasperated Baba sighed, lowered his head and slowly repeated: "My Lady, the exact words were 'security, everything is fine'." 

Earlier this week, Johan Stipp, a radiologist and neighbour of Pistorius, testified that he found him crying next to a dying Steenkamp at the bottom of the stairs. By then Steenkamp had no pulse and it was too late to save her life, he said.

During cross-examination of Stipp on Friday, Roux challenged his recollection that Pistorius told him that he shot Steenkamp because he believed she was an intruder. "Mr Pistorius says he can't remember telling you he thought she was an intruder … He recalls asking you to help him," said Roux.

But Stipp maintained that Pistorius had given him this explanation. "I shot her. I thought she was a burglar. I shot her," he quoted Pistorius as saying.

Roux has doggedly tried to cast doubt on the credibility of every witness since the trial began on Monday.

He has put it to Stipp and other neighbours it was impossible that they were woken, as they claim, on the night Steenkamp died by a woman's screams followed by gunshots. Roux claims it was in fact Pistorius who they heard scream, and that his voice could easily be mistaken for a woman's because it rose when he was distraught.

However when Nel asked Taylor whether Pistorius (27) sounded like a man or a woman when he shouted, she was adamant: "It sounded like a man, My Lady."

The trial will resume on Monday morning. – Sapa

Subscribe to the M&G

Thanks for enjoying the Mail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.

Digital subscribers get access to all of our award-winning journalism, including premium features, as well as exclusive events, newsletters, webinars and the cryptic crossword. Click here to find out how to join them.

Related stories


Subscribers only

First-of-its-kind rangeland atlas pushes for protection

Rangelands are ‘nature’s gift to humanity’, but have been overlooked, neglected

The health minister is on the ropes for dodgy vibes...

Mkhize’s request to take special leave left President Cyril Ramaphosa reeling, party insiders say

More top stories

First-of-its-kind rangeland atlas pushes for protection

Rangelands are ‘nature’s gift to humanity’, but have been overlooked, neglected

Verena C still collects water from a stream after projects...

Residents of Verena C in Mpumalanga have to collect water from a polluted stream after projects costing millions of rands failed

The health minister is on the ropes for dodgy vibes...

Mkhize’s request to take special leave left President Cyril Ramaphosa reeling, party insiders say

State halts its R10bn long-term plan to fully treat acid...

The state is saddled with the burden of treating acid water and polluters are escaping the responsibility

press releases

Loading latest Press Releases…